If m and n are both two digit numbers and m - n = 11x, is x an integer

The highlighted portion is the problem. When you say (m-n) is a multiple of 11, that implies that you ARE saying that x IS an integer. But that is something which is in-fact being asked. You can't assume it while solving for the question stem.

First we know that m is a a multiple of 11 but we still don’t know anything about 'n' therefore insufficient. Then we know that m+n is a multiple of 11 but that doesn't mean that they are both multiples of 11, it could be that they are both not non multiples of 11. Both together since m is a multiple of 11 then n must also be a multiple of 11. The difference of two multiples of 11 is always a multiple of 11. Thus answer is C

Hope this clarifies

Gimme some freaking Kudos!!
Best
J

how can we say that m is a multiple of 11

m could be 11.10
No where mentioned is the stem that M is an int , its just a number

OA should E

11.10 is not a 2-digit number.

If a number is a multiple of 11, that means you can write the number as '11q' where q is an integer. So if m - n = 11x, and x is an integer, that just means that m-n is a multiple of 11. So that's the question we're trying to answer: is m - n divisible by 11?

Statement 1 tells us that the two-digit number m looks something like 11, 22, 33, etc. Those numbers are all multiples of 11, so Statement 1 is just telling us that m alone is divisible by 11. We know nothing about n, however, so we can't say if m - n is divisible by 11.

Statement 2 tells us that m + n is divisible by 11. This is not sufficient, as you can see by generating almost any two examples, one using multiples of 11, and one not. So maybe m = 22 and n = 11, and then m-n is also divisible by 11. But maybe m = 23 and n = 10, and then m - n is not divisible by 11.

Using both statements, we know that m+n and m are both multiples of 11. That guarantees that n is also a multiple of 11. And if m and n are both multiples of 11, then m-n will always be a multiple of 11 as well, so the answer is C.

If it's unclear why n must be a multiple of 11 here, you can see that in one of the following ways:

• perhaps the fastest is to use the fact that, if we subtract one multiple of 11 from another, we always get a multiple of 11. So if (m+n) and (m) are both multiples of 11, then (m+n) - m will be too, but that's just equal to n.

• the longer way is conceptually more useful to understand, because it illustrates why it's true that you always get a multiple of 11 when you add or subtract two multiples of 11:

- if m+n is a multiple of 11, then m+n = 11q for some integer q
- if m is a multiple of 11, then m = 11k for some integer k

So we know:

m + n = 11q

but m = 11k, so we can substitute for m and rearrange:

11k + n = 11q
n = 11q - 11k
n = 11 (q - k)

and we can now see that n is equal to 11 times some integer, so n is a multiple of 11 also.

Of course there's nothing special about '11' here. When you add or subtract two multiples of any integer p, you always get a multiple of p.

My way to solve this problem was plugging numbers.


(1) m could be 11, 22, 33 ......
If n is 21, then m-n = 1.
11x = 1 when x is 1/11. So x is not integer.
If n is 11 and m is 22,
Then m-n = 11
If this is the case, x = 1. So x is integer.
Two different answers. Not sufficient.

(2)
If m = 22 and n = 11, then m-n = 11. X is integer.
If m = 23 and n = 10, then m-n = 13. X is not integer (11/13).
Not sufficient.

(1) + (2)

If m = 22, then n can only be a multiple of 11. Otherwise, (2) can’t be true.
Also, if m=22, then
22 + n = 11a
N = 11a-22
N = 11(a-2)
So n should be a multiple of 11.

So, M = 11a n = 11b. (A,b are just randomly chosen variables which will be replaced by positive integers, here it is positive because it is two digit numbers)
11a-11b = 11(a-b)
11(a-b) = 11x
A-b = x
Since, a and b are integers, x must be integers.

IMO = C.

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.