Bunuel wrote:
In professional boxing matches, boxers compete against other boxers within the same weight class, and these competitions sometimes result in a boxer giving the opposing boxer a head injury. Records show that, of all weight classes, heavyweight boxers suffer from the highest rate of head injuries per match, a result attributed to the fact that they have the largest muscle mass of all weight classes. Records also show that lightweight boxers have the lowest muscle mass of all weight classes.
If the above statements are true, which of the following statements must also be true?
A. Of all weight classes, lightweight boxers have the lowest rate of head injuries per match.
B. Of all weight classes, heavyweight boxers cause the highest rate of head injuries to opponents per match.
C. It is more dangerous to belong to the heavyweight boxing class than to other classes.
D. On average, heavyweight boxers suffer from more head injuries per year than do boxers of other weight classes.
E. Larger muscle mass enables boxers to hit harder, causing head injury.
Explanation
We’ll go for ALTERNATIVE because we are asked to assess which answer choice must be true.(A) We have no information on the class with the lowest rate, only on that with the highest, so (A) does not HAVE to be true. Note that while the passage does state that the high rate of head injuries per match in the heavyweight class is “attributed” to muscle mass, it does not tell us that this is a strictly linear correlation: we do not know whether less muscle mass always means fewer head injuries, so we cannot conclude anything about the class with the lowest rate.
(B) The passage tells us that boxers compete against
boxers in the same weight category. Therefore, the boxers who caused heavyweight boxers to have the highest rate of head injuries per match were other heavyweight boxers! This must be true and is the correct answer. For practice, let’s examine the others.
(C) We do not have information about all sources of danger and cannot say how head injuries compare with everything else.
(D) Without information on the number of matches played per year, we cannot calculate the number of head injuries per year.
(E) is a statement that is perhaps reasonable to
infer from the given passage, but does not necessarily
derive from it. In other words, it is not necessarily true—maybe larger muscle mass makes hits to the body less effective, so the boxers aim more for the head.