| Critical Reasoning Butler: January 2025 |
| January 29 | CR 1 | CR 2 |
___________________________
CR 1 Candidate: Today’s voters expect their government to be accountable. Virtually, every improvement in government’s accountability inspires a new round of demands for greater accountability. If a politician is satisfied with the government’s current level of accountability, that politician will soon find that the constituents are not. As your representative in parliament, meeting your demands for accountability will be my goal!
Which of the following must be true on the basis of the statements above?
A. The candidate’s competitors will succeed in attracting voters only if those competitors adopt the candidate’s goals as their own.
B. The candidate’s goal is possible to meet, only if it is possible to continue the current advances in government accountability.
C. A politician who fails to accurately anticipate the demands of the constituents is certain to fail in advancing government accountability.
D. If a politician becomes satisfied with the accountability that the government displays, the government accountability will decline.
E. The candidate’s constituents are currently satisfied with the accountability displayed by the government.
___________________________
CR 2 The World Energy Council maintains ranking of nations, detailing which country’s citizens are the most and least energy conscious by measuring the amount of electricity consumed per every 100 citizens.
Of the following, each statement, if true, would serve as a logical objection to using the council’s ranking as a representation of the energy consciousness of citizens in each nation EXCEPT:
A. The refrigeration of food consumes significantly less electricity in countries with a temperate or arctic climate than it does in countries with a tropical climate.
B. Some countries have hundreds of millions of citizens and some barely have a few millions.
C. The average citizen in developed nations can afford to purchase more energy-efficient technology than can citizens of less developed nations.
D. Due to low electricity production, many developing countries regularly shut down residential electrical supply for as long as a few hours every day for several months in a year.
E. The power grids of some countries are in poor shape and thus waste more electricity than do power grids of other countries.