In a cricket team of 20 players, there are a certain number of wicket-

Question

Methodical Ways to Solve Venn Diagrams - Exercise Question #2

2-  In a cricket team of 20 players, there are a certain number of wicket-keepers. All of them can either bowl or bat or both. The number of wicket-keepers who can only bat are 3 and the number of wicket keepers who can only bowl is 1. Five players in the team are all-rounders, who can bat as well as bowl, but are not wicket-keepers. If there are atleast 5 players in the team, who can only bat or who can only bowl. Then what is the maximum number of players who can do all three things?

Options

A)  0
 B)  1
 C)  2
 D)  3
 E)  4

To read the article:      Methodical Ways to Solve Venn Diagrams

To solve question 1:    Question 1

https://e-gmat.com/blogs/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Free-Session-NP-e1533292073470.jpg

PrateekMittal · Accepted Answer

Hi  EgmatQuantExpert

Thanks for the question.

I find the following portion from question stem a bit misleading:

"If there are at least 5 players in the team, who can only bat or who can only bowl."

I am interpreting this line as follows....
Atleast 5 players who can "either only ball or only bat" i.e. "only ball + only bat together" >= 5

now in solution you have considered:
"only ball" >= 5
"only bat" >= 5
for this to be true, the question stem should have been clearer in stating that there are at least 5 players who can only bat and at least 5 players who can only bowl.

Please clarify. Also, if my understanding is wrong somewhere, please guide me.

Bunuel  if you could give your 2 cents too..

Archit3110 · Answer

I am not able to understandIf there are  atleast 5 players in the team , who can only bat or who can only bowl
not able to get an exact value which needs to be considered.....

smlprkh · Answer

Answer is A.

If you need someone to do all 3, he/she must know how to wicket keep. However, it is clearly written that a wicketkeeper can't both bowl and bat.

Therefore, no such person exists.

EgmatQuantExpert · Answer

Hey  smlprkh ,
Thanks for pointing it out.
We have edited the question.
Thanks and Regards,

EgmatQuantExpert · Answer

Hey  Archit3110 ,
It simply means that at least 5 players only bat and at least 5 players can only bowl.
Since this the minimum number of player that can only bat or bowl, the number of players can be more than 5 also.

Thanks and Regards,

EgmatQuantExpert · Answer

Solution

Understanding the question

Let us first identify the different sets mentioned in this question,

• The universal set is the players of the team.
• Among them,
 o Set A is the people who are batsmen,
o Set B is the people who are bowlers, and
o Set C is the people who are wicket-keepers
o In this question, the number of players who can do neither of the above = 0

Now that we have identified the sets mentioned in the question, let’s understand the information given about them
 • We are told that the total number of players in the team = 20
• Among them, there are certain number of wicket-keepers and all of them are either batsmen or bowler or both.
 o This implies that there is no player, in the team, who is only a wicket-keeper
o The number of wicket-keepers who can only bat = 3, and
o The number of wicket-keepers who can only bowl = 1 
• We are also told that there are atleast 5 players, who can only bat, and atleast 5 players , who can only bowl
• Five players in the team are all-rounders, who can bat and bowl, but are not wicket-keepers 
• And we need to find out the maximum number of players, who can do all three things.

Draw the Venn Diagram

Now that we have understood all the information that is given to us, let’s represent this information in a two-set venn-diagram.

https://e-gmat.com/blogs/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/3.png

Let’s find relationships between different entities in the venn diagram using the information given to us

• In this question, n(U) = n(A or B or C)
• Thus,
 o n(U) = n(A or B or C) = a + b + c + d + e + f + g = 20
o We know, c = 0, since there is no player who is only a wicket-keeper
  So, a + b + d + e + f + g = 20 ……… (1)

• And, we are given that,
 o n(only A and C) = 3, which implies that f = 3
o n(only B and C) = 3, which implies that e = 1
o n( only A and B) = 5, which implies that d = 5

• Substituting these values in equation (1), we get, a + b + g = 20 – 3 – 1 - 5 = 11 ……. (2)
• We are also given that,
 o n(only A) ≥ 5 => a ≥ 5
o n(only B) ≥ 5 => b ≥ 5

• In equation (2), a + b + g = 11, ‘g’ represents the number of the players, who can do all three things
 o For ‘g’ to be maximum, (a + b) must be minimum
o We know that the minimum value of a and b are 5 each. So, the minimum value of a + b = 5 + 5 = 10
o Therefore, the maximum value of g = 11 – 10 = 1

Hence, the maximum number of players, in the team, who can do all three things = 1

https://e-gmat.com/blogs/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/4.png

Hence, the correct answer is option B.

https://e-gmat.com/blogs/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/Ability-Quiz-WP-e1533292133520.png

chacinluis · Answer

The questions says:  "If there are at least 5 players in the team, who can only bat or who can only bowl"

Therefore you can have those that can only bat that are wicket or not wicket, and those that can only bowl that are wicket or not wicket.

Based on your Venn diagram you should have

a+f>=5
b+e>=5

which become

a+f=a+3>=5
a>=2

b+e=b+1>=5
b>=4

ShreyasJavahar · Answer

This seemed fairly straightforward to me. Please refer to the image below.
The areas with two roles overlapping have 5,3 and 1 player(s). Now to obtain the number of players who perform all 3 roles, the limiting factor is the least number of players who can play two roles, which in this case happens to be 1, and that is the answer.
 EgmatQuantExpert  , do you see any issues with this approach?

seema321 · Answer

If there are atleast 5 players in the team, who can only bat or who can only bowl.-

I am interpreting this line as follows....
Atleast 5 players who can "either only ball or only bat" i.e. "only ball + only bat together" >= 5

now in solution you have considered:
"only ball" >= 5
"only bat" >= 5
for this to be true, the question stem should have been clearer in stating that there are at least 5 players who can only bat and at least 5 players who can only bowl.

Please clarify. Also, if my understanding is wrong somewhere, please guide me.

Fdambro294 · Answer

At first, it was a little difficult to work through the verbiage of the question. After understanding the 3 Sets, we have the following Sets:

Set W = Wicket Players

Set X = Batters

Set Y = Bowlers

However, every person who is part of Set W is part of

W + X only

W + Y only

or

All 3: W + X + Y

in other words, there are 0 people part of ---- ONLY W

(a) Find the No. of People who do EXACTLY 2 Things (are part of EXACTLY 2 Sets)

"3 of Wicket can only Bat"

X + W ONLY = 3

"1 of Wicket can only Bowl"

Y + W ONLY = 1

"5 people can Bat + Bowl, but are NOT Wicket"

X + Y ONLY = 5

No. of Unique Elements part of EXACTLY 2 SETS = (X + W only) + (Y + W only) + (X + Y only) = 3 + 1 + 5 =

9 people part of EXACTLY 2 Sets

"There are AT LEAST 5 people on the team who can only Bat or who can only Bowl."

This part of the Question ----- I wish it was written a bit more clearly.

Is there a MINIMUM 5 people who can do 1 or the OTHER?

OR

Is there a MINIMUM 5 people who can ONLY Bat and a MINIMUM 5 people who can ONLY Bowl?

Going with the former interpretation, the answer is NOT Given.

So going with the latter interpretation:

Since every Wicket is either part of 2 Sets or part of 3 Sets:

The No. of people who are part of EXACTLY 1 Set = (Bat Only - X only) + (Bowl Only - Y only)

and we are told that EACH has to have a MINIMUM 5 people

MIN No. of people who are part of EXACTLY 1 Set = (at least 5 in X) + (at least 5 in Y) = at least 10

Q- what is the MAXIMUM Amount of people who are part of ALL 3 SETS?

Out of 20 Unique people:

We know there are 9 people who are part of EXACTLY 2 Sets

We know AT MINIMUM there must be at least 10 people who are part of EXACTLY 1 Set

and because the 20 people are on the Team, they all must be doing something so there is NO ONE in the Neither Group

The MAXIMUM Number of People who Can Do all 3 Things =

(20 Unique ppl) - (9 ppl part of Exactly 2 Sets) - (at least 10 ppl part of Exactly 1 Set ) =

1 Person

-B-

Fdambro294 · Answer

Stated much better than I stated the misleading part of the question.

bumpbot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

In a cricket team of 20 players, there are a certain number of wicket-

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

In a cricket team of 20 players, there are a certain number of wicket-

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards