OFFICIAL EXPLANATIONProject SC Butler: Sentence Correction (SC1)
THE PROMPTQuote:
After Exeter Recycling reported dismal earnings for the fifth straight quarter, its Chairman announced that the Board of Directors planned to fire the current executive managers, seen by many as unresponsive and incompetent,
and in replacing them, choose younger and more nimble managers.
• Strip and condense the sentence. After Exeter Recycling reported dismal earnings for the fifth straight quarter [XYZ], its Chairman announced that the Board of Directors planned to fire the current executive managers , seen by many as unresponsive and incompetent, and in replacing them, choose younger and more nimble managers.→ You could eliminate the "After XYZ" part, too. Sometimes it is safer to keep both clauses and condense the one that has little to do with the question.
→ The underlined portion tests only the material after "announced that," so strike
its Chairman announced that→ The phrase
seen by many as unresponsive and incompetent is an adjective (and an appositive) that describes
current managers and that does not help us answer the question.
The sentence, stripped:
After XYZ, the Board of Directors planned to fire the current executive managers, and in replacing them, choose younger and more nimble managers.• meaning?The Board of Directors planned to do two things:
(1) fire the current executive managers, and
(2) replace those current managers with younger managers.
• Issues?
→ Verb tenses (e.g., (C) uses
replaced whereas (D) uses
replace→
Parallelism. The Board planned to do two things.
In the nonunderlined portion we have
to fire. The verb in the second action must be parallel to either the infinitive
to fire or the bare infinitive,
fire. (The word
to "distributes" or "carries over" to the second verb.
• Split #1: ParallelismOption A pairs . . .
to fire and
in replacing. Those two verbs are not parallel.
→ Alternatively, you could argue that
choose is the second of the Board's two actions and that
to fire and
[to] choose are parallel.
→ That construction is rhetorically flabby and unnecessarily wordy: the section action is
to replace, not really
to choose.
→ Compare A to E. No contest. (E) wins.
In option B,
to fire and
to be replacing them are not quite parallel.
This pairing may not be an automatic thumbs down from GMAC, but it suspicious and the option is not as good as E.
ELIMINATE options A and B
• Split #2: Verb tense and nonsensical meaningIn option C, we are told that the Board planned (1) to fire the current managers and (2) [to] replaced them.
Replaced is the wrong verb tense. We the bare infinitive.
ELIMINATE C
• Split #3: Improper sentence constructionLet's put option D into the shortened sentence:
After XYZ, the Board of Directors planned to fire the current executive managers, [AND?] to replace them with younger and more nimble managers.Option D is missing a conjunction such as
and.
ELIMINATE D
By POE,
the answer is E.Option E is parallel:
. . . . the Board planned
to fire and [to]
replace COMMENTARYThese answers range from good to excellent. Kudos to those who explained.
Have a good weekend.