kabirgandhi
Great example of a high-level RC passage, complex read and a lot of trap answers.
Q2. Why did we choose C over B?
My guess is that C says that the author writes the passage to advocate for additional research (seems correct till now) to help elucidate a particular theory's validity (this makes it seem like the author is trying to prove the hypothesis correct) or is it because this choice is too narrow? (i.e., does not mention the purpose of the sleep-related concepts in the first 2 paragraphs?)
GMATNinja MartyMurray KarishmaB kabirgandhi The distinction between
(B) and
(C) is subtle, and it hinges on understanding the author's
tone - a critical skill for Primary Purpose questions.
The Key Difference: "Advocate" vs. "Introduce"The word
"advocate" in choice
(B) means to actively promote or champion something - it signals a persuasive, promotional tone. However, throughout this passage, the author maintains a
neutral, informative tone. Look at the final sentence:
"The research thus far is promising but inconclusive; future scientific advances should allow this theory to be tested more rigorously."This is an
observation about what
could happen, not a call to action or advocacy. The author isn't pushing for research; they're simply noting that the theory remains unproven and could be tested better in the future.
Choice
(C) uses
"introduce" - a neutral word that perfectly captures what the author does: presents Jacobs' theory, explains the supporting evidence, and notes it's "promising but inconclusive." The phrase "has not yet been sufficiently proven" directly aligns with that conclusion.
Your instinct was spot-on -
(B) does make it seem like the author is trying to prove or promote the hypothesis, which doesn't match the passage's objective tone.
Regarding scope: Both
(B) and
(C) are fine in terms of scope. The sleep-related concepts in paragraphs \(1\)-\(2\) serve to explain the theory, so they're implicitly covered by both "particular theory" and "theoretical construct." Scope isn't the issue that eliminates
(B).
I hope this addresses your doubt.