Induvr09
More than the questions, I fail to understand the language the options use.
The language the options use is what makes boldface questions tricky. When you have such problems, simplify and paraphrase the sentence: break the sentence into its component parts, look up dictionaries, ask for help when needed. If you do this regularly, you will soon be able to understand the language without so much effort.
Quote:
For example:
-The first is a judgment that has been offered in support of the position that the argument calls into question; the second is that position.
-The first is an objection that has been raised against the position taken by the argument; the second is the position taken by the argument.
So, what's not clear here is the use of phrases like : position taken by the argument etc.
Your First ExampleThe first is a judgment that has been offered in support of the position that the argument calls into question;Judgment and Position both mean
Opinion or
Point of View or
Conclusion.
Calls into Question means
Disagrees With or
Cast Doubts On or simply
Weakens.
The position that the argument calls into question is an opinion about which the author has doubts. Basically it is an opinion (a conclusion) with which the argument disagrees. It is somebody else's conclusion, not the author's.
Something
offered in support of a position is obviously a strengthener or premise for a conclusion.
So the first boldface is support for a position (opinion) with which the author disagrees
The second boldface 'is
that position'. Which position? The position with which the author disagrees.
Your Second ExampleThe first is an objection that has been raised against the position taken by the argument; the second is the position taken by the argumentNow it should be clear that
position taken by the argument means the argument's conclusion.
So in this example, the second boldface is the argument's conclusion. The first boldface is an objection (weakener) that someone has raised against the argument's conclusion.
Point to NoteBoldface questions often contain multiple conclusions. The author's final conclusion is called
the argument's conclusion. In addition, there may be intermediate conclusions from the author. And there may be other conclusions that are not the author's conclusions but someone else's conclusions.
Hope this helped!
Posted from my mobile device