Official Solution: Bunuel
Leo: Transitioning from traditional light bulbs to LED bulbs can greatly reduce energy consumption and lower electricity bills. Many countries, including Germany, have seen significant improvements in energy efficiency and cost savings by making widespread changes to LED lighting in both residential and commercial sectors — improvements that show how broadly suitable LED technology is for modern lighting needs.
Samantha: While LED bulbs are more energy-efficient than traditional bulbs, they are not the ideal choice for all lighting needs. Their upfront cost can be high, their light quality can vary, and the success of LED adoption in Germany may not apply equally in countries with different energy usage patterns or economic conditions.
Based on the views expressed, select for
Agree the statement about which Leo and Samantha would most likely agree, and select for
Disagree the statement about which Leo and Samantha would most likely disagree. Make only two selections, one in each column.
• LED bulbs are more energy-efficient than traditional light bulbs. Leo says: “Transitioning from traditional light bulbs to LED bulbs can greatly reduce energy consumption...” This directly affirms that LED bulbs are more energy-efficient.
Samantha says: “While LED bulbs are more energy-efficient than traditional bulbs...” She explicitly acknowledges their superior efficiency.
Both speakers clearly affirm this point. This is the statement Leo and Samantha would most likely agree on.
• LED bulbs are cheaper to purchase than traditional bulbs. Samantha says: “LED bulbs can be expensive to purchase initially...” This directly contradicts the statement, so she would most likely disagree with it.
Leo does not mention the purchase cost of LED bulbs. He talks only about energy consumption and electricity bills, not upfront pricing. Since he is silent on this issue, we cannot determine his position.
Because only one speaker expresses a view and the other is silent, this statement cannot be the correct answer for agreement or disagreement.
• LED bulbs are broadly effective for lighting needs, regardless of geographic or sector-specific context. Leo says that many countries, including Germany, have seen significant improvements by adopting LED lighting “in both residential and commercial sectors.” This suggests he views LED technology as broadly effective across different contexts.
Samantha says: “They are not the perfect solution for all lighting needs,” and notes concerns about upfront cost, light quality, and differences in energy needs and economic conditions between countries. This shows she would likely disagree with the idea that LEDs are broadly effective regardless of regional or sector-specific variation.
This is the statement Leo and Samantha would most likely disagree about.
• LED bulbs require less frequent replacement than traditional bulbs. Neither Leo nor Samantha mentions bulb lifespan, durability, or replacement frequency. Leo focuses on energy consumption and cost savings. Samantha raises issues with upfront cost, light quality, and cross-context suitability — but not how long the bulbs last.
Since this topic is not addressed by either speaker, we cannot determine whether they would agree or disagree with the statement.
Therefore, this statement cannot be the correct answer for either column.
• LED lighting reduces carbon emissions more effectively than other modern clean-energy technologies. Leo discusses reduced energy consumption and lower electricity bills. However, he does not mention carbon emissions or compare LEDs to other clean-energy technologies such as solar, wind, or advanced energy systems.
Samantha focuses on the limitations of LED bulbs, including cost, quality, and contextual suitability, but does not discuss environmental impact or refer to other clean-energy technologies.
Since neither speaker addresses carbon emissions or makes any comparative claims about other clean-energy solutions, this statement cannot be used to determine agreement or disagreement.
Correct answer: Agree
"LED bulbs are more energy-efficient than traditional light bulbs."Disagree
"LED bulbs are broadly effective for lighting needs, regardless of geographic or sector-specific context. "