nishith17
Hi,
Please rate my AWA and provide suggestions to improve. I got this as a part of my free
Veritas Practice Test
Parents, if you need a summer camp for your children look no further than Federville Farms. In a recent survey, Federville Farms ranked first in both overall camper satisfaction and in food quality, and second in the variety of outdoor activities. Federville Farms has been family owned and operated for over forty years, so you have nothing to worry about when it comes to your child's safety, and it employs more Red Cross certified lifeguards than any other camp in the state. If you seek the best camp experience for your children, Federville Farms is the best choice you can make.
Discuss how well reasoned you find this argument. In your discussion be sure to analyze the line of reasoning and the use of evidence in the argument. For example, you may need to consider what questionable assumptions underlie the thinking and what alternative explanations or counterexamples might weaken the conclusion. You can also discuss what sort of evidence would strengthen or refute the argument, what changes in the argument would make it more logically sound, and what, if anything, would help you better evaluate its conclusion.My Answer- In the above news article Federville Farms has asked parents to en-roll their children in Federville Farms for the summer camp. They provides various reasons for that such as its rankings for overall camper satisfaction, food quality, and outdoor activities. They also state that Federville Farms is operating for more than forty years hence provides a safe environment for children. Safety is also taken care of by Red Cross certified lifeguards whose number is more than any other camp in the state. While Federville Farms provide good reasons on the basis of which they try to persuade parents to enroll children in Federville Farms there are a few flaws in their reasoning.
Firstly, Federville Farms states that it's ranked first in overall camper satisfaction and in food quality, and second in variety of outdoor activities. While the second rank in variety of outdoor activities is good but they fail to mention different types of outdoor activities available. It is possible that parents will be looking for some specific activities such as swimming which might not be available in the camp. Even if it is available, it fails to mention the customer satisfaction of these specific outdoor activities. It only mentions the first rank in overall camper satisfaction which might be misleading since there will be few areas where customer satisfaction is not good as other camps. Although, Federville Farms mentions the first rank in food quality, they don't mention the type of food served. It is possible that some children are allergic to one or other type of food served at the Federville Farms.
Second, they provide a case for safety. They state that the farm is being operated for last forty years and employs Red Cross certified guards. While experience of more than 40 is persuading, it also makes the customer doubt the age of equipment being used at the farm. Federville Farms fails to mention the time period in which they repair or replace the equipment used at the farm. The presence of Red Cross certified guards provides a good case for safety considerations at the plant.
Thirdly, they fail to mention the distance for the camp from the area where they are advertising and the cost of summer camp. These two factors can be determining factors for some parents.
In my opinion, Federville Farms provides a good case of why their farm is better than other farm but it has some flaws in the reasoning though which they try to persuade parents to choose their farm over other farms. If they cover the above mentioned points their case will be much more structured and fool proof.
Hi nishith17
I think it is good . In my opinion you should use templates as it leaves good impact on the e-grader . I think your essay is little short . You should try to elucidate more in your essay .Try to ascertain more facts that are pivotal for the argument to base the conclusion upon . Some facts are always missing . It should be well thought , well articulated , assertive . For that you ought to be pretty good at understanding the premise of the argument and what conclusion it has , you have identified & covered some of the assumptions , raised questionable flaws but they are not sufficient and you should come up with more of them . In summary You must use the better templates , which makes the essay look more comprehensible, and elaborate more to leave good impression on the e-grader . All the best !
Although I am not a a very high scorer in GMAT hence I'm not qualified to give GMAT advice , but I took the GMAT twice and got a 4.5 & 5.0 essay score respectively , In hope you will find my essay templates/advice useful , I wish to share templates which I used very often and which I still remember very vividly , they were advised by my GMAT instructor . You should try them next time and note the response . In anticipation that you shall get better grade .
Paragraph 1: "Introduction"
As advised , I always start by saying, "In the preceding statement, the author claims that (paraphrase of the author's argument)."
This shows that I understand the author's argument. I continue with my disagreement (and, becauseit has been often said, ALWAYS! disagree with the author's reasoning, and I pretty much always used the same statement, like:
“
Though his claim may well have merit, the author presents a poorly reasoned argument, based on several questionable premises and assumptions, and based solely on the evidence the author offers, we cannot accept his argument as valid. “
I can use that statement for pretty much any and every argument essay I encounter. I also use "we" but I try to avoid using "I". ( Take that as you wish! )
Paragraph 2: "Attacks the premise of the author's argument"
For me, paragraph 2 always attacks the premise of the author's argument. I usually write down a premise and then I attack the lack of evidence that the author bases his premise on.
I usually begin with same statement all the the time :
"
The primary issue with the author's reasoning lies in his unsubstantiated premises".
I like "
primary" and "
secondary" as transitional tools because they are more complex than "
first" and "
second". Throughout the first paragraph, I show flaws in the author's premises by pointing out his lack of evidentiary support (they pretty much always lack evidentiary support!!!) . I generally end with something like:
"
The author's premises, the basis for his argument, lack any legitimate evidentiary support and render his conclusion unacceptable."
Paragraph 3: "Attack the assumptions"
In the third paragraph, I always attack the assumptions
I usually begin with :
"
In addition, the author makes several assumptions that remain unproven. "
My assumption paragraph ends with something like:
"
The author weakens his argument by making assumptions and failing to provide explication of the links between X and Y he assumes exists. "
Paragraph 4: How I can strengthen the argument
Paragraph 4 is where I talk about how the author could strengthen his argument
I usually begin this paragraph with something like:
"
While the author does have several key issues in his argument's premises and assumptions, that is not to say that the entire argument is without base."
Then I provide some concrete ways the author could strengthen his argument. The easiest way to do this is to give examples of what kind of evidence the author could provide, and discuss how he can fill the holes in his assumptions.
I generally end with something like:
"
Though there are several issues with the author's reasoning at present, with research and clarification, he could improve his argument significantly. "
Paragraph 5 : Conclusion Para
As advised , This is my conclusion paragraph. I pretty much always conclude with the same sentence:
In sum, the author's illogical argument is based on unsupported premises and unsubstantiated assumptions that render his conclusion invalid.
As advised , I usually use "
in sum" because it's considered better stylistically than "
in conclusion" but signals to the e-grader that you're at your conclusion.
I usually add a couple sentences in between and then I end with:
"If the author truly hopes to change his readers' minds on the issue, he would have to largely restructure his argument, fix the flaws in his logic, I hope you find it useful . "
If possible try these templates and see what score you get . And do work on finding assumptions and raising questionable flaws .
Do let me know what score you get when you use them ( if you use!
)
Regards