Is |x| = y-z? 1)x+y=z 2) x

Question

Is |x| = y-z?

1)x+y=z
2) x < 0

|x| = -x or x.

If -x = y-z. then x+y = z
If x = y-z, then y-x = z

So from 1) x+y = z, so -x = y-z and |x| must be equals to y - z. So 1) is sufficient.

From 2) all we know is x is less than 0. Nothing about y or z is given. So 2) is insufficient.

OA is not my answer (which is A). What do you think of my working ? I'm having the thought that satisfying x+y=z OR y-x=z is sufficient to say if |x| = y-z.

saurya_s · Answer

From 1 , one get x=z-y. If x is +ve then, it is z-y; with x negative, it is y-z
From 2 , you get x is negative, so C.
Let me know what do u feel.
S

Alex_NL · Answer

Yes I do get C too.

st.1
x + y = z

x = z - y
if x = 7, z could be - 10 and y could be 17

|7| is not 17 -- 10

if x = 3, z could be 5 and y could be 2

|3| is 2 - 5

I guess this proves that A canÂ´t be the OA.

Regards,

Alex

ywilfred · Answer

I am a little confused when it got to |x| = -x = y-z. How can an absolute value of x be equals to its negative value ? Absolute values, I thought, have no negatives.

sdanquah · Answer

Is |x| = y-z? 

1)x+y=z 
2) x < 0 

From 1 x = z-y
the value of x will depend on the magnitude of both z and y. if z> Y
then we get x to be positive and x = Z-Y. Iand abs(X) = y -z, right?

Now if Z < Y then X = - (z-y). If we take the absolute value, we get
abs(x) = abs(-(z-y)) = z -y, right. so A is sufficient. 

Thus A is the answer and not C

hardworker_indian · Answer

You are right and wrong.
Absolute values have no sign. So |x| is always postive and represents the magnitude of x.
But in this problem, we are talking about x. x, the actual number, does have sign apart from magnitude.

From statement I alone, you cannot say "Sufficient". I is sufficient if the number x is proved to be negative, which is given in statement II. Hence C. The problem with your approach is that you missed the OR part.

|x| = -x or x. 

If -x = y-z. then x+y = z 
OR
If x = y-z, then y-x = z 

So from 1) x+y = z, so -x = y-z and x must be equals to y - z. So (1) is sufficient if x is negative. Nothing is known about the if x is positive. Insufficient.

From 2) all we know is x is less than 0. Insufficient. 

Together (2) says that x is negative and 1 proves the negative part of stem. Sufficient

sdanquah · Answer

Is |x| = y-z? 

1)x+y=z 
2) x < 0 


Hello, I think you are missing something here. wht you shd know is that the value of x is dependent on z and Y for instance let say z = 2 and y = 5
then 
 From statement one, X = 5-2 = 3, abs(x) = 3
Now flip it around and assume that y = 2 and Z = 5
then x = 2 - 5 = -3, abs(x) = 3.

So why do you say A is not sufficient 

Now consider it this way, abs(x) could mean that x is positive or negative.
if x is positive
then we have 
from one we have
X = y -z and abs(x) = abs(y-z) and abs(x) = y -z)
If X <0,
then from one it would mean
-x = z-y
X = -(z-y), take the absolute value of x and you get z-y. 
meaning A is sufficient.

I don't think you need B to conclude that abs(x) will always be equal to 
y -z or z - y.

jinino · Answer

Is |x|=y-z?

1) x+y=z
2) x<0

|x|=y-z gives 2 possibilities:

y-z=x or y-z=-x

From 1), x+y=z, first we can rearrange this equation to 

-x=y-z, which matches one of the 2 possibilities; second, we

can rearrange the equation to x=z-y, which does not matches

another possibility. So we cannot say by 1) alone is sufficient

for the equation |x|=y-z to hold.

From 2), x<0, we have no clue to determine the validity of 

|X|=y-z

If we take 1) and 2) together, and ask if x+y=z and x<0, is

|x|=y-z valid? We can get rid of one of the possibilities from

the equation |x|=y-z, and only -x=y-z left. And x+y=z is

sufficient to make -x=y-z hold. So 1) and 2) together are

sufficient, and my answer is C.

lastochka · Answer

i agree with C
thanks for explanation

Is |x| = y-z? 1)x+y=z 2) x < 0 |x| = -x or x. If -x =

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards