Rw27 wrote:

Can anyone please highlight the difference between the question under discussion and this question

https://gmatclub.com/forum/triangle-abc ... 32573.html How do we distinguish between the two?

The main difference is the constraints.

In this question you are free to choose any 3 points on the plane (and then have to remove colinearities).

This means you choose 3 x coordinates and 3 y coordinates.

So the calculation is 9C3 - colinearities.

Colinearities in this problem are when all three points are on the same line and as explained above there are 8 such points.

In the question you linked to the constraints are much stronger:

Essentially, once you choose points A and C then point B is fixed.

So you're only choosing 2 x coordinates and 2 y coordinates.

You can do this as explained in the link - 6C1 * 11C1 * 5C1 * 10C1 = 3300

You can also calculate 66*(65-colinearities) = 66*50 = 3300

Colinearities in this problem are when points A and C are on the same line and there are 15 such options (10 horizontal, 5 vertical)

If all this is confusing, the bottom line is that the constraints are the main difference - are you choosing 3 points or 2?

Good luck!

_________________

David

Senior tutor at examPAL

Signup for a free GMAT course

We won some awards:

Save up to $250 on examPAL packages (special for GMAT Club members)