Don't feel obligated to use algebra in every question. Many of these 'is this number less than that number' questions can be done using the number line. Btw, the solution given above is correct and the algebraic way.

This question is quite straight forward since they have given that a, b and c are positive integers. No confusions!

'Is b between a and c?' essentially means 'does b lie between a and c on the number line?'

1) b is 3 greater than a, and b is 5 less than c

This means 'b' is 3 steps to the right of 'a' but 5 steps to the left of 'c' on the number line. It must lie between 'a' and 'c'. (draw a number line if it is not clear)

2) c is 5 greater than b, and c is 8 greater than a

'c' is 5 steps to the right of 'b' which means 'b' is 5 steps to the left of 'c'. 'c' is 8 steps to the right of 'a' which means 'a' is 8 steps to the left of 'c'. 'a' is further to the left of 'c' than 'b'. So 'b' must be between 'a' and 'c'.

So (D)
_________________

this is ds
first i would do is restate the question.
a<b<c?

than you would start with which ever that usually look easier.
I would start with 2.

2) a = c-8 < b = c-5 < c=b+5
which would give you A<B<C
which would make the statement true so you would eliminate
ACE and leave you with B or D.

1)a= b-3 < b= a+3 < c= b+5
which would give you A<B<C
which makes both statement true so the answer would be D

This is my first time solving a problem so if someone else care to chip in and make sure I answered it correctly please feel free to do so.
As far as what level problem I would guess a lower one maybe 500? or less no clue to be honest

Thanks Karishma. I felt good answering this particular question correctly because when I first read the question I said to myself, "Hold on! This question doesn't need any calculations at all! Just visualize the points on the number line and you are done!"

check this out:

stmt1: b= a+3, b= c-8
now place them in order a,b,c in terms of b => b-3, b , b+8 sufficient => B, C, E ruled out
Stmt2: c= B+5, c = a+8 equate them a+3 = b now again write them all in terms of A

a, a+3,a+8 again suff, so D as A is ruled out

Kudos please

Your explanations are ALWAYS Awesome - Gold Standard! Thanks Karishma
_________________

Hi Karishma,
The stem requires that a, b, and c are positive integers, but that info isn't used much, is it? Even if the they are not, the correct answer will still be D. Is that right?

I drew a number line for this question and found that it doesn't matter whether a, b, and c are positive integers or not. Is my reasoning correct? Thank you very much!

Yes, it doesn't matter at all. Where exactly then numbers are on the number line is immaterial. All we care about is the relative placement of the numbers. But when we solve questions using algebra, we need to ensure that negative numbers/fractions etc will not affect our solution. A question with "positive integers" puts us at ease immediately.
_________________

The Best approach to solve these kind of questions is plot the number line and then mark the positions as additional data is being provided.
_________________

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________