xenok wrote:
I do have a few ideas that aren't completely thought out yet, but I want to throw it out there so maybe it can start some brainstorming.
1) Allow cross-posting between the two forums, that way good threads are kept common between both forums. It will also allow easier and more interaction between the posters in both forums. I don't know if this is technically feasible, but it's an old trick from my newsgroup days.
2) Create a separate forum for general application advice, then have separate forums for regions. I see two issues with this. First, it's hard to enforce the rule that people HAVE to post general advice in one forum and discuss school specific issues in another. Second, it doesn't really improve traffic in the international forum, though it might boost a lot of traffic in the general advice forum.
3) Screw it, create something like a GC10 (M7 + Insead, IMD, and LBS; three schools that belong up there with the very best IMO) to expose more people to the great opportunities that lie outside of the US shores. I don't quite know what this accomplishes (heh), but I just like the sound of it.
4) Create a database/knowledge vault for International/European b-school applicants. International b-schools are quite different from US b-schools, and the type of candidate they are looking for are also different. I don't think there are enough information highlighting these differences, and emphasizing the difference in experience. The hardest problem with this point though is that I have no idea how to resolve this issue.
Thank you for the ideas!
I like the one about cross-posting. I don't know if our forum allows that but we can at least assemble a small "Intro Sticky" that would have all relevant threads from the other forum, but having live threads would be better of course.
#2 is tough - we tried sub-forums and they often fail. For example we had Reviews subforum and it was dead because people did not want to leave the Math or Verbal or MBA forum to post a review or provide feedback about a product. I would hold off on this one.
#3 Sure! I think BSD already did that in his thread right here:
ranks-and-clusterings-of-various-international-b-schools-78320.html#4 Agree as well though I would recommend building it using stickies - it is the best of two worlds - keeps people in one forum and also preserves knowledge. We used to have a GMAT Knowledge Vault and once I moved one of the topics back into the GMAT Forum, it's visitation and popularity was 5x times the other topics, so I have evidence to believe it is best not to split up sub-forums for a very limited number of posts. (Though some members definitely prefer that format and there are reasons reasons to have a subforum, but I noticed that often threads are more popular when they are stickied or linked from one main thread). I know Praet disagrees with me somewhat on this, and you are welcome too! Actually - I love to be proved wrong, esp if I was pessimistic about it.