In the early twentieth century, the idea that pianists should be music

Question

New Project RC Butler 2019  -  Practice 2 RC Passages Everyday   
Passage # 435, Date: 06-Nov-2019
 This post is a part of New Project RC Butler 2019 .  Click here for Details

In the early twentieth century, the idea that pianists should be musician-scholars whose playing reflected the way composers wanted their music to sound replaced the notion that pianists should be virtuosos whose performances thrilled audiences with emotional daring and showy displays of technique. One important figure to emerge in the period, though a harpsichordist rather than a pianist, was Wanda Landowska (1879–1959). She demonstrated how the keyboard works of Baroque composers such as Bach, Handel, Scarlatti, and Couperin probably sounded in their own times. It would be a mistake to consider Landowska a classicist, however. She had been born in an age of Romantic playing dominated by Liszt, Leschetizky, and their pupils. Thus she grew up with and was influenced by certain Romantic traditions of performance, whatever the stringency of her musical scholarship; Landowska knew how to hold audiences breathless, and when she gave recitals, they responded with deathlike silence and rapt attention.

Her playing was Romantic, but it was at least as close in spirit to the style of playing intended by composers of the Baroque (1600–1750) and Classical (1750–1830) eras, as have been the more exacting but less emotionally resonant interpretations of most harpsichordists since Landowska. She had a miraculous quality of touch, a seemingly autonomous left hand; no artist in her generation could clarify with such deftness the polyphonic writing of the Baroque masters. And none could make their music so spring to life.

Her achievements were the result of a lifetime of scholarship, truly remarkable physical gifts, and resilient rhythm, all combined with excellent judgment about when not to hold the printed note sacrosanct. Of course, developing such judgment demanded considerable experience and imagination. She was a genius at underlining the dramatic and emotional content of a piece, and to do so, she took liberties, all kinds of liberties, while nevertheless preserving the integrity of a composer’s score. In short, her entire musical approach was Romantic: intensely personal, full of light and shade, never pedantic.

Thanks to Landowska, Bach’s music (originally composed for the harpsichord) now sounded inappropriately thick when played on the piano. One by one, pianists stopped playing Bach’s music as adapted for the piano by Liszt or by Tausig. Then they gradually stopped performing any kind of Baroque music on the piano, even Scarlatti’s. The piano repertoire, it began to be felt, was extensive enough without reverting to transcriptions of Baroque music originally written for the harpsichord—and piano performances of Bach and Scarlatti were, despite the obvious similarities between the harpsichord and the piano, transcriptions, no matter how faithfully the original notes were played. In accordance with this kind of purism came an emphasis on studying composers’ manuscript notations, a relatively new field of musicology that is flourishing even today.   1 
 E 
 1. The passage suggests that Landowska’s playing embodied a rejection of which of the following?

A) Emotionally resonant interpretations of musical works.
B) An audience’s complete silence during a performance.
C) Performances of previously obscure Baroque works.
D) The idea that a performer can correctly judge when not to hold the printed note sacrosanct.
E) Performances emphasizing showy displays of technique that compromise the integrity of a composer’s original score.

2 
 D 
 2. Which of the following can be inferred from the passage about the compositions of Scarlatti?

A) They were adapted by Liszt and Tausig. 
B) They have not been transcribed faithfully.
C) They were not composed during the Baroque period. 
D) They were composed for instruments other than piano.
E) They fell out of favor with most musicians in the early twentieth century.

3 
 E 
 3. The passage suggests that Landowska would probably have objected most strongly to which of the following?

A) A performance of a Bach keyboard piece played on the harpsichord.
B) A performance of a Handel organ piece on a Baroque pipe organ.
C) A modern composition written for a harpsichord and two pianos.
D) A piano solo in which the performer occasionally departs from the tempo indicated by the composer.
E) A performance of a piano and violin sonata in which the piano part is played on the harpsichord.

4 
 C 
 4. The author’s assertion that Landowska should not be considered a classicist serves primarily to emphasize which of the following?

A) Landowska specialized in playing the works of composers of the Baroque era.
B) Landowska’s repertoire included orchestral music only.
C) Landowska’s musical performances were not devoid of emotion.
D) Landowska’s repertoire emphasized works of long-lasting interest and value.
E) Landowska advocated the study of Classical style or form.

Skywalker18 · Answer

All correct except Q3 in 9 mins 45 seconds, including 5 mins 30 seconds to read.
Para 1- idea that pianists should be musician-scholars whose playing reflected the way composers wanted their music to sound replaced the notion that pianists should be virtuosos; Wanda Landowska- influenced by certain Romantic traditions
Para 2- WL- miraculous quality of touch, a seemingly autonomous left hand
Para 3- her entire musical approach was Romantic: intensely personal, full of light and shade, never pedantic.
Para 4- Thanks to Landowska, Bach’s music (originally composed for the harpsichord) now sounded inappropriately thick when played on the piano; an emphasis on studying composers’ manuscript notations

1. The passage suggests that Landowska’s playing embodied a rejection of which of the following? 
E) Performances emphasizing showy displays of technique that compromise the integrity of a composer’s original score.- Correct, WL's playing serves to express the idea described in the first line-" pianists should be musician-scholars whose playing reflected the way composers wanted their music to sound replaced the notion that pianists should be virtuosos whose performances thrilled audiences with emotional daring and showy displays of technique"
The last para describes preserving the integrity of composer's original score

2. Which of the following can be inferred from the passage about the compositions of Scarlatti? 
D) They were composed for instruments other than piano.

hen they gradually stopped performing any kind of Baroque music on the piano, even Scarlatti’s. The piano repertoire, it began to be felt, was extensive enough without reverting to transcriptions of Baroque music originally written for the harpsichord

3. The passage suggests that Landowska would probably have objected most strongly to which of the following? 
We know that "performers should use the instrument for which the music was originally written"

A) A performance of a Bach keyboard piece played on the harpsichord.
B) A performance of a Handel organ piece on a Baroque pipe organ.- incorrect
C) A modern composition written for a harpsichord and two pianos.- incorrect
D) A piano solo in which the performer occasionally departs from the tempo indicated by the composer.- incorrect
E) A performance of a piano and violin sonata in which the piano part is played on the harpsichord.

I was down to options A and E and chose option A. But I think we might be able to eliminate option A because of
"Thanks to Landowska, Bach’s music (originally composed for the harpsichord) now sounded inappropriately thick when played on the piano."

4. The author’s assertion that Landowska should not be considered a classicist serves primarily to emphasize which of the following? 
C) Landowska’s musical performances were not devoid of emotion.- Correct

She had a miraculous quality of touch, a seemingly autonomous left hand; no artist in her generation could clarify with such deftness the polyphonic writing of the Baroque masters. And none could make their music so spring to life.

hero_with_1000_faces · Answer

Hi  SajjadAhmad 
Can you please post answer for Q3.

Cannot find much difference between A and D.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Official Explanation

3. The passage suggests that Landowska would probably have objected most strongly to which of the following?

Difficulty Level:   750

Explanation

The passage tells us that Landowska was an adherent of the idea that performers of other people's musical works should play  “the way composers wanted their music to sound”  (line 2-3). In the context of the passage, this means that performers should use the instrument for which the music was originally written. This rules out  Choices B, C, and D , as they are not examples of this kind of deviation from the composers’ intentions.

Choice A  is incorrect, since the passage tells us that Bach's music was  “originally composed for the harpsichord”  (First line of last para).

This leaves  Choice E  as the only correct option: Landowska would object to the music originally intended for the piano being performed on a harpsichord.

Answer: E

hero_with_1000_faces · Answer

Hi  SajjadAhmad

Can you please clarify one Doubt.

We know for fact that "Bach and Scarlatti" composed music which were for Harp.

However in this question 3. "A" states that 'A performance of a  Bach keyboard piece  played on the harpsichord.

Doesn't Keyboard piece means, composed for Piano ? any musicians in the house ? lol

Westminster · Answer

can anyone explain this sentence--She was a genius at underlining the dramatic and emotional content of a piece, and to do so, she took liberties, all kinds of liberties,

""while nevertheless preserving the integrity of a composer’s score""

in the first question's solution shows option :e , how would it be an answer, however, "she preserved the integrity of a composer score""

akhil3101 · Answer

Question 1:
 The passage suggests that Landowska’s playing embodied  a rejection  of which of the following?

A) Emotionally resonant interpretations of musical works.
B) An audience’s complete silence during a performance.
C) Performances of previously obscure Baroque works.
D) The idea that a performer can correctly judge when not to hold the printed note sacrosanct.
E) Performances emphasizing showy displays of technique that compromise the integrity of a composer’s original score.

'Rejection' is the key
As per passage Landowska's playing preserves the integrity of a composer's score. But option E says the 'compromise of the integrity of composer's original score'

junii · Answer

Please can you post OE for Q4?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Official Explanation

4. The author’s assertion that Landowska should not be considered a classicist serves primarily to emphasize which of the following?

Difficulty Level:   650

Explanation

The  second paragraph  of the passage suggests that the primary difference between the Classical and the Romantic styles of playing is that the former puts emphasis on technical mastery and faithfulness to the original score, while the latter focuses on the emotional aspects of performance. Therefore,  Choice C  is correct.

Answer: C

amolborgaonkar · Answer

I'm having difficulty comprehending the second paragraph, " but it was at least as close in spirit to the style of playing intended by composers of the Baroque (1600–1750) and Classical (1750–1830) eras, as have been the more exacting but less emotionally resonant interpretations of most harpsichordists since Landowska ". Can someone please help me out here?

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

In the early twentieth century, the idea that pianists should be music

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

In the early twentieth century, the idea that pianists should be music

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards