formerlyknownas
bapp
I applied in R2 this year and got dinged. I have interviewed at another comparable school, so all is not lost.
I have a question to folks who have interviewed or are going to HBS this year - who all of you used an admission consultant?
I used a well known admission consultant, but soon I realized how generic their advice is. I did not find it helped the process for me at all, it ended up consuming more of my time with no real value. Even though my essays came out fine, I now think application would have been better if it was not touched by the consultant. Any one else here who got in and thinks the same?
I used a well known consultant for interview prep and I won't give any more details. I would leave it at that.
I will tell you that for what I got, the fee charged was way too much. I didn't leave the mock interview feeling better prepared. And consultant spent too much time trying to put words in my mouth rather than let me find the words that are in me. I am not even sure that the consultant read my application cover to cover as happens in a HBS interview. Overall, I was not too happy.
As you can see from R1 admits, you don't need a consultant to get into HBS or any other school.
My experience w/ admission consultants was a positive one. I could be mistaken, but it seems that many of you only worked with a consultant during the months leading up to your app/interview. I purchased a package from one of the major companies during early 2010, and worked with a primary consultant for a solid year fine tuning my profile and preparing my applications. In many respects, my consultant took on the role of a professional coach. While I did the legwork and writing, etc, my consultant/coach served as a constant balancing force w/ suggestions and brainstorming exercises that helped me get back on track when I got stuck in a rut or had difficulty articulating my story. Personally, I consider the experience similiar to that of competitive athletes who work with a coach/mentor who is well versed in the fundamentals and who will notice things that you would otherwise miss. And then there is of course the additional value added that stems from their familiarity with particular adcoms, etc.
I was admitted to Sloan during round 1, interviewed and am waiting to hear back from HBS during round 2, and received an interview invite from NYU Stern that I have not yet attended. While I can only speculate what my success rate would look like if I had not hired a consultant, I firmly believe that it was well worth the investment. Fingers crossed to see what happens next Tuesday, though.
This was just my experience, but thought I would share to illustrate that there can be value in hiring consultants.
All the best -