Bunuel wrote:
Many websites that owe their financial success to Oodles, a popular search engine, now claim that Oodles has destroyed their business by making slight alterations to the very search algorithm that initially fostered the websites’ success. However, such claims can be confidently rejected as greedy and self-entitled: the websites’ own data shows that the changes in Oodles’ algorithm have only resulted in 8-12% less traffic for the websites than they have grown accustomed to.
Which of the following, if true, would best strengthen the websites’ argument?
A. In recent months internet sales have become so competitive and profit margins so thin that even a slight drop in traffic is catastrophic for a website.
B. Leaked internal Oodles memos show that the search engine was aware that a number of the websites would be affected by the changes.
C. Oodles is not the only search engine on the internet, so the websites could make up the missing traffic elsewhere.
D. The drop in traffic is only temporary while Oodles finetunes the new algorithm.
E. Before making the changes to its algorithm, Oodles asked and received permission from the affected businesses to make the changes.
VERITAS PREP OFFICIAL SOLUTION:
Question Type: Strengthen
Websites' Argument: Changes in search algorithm have resulted in failure of websites.
Assumption: Changes led to the failure and no other possible reasons.
A. In recent months internet sales have become so competitive and profit margins so thin that even a slight drop in traffic is catastrophic for a website. – Correct. Attacks the data cited by stating that small drop results in huge loss, strengthening the websites' argument.
B. Leaked internal Oodles memos show that the search engine was aware that a number of the websites would be affected by the changes. – Out of context. Not being aware/being aware does not help us to strengthen the websites’ claims.
C. Oodles is not the only search engine on the internet, so the websites could make up the missing traffic elsewhere. – Out of context.
D. The drop in traffic is only temporary while Oodles fine tunes the new algorithm. – Opposite.
E. Before making the changes to its algorithm, Oodles asked and received permission from the affected businesses to make the changes. – Out of context. Same reason as B.
Answer: A