City Controller: 63% of our residents voted to approve the

Question

City Controller : 63% of our residents voted to approve the developer's request to build a national chain hotel on the site of the old consignment store. The hotel will increase our revenue base and, therefore, provide more money for schools and community services.

Mayor : But our recent survey showed that the most important reason people want to live here is our small-town feel resulting from the local ownership of the vast majority of businesses.

What is the best explanation for the apparent contradiction in opinions cited by the controller and the mayor?

(A) Most people believe having a small-town feel is more important than having quality schools. 
(B) A locally-owned business might be able to generate as much revenue as a well-known hotel chain. 
(C) The recent survey did not ask about preferences for a chain hotel versus a locally-owned bed and breakfast.
(D) An increase in the town's revenue base may not result in additional money for the schools. 
(E) The recent survey cited by the mayor polled people who are considering moving to the town.

methevoid · Accepted Answer

Most Necessary here is to understand what contradiction is to be solved? - 
CC -  Our residents  say Hotel Chain is Good.

M - Recent survey said people want to live here because of small town feel.

The two are talking about 2 different surveys, we have to find out how?

(A) What most people believe does not help to solve the contradiction here. 
(B) Also does not help us to solve any contradiction, it just raises doubt over CC's statement. 
(C) Shell GAME Answer - It confuses us by putting -locally-owned bed & breakfast - when Mayor talks only about local ownership, not B & B.
(D) Contradicts just the statement of CC, does not help to answer the contradiction between CC & Mayor's statement.
 (E) Bingo!!! IF the Survey by Mayor is taken by people who are yet not residents of the city, but only are considering to move to the city then it solves wat the CC and Mayor are talking about.

Bunuel · Answer

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION

The majority of residents voted to allow a national chain to build a hotel in town. This appears to contradict the mayor's claim that a recent survey showed most people want to live in the town because of the locally-owned businesses. In order to answer the question, we need an additional piece of information which explains away, or resolves, this apparent contradiction.

(A) If people rank a small-town feel higher in importance than quality schools, then this fact would still contradict the combination of the vote and the survey response.

(B) If a locally-owned business could generate the same amount of revenue as the national hotel, then this fact would still contradict the combination of the vote and the survey response.

(C) This does not address why the residents voted to approve the hotel while survey respondents said they preferred locally-owned businesses.

(D) This appears to contradict the reason given for residents voting to approve the hotel but does not do so in a way that explains the discrepancy with the survey respondents.

(E) CORRECT.  If the survey respondents were not actually residents of the town, this explains why the residents of the town voted in a way that does not reflect the results of the survey.

rthothad · Answer

I will go with E.
The contradiction is because the City Controller is referring to local residents but the Mayor is referring to a survey whose participants could be non-residents.

shubham2312 · Answer

it would be great help if someone will help me in breaking down question stem 
i am able to understand argument but not been able to find out what kind of answer choice we are supposed to find

something due to which i selected many wrong choices in mock also

samusa · Answer

This question is a resolve the paradox type question.We have to find out the choice that proves that both the contradictory opinions can be true at the same time. E does exactly that by telling us that different people were polled in the survey quoted by the Mayor. Different set of people can have different opinions.

Hope the above helps!! I do not mind Kudos ... :-D

shubham2312 · Answer

thanks a lot buddy 
i face difficulty whenever a question stem is framed in a different manner 
i would have attempted this question if it was mentioned that it a resolve the paradox kind of question

what is the best way to equip myself with different kind of question stem?
thanks once again

samusa · Answer

The answer to your question is ONE word- PRACTICE .... :wink:

As we practice more , we get better with each question. It takes time but it does happen... Best of Luck...

mvictor · Answer

I picked E, and this is my reasoning:
CC - says 63% of residents approve construction of new hotel.
mayor - people want to live here because of some reason.

what could be the discrepancy here? what if the survey of the mayor was not polled on people who actually reside there? Note that it is not directly implied that THOSE people who responded to city controller's poll answered in the same poll conducted by mayor.

What is the best explanation for the apparent contradiction in opinions cited by the controller and the mayor?

A. Most people believe having a small-town feel is more important than having quality schools. 
might be, or might be not, there is no information that would make us believe that such is the case.

B. A locally-owned business might be able to generate as much revenue as a well-known hotel chain. 
might, or might not. this is not really important to us.

C. The recent survey did not ask about preferences for a chain hotel versus a locally-owned bed and breakfast.
this is out of scope. compares CH vs. locally-owned bed and breakfast.

D. An increase in the town's revenue base may not result in additional money for the schools. 
still doesn't explain the paradox presented in the argument.

E. The recent survey cited by the mayor polled people who are considering moving to the town.
aha, if people who responded in CC's questionnaire were residents, but people who responded to mayor's questionnaire were people who are not, then we have the paradox solved.

E so far is the best answer.

jinwshin · Answer

The passage is teliing us that the survey had been conducted toward 63% of our "residents"

Doesn''t the choice (E) refuting the stated fact?

I heard that official answers should not attack the given facts, as the choice (E) does.

IMO, choice (E) fails to explain the discrepancy, but it actually changes the whole meaning of the passage.

MBAB123 · Answer

Choice E talks about the survey cited by the Mayor, not the controller. And the mayor does not mention anywhere that the survey that he conducted was limited to or related to the city's residents.

carlosvisbal88 · Answer

Let's try to tackle this question step by step.

City Controler Survey
 63% Ppl  ---> approved national hotel chain (NHC) because revenue increase base, so it can provide more money to schools and CS.

Mayor
New Survey: 
 People  prefer to live in a small town with local ownership of  vast mayority  of business.

So we have to try to solve the contradiction between both statements.

We should ask ourselves: What have to be true on the statements so both city controller and mayor have different interpretation of surveys? Why people change view?

Things that comes into my mind before start looking the answers choice:
People that were polled are different. DIFFERENT GROUPS. When the question is about surveys, we should look if polled groups are the same.
There is more info on the mayor's survey that we don't know. For instance, that people prefer local ownership but still comfortable with non local ownership.
Although Ppl prefer local ownership of  vast mayority of business , the positive impact in the revenue is preferred over having business with local ownership.

Now that we thought on some possible explanations, we can go through each answer and eliminate one by one, from WRONG to RIGHT:
 (A) Most people believe having a small-town feel is more important than having quality schools. 
This could be supporting the fact that the majority of people in the city controller's survey was against of the new hotel. Why the majority voted in favor in the first place?. ELIMINATE

(B) A locally-owned business might be able to generate as much revenue as a well-known hotel chain. 
This statement is comparing a locally own business with the hotel chain, but does not explain why the people first approved to build the hotel. If this were the case, people should voted against the hotel's proposal. ELIMINATE.

( C) The recent survey did not ask about preferences for a chain hotel versus a locally-owned bed and breakfast. 
If people in the  recent survey  were asked NCH vs LOH, the result of the recent survey would be the same because it says that people prefer to live in a small town resulting from local ownership. This statement wouldn't affect the conclusion of the mayor, and doesn't help to explain the contradiction. Moreover, we don't know anything about why they said yes in first place. ELIMINATE

(D) An increase in the town's revenue base may not result in additional money for the schools. 
This is attacking the premise of the CC, we shouldn't look to attack the premise but to try to explain the contradiction. Furthermore, if the people think that an increase in revenue won't result in additional money for the school, why the approved it in the first place? Does not explain the contradiction. ELIMINATE.

(E) The recent survey cited by the mayor polled people who are considering moving to the town. 
This is what we were looking for. There are two different groups in the surveys. Polling different people explains different results.

vic231 · Answer

KarishmaB   AndrewN

Need help with choice E. Mayor mentions that the reason people  WANT TO LIVE HERE  is our small-town feel. Those who are already residents of the town would not be WANTING TO LIVE HERE, it must refer to folks who are not residents of the town at the moment but want to live in that town. 
Choice E then mentions that the mayor polled non-residents who are considering moving to the town, basically they are referring to the same group of people.
This should not resolve the contradiction.

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

City Controller: 63% of our residents voted to approve the

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

City Controller: 63% of our residents voted to approve the

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards