Premise:The government of Farland continues to spend heavily to employ highly skilled attorneys as public prosecutors.
Conclusion : Gov. spending is unwarranted since public prosecutors often go a year or more without having to fight a single case in court because fewer than five percent of criminal cases are fought in the courts and the remaining cases are resolved outside of court through plea bargains.
We need to weaken the above argument.
A. The number of non-criminal cases fought in the courts has been increasing in Farland.
Incorrect. Even when the number of cases are increasing the fact still remains true that only fewer than five percent of criminal cases are fought in the courts and that public prosecutors often go a year or more without having to fight a single case in court .So this statement does not weaken the conclusion.
B. A plea bargain does not consume as much of a public prosecutor’s time as fighting a case in court does.
Incorrect. How much time it takes for a prosecutor to solve a case inside a court and outside a court is not of concern. Even if more time is taken to solve cases inside the court the fact remains true that only only fewer than five percent of criminal cases are fought in the courts.
C. Many criminal defendants currently forgo waging court battles, which are costly to the government, because they are convinced they will lose.
Correct. if the defendant forgoes court battles that are costly to government, it can mean that government spending in court cases has reduced because of this. So in a way, this choice suggests that by having highly skilled prosecutors, gov is saving on its spending.
D. The government department that public prosecutors work for is run more efficiently than many other departments.
Incorrect. Comparing efficiency of different gov. departments is not of any concern. This statement does not weaken the conclusion at all.
E. The proportion of criminal cases settled in plea bargains has increased over the last few years.
Incorrect. This choice strengthens the conclusion by stating that even when fewer than five percent of criminal cases are fought in the courts , the cases that are resolved outside of court through plea bargains are ever increasing.