sivakumarm786
Papai21
sivakumarm786
Are all of the numbers in a set of 3 or more numbers equal?
St1. The sum of all 14 numbers in the set is 98.
that is the set can consist of 14 numbers all 7's so that sum is 98 or it can consist of 14 different numbers such that their sum is 14.
st 1 is not sufficient
St2. The sum of any 3 numbers in the set is 21.
Interesting. st 2 implies if we pick any 3 numbers from the set their sum is 21 which is possible only if all the numbers are equal to 7. the number of elements in the set can be >= 3 and is true of any number of elements.
Hence, st 2 is Sufficient.
Answer: B
Hi..
Can you please explain why St.2 is valid, incase the set has only 3 elements?
E.g. Set is {a,b,c} and the sum of the elements is 21 then a,b,c can have different values also.
They are only equal if the number of elements in the set is greater than 3.
Am I missing something?
Posted from my mobile deviceHi Papai21
Check the link given below the Question for explanation:
Quote:
Check RonTargetTestPrep post HERE
As Ron has brought out... set of only 3 numbers is
minimalist scenarioHi, I still have doubts about this question, in my opinion the answer is not B but actually C, like in the question you have linked.
The second statement claims that the sum of any 3 numbers in the set is 21. Hence, two possible solutions are the following:
- {1, 2, 18} --> The sum of any 3 numbers is 21 --> The numbers are not all equal
- {7, 7, 7, 7} --> The sum of any 3 numbers is 21 --> The number are all equal
Neither the stem nor the statement 2 deny the possibility to have a set of 3 numbers, thus the set {1, 2, 18} is allowed.
In conclusion, the statement 2 alone is not consistent.
Instead, considering the combination of statement 1 and 2, I will have a consistent answer.
Statement 1 claims that the set has 14 numbers, hence a 3 number set is not accepted.
Do I miss something?