Bunuel wrote:
Folic acid is a nutrient present in leafy vegetables and some other foods. In the blood, folic acid inhibits the formation of substances found in arterial blockages that commonly cause heart attacks. Moreover, in a long-term study of 10,000 individuals, the subgroup with the highest blood levels of folic acid had fewer heart attacks than the subgroup with the lowest levels. Therefore, a decrease in dietary folic acid will increase the risk of a heart attack.
Which of the following, if true, would most strengthen the argument?
A. Many of the people who had heart attacks during the study were eating a high-fat diet, which is known to contribute to the formation of arterial blockages.
B. Folic acid cannot be synthesized or stored by the body.
C. Arterial blockages usually take years to develop.
D. The group that had the fewest heart attacks also had the best exercise habits.
E. The subjects in the study were tested for folic acid levels most frequently in the first two years of the study.
Premises:Folic acid is a nutrient present in leafy vegetables and some other foods.
It inhibits the formation of substances found in arterial blockages that cause heart attacks.
In a study, people with the highest blood levels of folic acid had fewer heart attacks than those with the lowest levels.
Conclusion: A decrease in dietary folic acid will increase the risk of a heart attack.
Important to note here before you proceed - the conclusion says "a decrease in
dietary folic acid will increase the risk of a heart attack." It doesn't say "a decrease in folic acid will increase the risk of a heart attack." which is what we would have expected.
What would strengthen this claim? We need to strengthen that if one does not consume folic acid in food, one's risk of heart attack increases.
A. Many of the people who had heart attacks during the study were eating a high-fat diet, which is known to contribute to the formation of arterial blockages.This option makes us doubt the study that the author is using to support his statement. It says that the reason for heart attack in those people was different. It certainly does not strengthen the conclusion about the impact of folic acid.
B. Folic acid cannot be synthesized or stored by the body.This is interesting. It tells us that folic acid cannot be created or stored by the body. This means that one must consume dietary folic acid. It strengthens the "dietary" part of the claim.
C. Arterial blockages usually take years to develop.Irrelevant.
D. The group that had the fewest heart attacks also had the best exercise habits.Again, this makes us doubt the study that the author is using to support his statement. It says that the reason for fewer heart attacks in those people was exercise, not folic acid. Hence it doesn't strengthen the conclusion.
E. The subjects in the study were tested for folic acid levels most frequently in the first two years of the study.Frequency of testing is irrelevant.
Answer (B)