Hi iamDARKLORD,Great catch, and you're completely right: the distance is
not given in the question stem. That's exactly why you should
not borrow the
250 km from Statement (
1) when you test Statement (
2) on its own. In DS, each statement has to stand alone - so anything in Statement (
1) simply doesn't exist while you evaluate Statement (
2).
So where does the
250 in that solution come from? It was pulled in from Statement (
1), which is a mistake. The good news is that
Statement (2) never needs the distance at all - it cancels out.
Why distance doesn't matter hereCall the unknown distance d.
- Prem:
5:00 a.m. ->
11:00 a.m. =
6 hr, so speed = d/
6- Ramesh:
7:00 a.m. ->
3:00 p.m. =
8 hr, so speed = d/
8Set their positions equal at clock time T and every term carries a d, so it divides out - leaving a single value of T. No number for the distance is required.
See it with two distancesSince the doubt is really "can we answer without a distance?", let's try two different ones and watch the answer stay put:
-
d = 240 km: Prem =
40 km/hr, Ramesh =
30 km/hr - they meet at about
9:17 a.m.-
d = 480 km: Prem =
80 km/hr, Ramesh =
60 km/hr - they meet at about
9:17 a.m.Same meeting time both times. Because the answer is fixed no matter what distance you pick, Statement (
2) alone is
sufficient - and you never needed the
250.
That's also why the answer is
B, not C: Statement (
1) gives speeds but no start times (
not sufficient), while Statement (
2) gives the full timing on its own.
Answer: BiamDARKLORD
why did u consider distance as 250km for Option B? as distance is not given in questions statement