Hoping to increase his company's market share, the CEO of QuikFashion

Question

Hoping to increase his company's market share, the CEO of QuikFashion has decided to hold a month-long sale in which all of the clothing in QuikFashion's stores will be discounted by at least 50 percent. Although this discount will mean that the company is selling clothing at cost, the CEO hopes that this broadly advertised sale will attract repeat buyers to QuikFashion, who will return to buy clothing at full price after the month of sales.

In assessing the CEO's ability to achieve his goals with this plan, it would be most useful to know which of the following?

A. Whether following a different plan might allow QuikFashion to maintain its current market share but increase profits. 
 B. Whether QuikFashion can cut the cost of production sufficiently to still make profits from its discounted clothing. 
 C. Whether some items of clothing will be discounted more than others. 
 D. Whether a sale lasting a different length of time would prove more profitable in the long run. 
 E. Whether QuikFashion's competitors would respond by discounting their own clothing.

This is a  CR Butler Question

Check the links to other Butler Projects:

Data Sufficiency Butler  
  Problem Solving Butler  
  Sentence Correction Butler  
  Reading Comprehension Butler  
  Integrated Reasoning Butler

dkpkoti · Answer

We need to find an option that takes into consideration any factor that potentially weaken the plan of increasing the market share plan. So for me it is E - as Understanding how competitors react to the sale is crucial. If competitors also lower their prices significantly, it could decrease QuikFashion's market share and limit the effectiveness of the sale in attracting repeat customers.

Krunaal · Answer

(A) This option considers whether another plan might work better for profitability, but it doesn't directly address the CEO's specific goal of increasing market share through discounted sales.  Incorrect , as it is not focused on the core issue of how the discount plan would affect future customer behavior.

(B) While it’s important to consider profitability, the CEO has already stated that the company will be selling at cost during the sale. The CEO’s goal is not immediate profits, but to attract repeat customers.  Incorrect , as profitability during the sale is not the focus.

(C) This may influence the sales of particular items, but it doesn't address the overall strategy of increasing market share and attracting repeat customers.  Incorrect , as it doesn't get to the heart of the long-term goal.

(D) This option considers the duration of the sale, but it focuses on profitability rather than the potential to build repeat customers and market share.  Incorrect , as the primary goal is not about immediate profit but long-term customer retention.

(E) This is critical to the CEO's plan. If competitors respond with similar or better discounts, QuikFashion may not succeed in attracting more customers or increasing market share, as customers could simply go to other stores with equivalent discounts.  Correct , as understanding how competitors will react is key to determining if the strategy can actually attract new customers and keep them coming back.

Answer E.

Nikhil17bhatt · Answer

IMO E

To assess the CEO's ability to achieve his goals with the plan of holding a month-long sale with at least a 50 percent discount, it is important to consider factors that could influence the success of attracting repeat buyers who will return to purchase clothing at full price after the sale ends.

Let's analyze each option:

(A) Whether following a different plan might allow QuikFashion to maintain its current market share but increase profits.
Explanation: This option considers alternative strategies that might be more profitable.
Why it's not the most useful: While exploring alternative plans could be beneficial, it does not directly assess the likelihood of the current plan achieving the CEO's specific goal of attracting repeat buyers.
(B) Whether QuikFashion can cut the cost of production sufficiently to still make profits from its discounted clothing.
Explanation: This option considers whether the company can reduce production costs to make a profit even with the discount.
Why it's not the most useful: The CEO's plan already assumes selling at cost, so the focus is on attracting repeat buyers rather than making immediate profits from the sale. This option does not address the core goal of the plan.
(C) Whether some items of clothing will be discounted more than others.
Explanation: This option considers the variability in discount rates across different items.
Why it's not the most useful: While varying discounts might influence buying behavior, it does not directly address the overall effectiveness of the sale in attracting repeat buyers who will return at full price.
(D) Whether a sale lasting a different length of time would prove more profitable in the long run.
Explanation: This option considers the impact of the sale duration on long-term profitability.
Why it's not the most useful: The focus of the CEO's plan is on attracting repeat buyers, not necessarily on the duration of the sale. This option does not directly assess the likelihood of achieving the CEO's goal.
(E) Whether QuikFashion's competitors would respond by discounting their own clothing.
Explanation: This option considers the potential competitive response to QuikFashion's sale.
Why it's the most useful: If competitors also discount their clothing, it could undermine QuikFashion's ability to attract repeat buyers, as customers might simply take advantage of the discounts across multiple stores without developing loyalty to QuikFashion. Understanding the competitive landscape is crucial to assessing whether the CEO's plan will successfully attract repeat buyers who will return at full price.
Summary:
(A), (B), (C), and (D) do not directly address the likelihood of achieving the CEO's specific goal of attracting repeat buyers who will return at full price.
(E) is the most useful because it directly considers the competitive response, which could significantly impact the effectiveness of the CEO's plan in attracting and retaining repeat buyers.
Thus, the correct answer is (E) Whether QuikFashion's competitors would respond by discounting their own clothing.

prantorboni · Answer

We need to identify an option that accounts for any factors that could undermine the strategy to increase market share. E is the best choice because if competitors also significantly cut their prices, it could harm QuikFashion's market share and reduce the sale's ability to draw in repeat customers.

Answer: E

Answer: E

Bunuel · Answer

Magoosh Official Explanation:

Evaluating this situation, we have a company that is willing to lose potential short-term profits in the hopes of creating a greater market share in the long-term. Note that the terms of the argument are not focused on long-term PROFITS, per se, but rather on market share. (E) brings up the issue of QuikFashion’s competitors, for even if QuikFashion earned more money in both the short term and long term, this would not help the company achieve its goal of a greater market share if its competitors also did so. Whatever competitive edge QuikFashion was hoping to gain by discounting its own products would likely be neutralized when its competitors made the same move.

(A) ignores the market-share goal and focuses exclusively on profits, which are not, in this scenario, the CEO’s ultimate goal as stated by the stimulus.

The stimulus has told us that the company will essentially be selling clothing at cost during the sales, foregoing short-term profits for long-term market share growth. The creation of profits during the short-term sale (B) is thus not a serious issue in this scenario.

The discount is, generally, not as important as what the CEO hopes that proposed discount will do in the long term. Therefore, the discount applied to different products is not of concern in evaluating the strategy’s effectiveness on the whole (C).

While (D) finally returns us to the question of short term versus long term, it also erroneously focuses on profits, which are not the main terms with which this CEO is currently concerned.

Answer = (E)

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot:

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

This post was generated automatically.

Hoping to increase his company's market share, the CEO of QuikFashion

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

Hoping to increase his company's market share, the CEO of QuikFashion

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards