
I'm certainly not counting on an admit w/o an interview, ryguy. Columbia is going to be my "Hail Mary" application - I think it's a really solid school on paper and I'm already enthusiastic enough about it to consider applying ED. Hopefully, speaking to recent alumni (after their "rah rah, my b-school is the best" fervor has faded a bit) will give me a better sense of the pluses and minuses and I can determine how well I really fit into Columbia's culture. That's one reason I prefer chasing down alumni as opposed to incoming students or current students - not to say that the incoming/current students aren't a fantastic resource, I just find the alumni to be a bit more objective and pragmatic in their assessment of their in- and post-b school experiences.
Thanks for the suggestions. Hopefully you will be able to woo Mme. Columbia this time