Even in the midst of its resurgence as a vital tradition, many sociol

Question

Even in the midst of its resurgence as a vital
tradition, many sociologists have viewed the current
form of the powwow, a ceremonial gathering of native
Americans, as a sign that tribal culture is in decline.
 (5)  Focusing on the dances and rituals that have recently
come to be shared by most tribes, they suggest that an
intertribal movement is now in ascension and claim the
inevitable outcome of this tendency is the eventual
dissolution of tribes and the complete assimilation of
 (10)  native Americans into Euroamerican society.
Proponents of this “Pan-Indian” theory point to the
greater frequency of travel and communication
between reservations, the greater urbanization of native
Americans, and, most recently, their increasing
 (15)  politicization in response to common grievances as the
chief causes of the shift toward intertribalism.

Indeed, the rapid diffusion of dance styles, outfits,
and songs from one reservation to another offers
compelling evidence that intertribalism has been
 (20)  increasing. However, these sociologists have failed to
note the concurrent revitalization of many traditions
unique to individual tribes. Among the Lakota, for
instance, the Sun Dance was revived, after a forty-year
hiatus, during the 1950’s. Similarly, the Black Legging
 (25)  Society of the Kiowa and the Hethuska Society of the
Ponca—both traditional groups within their respective
tribes—have gained new popularity. Obviously, a more
complex societal shift is taking place than the theory of
Pan-Indianism can account for.

(30)  An examination of the theory’s underpinnings may
be critical at this point, especially given that native
Americans themselves chafe most against the Pan
Indian classification. Like other assimilationist theories
with which it is associated, the Pan-Indian view is
 (35)  predicated upon an a priori assumption about the
nature of cultural contact: that upon contact minority
societies immediately begin to succumb in every
respect—biologically, linguistically, and culturally—to
the majority society. However, there is no evidence
 (40)  that this is happening to native American groups.

Yet the fact remains that intertribal activities are a
major facet of native American culture today. Certain
dances at powwows, for instance, are announced as
intertribal, other as traditional. Likewise, speeches
 (45)  given at the beginnings of powwows are often
delivered in English, while the prayer that follows is
usually spoken in a native language. Cultural
borrowing is, of course, old news. What is important to
note is the conscious distinction native Americans
 (50)  make between tribal and intertribal tendencies.

Tribalism, although greatly altered by modern
history, remains a potent force among native
Americans: It forms a basis for tribal identity, and
aligns music and dance with other social and cultural
 (55)  activities important to individual tribes. Intertribal
activities, on the other hand, reinforce native American
identity along a broader front, where this identity is
directly threatened by outside influences.
    1 
 1. Which one of the following best summarizes the main idea of the passage?

(A) Despite the fact that sociologists have only recently begun to understand its importance, intertribalism has always been an influential factor in native American culture.
(B) Native Americans are currently struggling with an identity crisis caused primarily by the two competing forces of tribalism and intertribalism.
(C) The recent growth of intertribalism is unlikely to eliminate tribalism because the two forces do not oppose one another but instead reinforce distinct elements of native American identity.
(D) The tendency toward intertribalism, although prevalent within native American culture, has had a minimal effect on the way native Americans interact with the broader community around them.
(E) Despite the recent revival of many native American tribal traditions, the recent trend toward intertribalism is likely to erode cultural differences among the various native American tribes.

2 
 2. The author most likely states that “cultural borrowing is, of course, old news” (lines 47–48) primarily to

(A) acknowledge that in itself the existence of intertribal tendencies at powwows is unsurprising
(B) suggest that native Americans’ use of English in powwows should be accepted as unavoidable
(C) argue that the deliberate distinction of intertribal and traditional dances is not a recent development
(D) suggest that the recent increase in intertribal activity is the result of native Americans
(E) indicate that the powwow itself could have originated by combining practices drawn from both native and non-native American cultures

3 
 3. The author of the passage would most likely agree with which one of the following assertions?

(A) Though some believe the current form of the powwow signals the decline of tribal culture, the powwow contains elements that indicate the continuing strength of tribalism.
(B) The logical outcome of the recent increase in intertribal activity is the eventual disappearance of tribal culture.
(C) Native Americans who participate in both tribal and intertribal activities usually base their identities on intertribal rather than tribal affiliations.
(D) The conclusions of some sociologists about the health of native American cultures show that these sociologists are in fact biased against such cultures.
(E) Until it is balanced by revitalization of tribal customs, intertribalism will continue to weaken the native American sense of identity.

4 
 4. The primary function of the third paragraph is to

(A) search for evidence to corroborate the basic assumption of the theory of Pan-Indianism
(B) demonstrate the incorrectness of the theory of Pan-Indianism by pointing out that native American groups themselves disagree with the theory
(C) explain the origin of the theory of PanIndianism by showing how it evolved from other assimilationist theories
(D) examine several assimilationist theories in order to demonstrate that they rest on a common assumption 
(E) criticize the theory of Pan-Indianism by pointing out that it rests upon an assumption for which there is no supporting evidence

5 
 5. Which one of the following most accurately describes the author’s attitude toward the theory of PanIndianism?

(A) critical of its tendency to attribute political motives to cultural practices
(B) discomfort at its negative characterization of cultural borrowing by native Americans
(C) hopeful about its chances for preserving tribal culture
(D) offended by its claim that assimilation is a desirable consequence of cultural contact
(E) skeptical that it is a complete explanation of recent changes in native American society

6 
 6. With which one of the following statements would the author of the passage be most likely to agree?

(A) The resurgence of the powwow is a sign that native American customs are beginning to have an important influence on Euroamerican society.
(B) Although native Americans draw conscious distinctions between tribal and intertribal activities, there is no difference in how the two types of activity actually function within the context of native American society.
(C) Without intertribal activities, it would be more difficult for native Americans to maintain the cultural differences between native American and Euroamerican society.
(D) The powwow was recently revived, after an extended hiatus, in order to strengthen native Americans’ sense of ethnic identity.
(E) The degree of urbanization, intertribal communication, and politicization among native Americans has been exaggerated by proponents of the theory of Pan-Indianism.

7 
 7. Which one of the following situations most clearly illustrates the phenomenon of intertribalism, as that phenomenon is described in the passage?

(A) a native American tribe in which a number of powerful societies attempt to prevent the revival of a traditional dance
(B) a native American tribe whose members attempt to learn the native languages of several other tribes
(C) a native American tribe whose members attempt to form a political organization in order to redress several grievances important to that tribe
(D) a native American tribe in which a significant percentage of the members have forsaken their tribal identity and become assimilated into Euroamerican society
(E) a native American tribe whose members often travel to other parts of the reservation in order to visit friends and relatives

8 
 8. In the passage, the author is primarily concerned with doing which one of the following?

(A) identifying an assumption common to various assimilationist theories and then criticizing these theories by showing this assumption to be false
(B) arguing that the recent revival of a number of tribal practices shows sociologists are mistaken in believing intertribalism to be a potent force among native American societies
(C) questioning the belief that native American societies will eventually be assimilated into Euroamerican society by arguing that intertribalism helps strengthen native American identity
(D) showing how the recent resurgence of tribal activities is a deliberate attempt to counteract the growing influence of intertribalism
(E) proposing an explanation of why the ascension of intertribalism could result in the eventual dissolution of tribes and complete assimilation of native American into Euroamerican society

Source:   LSAT Official PrepTest 25   
 Difficulty Level:   650

RC Butler 2021  -  Practice Two RC Questions Everyday.   
Passage # 222 Date: 04-Jun-2021
 This question is a part of RC Butler 2021 .  Click here for Details

ballest127 · Answer

Hi experts,

Could you please post OE of Q6 and Q7?
These two questions are really hard.

Thank you.

Saasingh · Answer

Hey,

For Q6 , please refer to the below lines at the end of passage:
Intertribal activities, on the other hand, reinforce native American identity along a broader front, where this identity is directly threatened by outside influences.

Option C restates this in a different language. Author believes that inter tribalism does not restrict tribalism but instead reinforces it. So option C directly implies.

Also, A,B,D,E cannot be inferred from any part of the passage.

For Q7 , I could understand from the passage that inter tribalism = mix of tribes from different cultures ("assimiliation", "diffusion of dance styles, outfits, and songs from one reservation to another").
Thus, all options except B talk about things happening within the same tribe. Only option B talks about one tribe learning things about "other tribe".

Hope it helps.

Regards,
Saakhi

ShubhamPatil · Answer

Please help me with Q2.
I got confused between option A and C.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

(C)  misinterprets  “old news”  to mean  “not a recent development,”  but that makes no sense: Nothing else in the paragraph deals with a contrast between the recent and the familiar. Everything in  paragraph 4  deals solely with phenomena happening in native American culture today. As  (A)  implies,  “old news”  really means  “nothing surprising; nothing to jump out of your chair about.”   C  is wrong.

PrachiMaloo · Answer

Can anyone explain in brief questions 2 and 8?

kntombat · Answer

PrachiMaloo , I think the answer to question 2 can be found right above your original post.

GMATNinja , can you help us out with question 8 please.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

2. The author most likely states that “cultural borrowing is, of course, old news” (lines 47–48) primarily to

Difficulty Level:   600

Explanation

This potentially very tricky “purpose of a detail”/Logic question becomes easier when you use the Keywords provided, and think about overall author purpose and structure.  Paragraph 3  ends by declaring that a key element of the intertribalism theory is missing: Tribes are not being assimilated wholesale into the majority culture.  Paragraph 4  begins with  “Yet the fact remains,”  a strong Contrast signal, which the author uses to announce a list of evidence for intertribalism. And to help us he provides two familiar Example signals:  “for instance”  introduces the first evidence of intertribalism at powwows, and  “Likewise”  introduces the second. So far so good.

Next comes the sentence in question. Its phrase  “of course”  serves the same purpose as  “naturally”  or  “granted” —that is, it grants a point the author wants to take off the table, so that he can make the point he truly wants to make.  “Granted,”  he’s saying,  “the kind of cultural borrowing I’ve just described is old news. But!...”  And while he doesn’t say  “But”  we can mentally insert that Contrast Keyword and see the connection to the next sentence:  “But what IS news—what is important—is that the native Americans are consciously aware of it. They’re making use of intertribalism to serve a purpose” —a purpose that  Paragraph 5  will describe. This analysis makes  (A)  the only logical choice: The sentence in question  “acknowledges”  that the evidence for intertribalism exists, but that evidence is  “unsurprising”  and hence doesn’t undercut the author’s main thesis.

(B)  is tempting if you simply translate  “of course”  into  “unavoidable.”  But  (B)  distorts the author’s purpose, which is to grant that counterevidence does exist, not to argue that a single piece of evidence  “has to be accepted.” (B)  is also too narrow: It focuses merely on the spoken-English detail in  lines 44-47 —the  “likewise”  sentence—whereas  “Cultural borrowings”  relates to both pieces of evidence starting at  line 42.

(C)  misinterprets  “old news”  to mean  “not a recent development,”  but that makes no sense: Nothing else in the paragraph deals with a contrast between the recent and the familiar. Everything in  paragraph 4  deals solely with phenomena happening in native American culture today. As  (A)  implies,  “old news”  really means  “nothing surprising; nothing to jump out of your chair about.”

(D) , like  (C) , errs in implying that there’s something significant in the  “recentness”  of intertribal tendencies. More to the point,  (D)  merely repeats the essence of the one detail in  lines 44-47  (using English at powwows) without relating at all to what  lines 47-48  are saying.

(E)  focuses on the origin of the powwow—something that goes way back in history, far beyond the scope of anything in this passage. From  lines 2-3  we know that the author’s scope is  “the current form of the powwow.”

Answer: A

8. In the passage, the author is primarily concerned with doing which one of the following?

Difficulty Level:   600

Explanation

Here, you might have pre-phrased the author’s main concern as  “rebutting the idea that intertribalism is a bad thing.”  Even a pre-phrasing that loose should lead you to  (C).  The  “belief” (C)  mentions is the one held by the sociologists, that  “Pan-Indianism”  must result from today’s intertribal tendencies. The author believes, as we’ve seen in question after question, that intertribalism has a salutary effect, and  (C)  picks up on that.

(A)  The author explores this  “assumption”  in the context of one theory only,  “PanIndianism.”  And true, it is shown to be false, but all of that happens in  Paragraph 3  only. There’s a lot more going on in the rest of the passage.

(B)  To the author, what sociologists are mistaken about is whether today’s intertribalism signals a general Pan-Indian tendency that will wipe out native American identity altogether. Contrary to  (B) , the author agrees that intertribalism is potent today. He and the sociologists simply disagree on its meaning.

(D)  has no basis in the text. We are never told precisely why such tribal activities as the powwow are enjoying a revival. Certainly there’s no evidence that native Americans are using the powwow or anything else in a conscious effort to combat intertribalism; indeed, the end of  paragraph 4  suggests that they are quite aware of the difference between tribalism and intertribalism and are using each for positive ends.

(E)  is the purpose that would be served should the sociologists of  paragraph 1  write a 60+ line passage defending their theory of  “Pan-Indianism.”  Since it is not they, but one of their staunch opponents, who has written the passage in question,  (E)  couldn’t be more off.

Answer: C

A. · Answer

Please share explanation of question 5

JSAbhishek · Answer

Can someone explain the answer for Q5 and Q6?

Even in the midst of its resurgence as a vital tradition, many sociol

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Even in the midst of its resurgence as a vital tradition, many sociol

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards