The concept of labor productivity growth has long been a key

Question

The concept of “labor productivity growth” has long been a key indicator of economic performance, reflecting the efficiency with which labor inputs are converted into goods and services. Increases in labor productivity are closely tied to rising living standards, as they enable higher output without a proportional increase in labor hours. Traditionally, productivity gains were driven by technological advancements and capital investment. However, economists have increasingly focused on the role of workforce skills and education in sustaining long-term productivity growth, particularly as economies transition to more knowledge-intensive industries.

Germany provides a notable example of this dynamic. A 2019 study by the European Centre for Economic Research examined productivity trends in German manufacturing from 2000 to 2018. The study found that while automation and digitalization accounted for significant early gains, productivity growth slowed after 2012, coinciding with a plateau in workforce skill development. During this period, industries such as automotive manufacturing saw diminishing returns on automation alone, with labor productivity increasing by just 0.8 percent annually from 2013 to 2018—down from 2.5 percent in the previous decade. The report highlighted that firms with robust employee retraining programs outperformed their peers by nearly 40 percent in productivity measures, underscoring the importance of continuous skill enhancement to offset diminishing technological returns.

The notion that technological upgrades alone drive productivity growth is therefore incomplete. Sectors like pharmaceuticals and precision engineering, which invest heavily in employee upskilling, reported higher labor productivity than sectors with less emphasis on human capital development. A 2020 analysis revealed that pharmaceutical firms attributed over 35 percent of productivity growth to workforce training, compared to just 12 percent in the textile industry. This divergence reflects the varying dependence of industries on specialized skills versus routine tasks, highlighting the role of education and on-the-job learning as critical differentiators in high-value sectors.

Germany’s experience illustrates that while capital investment remains crucial, human capital development plays an increasingly pivotal role in driving sustainable productivity growth. As economies face demographic shifts and labor shortages, prioritizing workforce education and reskilling offers a viable path to maintaining competitive advantage and ensuring long-term economic resilience in a rapidly evolving global market.    1  1. Which of the following is a claim made in the passage about labor productivity growth in Germany between 2000 and 2018?

(A) The slowdown in productivity growth after 2012 was primarily caused by a decline in automation and digitalization investments.
(B) Sectors that focus heavily on automation consistently outperformed those that did not in terms of productivity growth from 2013 to 2018.
(C) Workforce retraining programs contributed significantly to mitigating the slowdown in productivity growth after 2012.
(D) Since workforce training accounted for just 12% of productivity growth in the textile sector, technological investments must have driven the remaining gains.
(E) Higher labor productivity growth in Germany after 2012 was entirely driven by workforce skills and education.

2 
 2. Based on the information in the passage, it can most reasonably be inferred that sectors in Germany with higher labor productivity growth after 2012

(A) relied heavily on workforce retraining programs and reduced investments in automation.
(B) experienced diminishing returns on automation alone, prompting the need for workforce retraining to sustain growth.
(C) saw larger productivity gains when both workforce retraining and capital investments were emphasized.
(D) primarily belonged to industries with lower capital intensity and simpler supply chains.
(E) achieved higher productivity growth due to workforce adjustments in response to demographic shifts and labor shortages.

3 
 3. A claim made in the passage is that

(A) technological advancements alone were insufficient to sustain long-term labor productivity growth in Germany after 2012.
(B) German manufacturing sectors with the highest productivity growth after 2012 did not rely on workforce retraining programs.
(C) productivity growth in Germany slowed across all sectors due to a plateau in capital investment and automation.
(D) workforce retraining programs contributed to higher productivity growth in industries that had previously relied heavily on automation.
(E) industries in Germany with lower productivity growth after 2012 were primarily those with limited technological investment.

4 
 4. Which of the following situations is most analogous to the problematic situation identified in the passage concerning the reliance on technological advancements to drive productivity growth?

(A) A company reports revenue growth figures without accounting for inflation, leading to an overestimation of the company’s real economic performance.
(B) A manager credits the success of a project solely to new software, overlooking the extensive experience-building employees underwent to implement it effectively.
(C) A university ranks departments based only on research output, ignoring the contributions of faculty mentoring and student success rates.
(D) A construction firm measures productivity by the number of buildings completed but fails to account for the increased use of subcontractors who perform much of the work.
(E) A healthcare provider reports improved patient outcomes after adopting new medical equipment but neglects to mention the concurrent hiring of highly specialized staff.

Check the links to other Butler Projects:

Problem Solving Butler  
  Data Sufficiency Butler  
  Critical Reasoning Butler  
  Reading Comprehension Butler  
  Data Insights Butler

cdrectenwald · Answer

Question 1
Which of the following is a claim made in the passage about labor productivity growth in Germany between 2000 and 2018?

Correct Choice: (C)
The passage explicitly says that, although productivity slowed after 2012 (in part because workforce skills plateaued), firms with robust retraining programs outperformed their peers—i.e., those programs significantly mitigated the slowdown.
Question 2
Based on the information in the passage, it can most reasonably be inferred that sectors in Germany with higher labor productivity growth after 2012

Correct Choice: (C)
The passage contrasts industries that relied on automation alone (which began to yield diminishing returns) with those that combined capital investment and robust workforce retraining. The latter enjoyed larger productivity gains. Thus, higher-growth sectors emphasized both human capital development and technology.
Question 3
A claim made in the passage is that

Correct Choice: (A)
A central theme is that technological advancements alone were not enough to sustain labor productivity growth after about 2012. The passage repeatedly highlights the need for ongoing skill development and retraining to offset the slowing returns from automation.
Question 4
Which of the following situations is most analogous to the problematic situation identified in the passage concerning the reliance on technological advancements to drive productivity growth?

Correct Choice: (B)
The key problem in the passage is crediting productivity gains entirely to technology while overlooking the crucial role of workforce upskilling.
Choice (B) directly parallels this by describing a manager who credits a project’s success solely to new software, ignoring the extensive employee training needed to implement it effectively.
Although choice (E) is somewhat similar (new equipment vs. specialized staff), (B) is the closest mirror of the “technology‐alone” misconception the passage warns against.

Bunuel · Answer

Official Solution:

1. Which of the following is a claim made in the passage about labor productivity growth in Germany between 2000 and 2018?

(A) The slowdown in productivity growth after 2012 was primarily caused by a decline in automation and digitalization investments.
(B) Sectors that focus heavily on automation consistently outperformed those that did not in terms of productivity growth from 2013 to 2018.
(C) Workforce retraining programs contributed significantly to mitigating the slowdown in productivity growth after 2012.
(D) Since workforce training accounted for just 12% of productivity growth in the textile sector, technological investments must have driven the remaining gains.
(E) Higher labor productivity growth in Germany after 2012 was entirely driven by workforce skills and education.

A)   Incorrect:  The passage mentions that automation and digitalization drove early productivity gains, but the slowdown was linked to a plateau in workforce skill development, not a reduction in technology investment. 
 
 B)   Incorrect:  The passage states that automation showed diminishing returns after 2012, and firms that emphasized retraining outperformed their peers, contradicting this option.

C)   Correct:  The passage explicitly highlights that firms with strong retraining programs outperformed others by nearly 20%, indicating retraining played a key role in mitigating the productivity slowdown.

D)   Incorrect:  The passage discusses that pharmaceuticals attributed 35% of productivity growth to retraining, while textiles attributed 12%, but it does not suggest that technology alone drove the remaining gains in textiles. This misrepresents the idea by making an assumption not stated in the passage.

E)   Incorrect:  While workforce skills and retraining are important, the passage emphasizes that both technology and human capital contribute to productivity growth. The phrase "entirely driven" inaccurately reflects the balanced role of both factors.

2. Based on the information in the passage, it can most reasonably be inferred that sectors in Germany with higher labor productivity growth after 2012

(A) relied heavily on workforce retraining programs and reduced investments in automation.
(B) experienced diminishing returns on automation alone, prompting the need for workforce retraining to sustain growth.
(C) saw larger productivity gains when both workforce retraining and capital investments were emphasized.
(D) primarily belonged to industries with lower capital intensity and simpler supply chains.
(E) achieved higher productivity growth due to workforce adjustments in response to demographic shifts and labor shortages.

A)     Incorrect:    The passage does not indicate that sectors reduced automation investments; rather, it highlights that retraining complemented automation to drive growth. This option misrepresents the balance between the two factors.

B)   Incorrect:  While diminishing returns on automation were mentioned, the passage emphasizes that retraining mitigated productivity slowdowns rather than being a direct consequence of diminishing returns alone.

C)   Correct:  The passage explicitly states that sectors like pharmaceuticals, which invested in both retraining and capital improvements, experienced the highest productivity growth. This is the most supported inference.

D)   Incorrect:  The passage suggests that sectors with greater reliance on specialized skills and complex processes outperformed lower capital intensity sectors, contradicting this option.

E)   Incorrect:  Although demographic shifts and labor shortages are mentioned as future concerns, the passage attributes productivity growth primarily to retraining and technological investment, not demographic changes.

3. A claim made in the passage is that

(A) technological advancements alone were insufficient to sustain long-term labor productivity growth in Germany after 2012.
(B) German manufacturing sectors with the highest productivity growth after 2012 did not rely on workforce retraining programs.
(C) productivity growth in Germany slowed across all sectors due to a plateau in capital investment and automation.
(D) workforce retraining programs contributed to higher productivity growth in industries that had previously relied heavily on automation.
(E) industries in Germany with lower productivity growth after 2012 were primarily those with limited technological investment.

A)   Correct:  The passage explicitly states that automation and technological advancements led to early productivity gains, but long-term growth required workforce retraining. This reflects the key claim regarding diminishing returns on technology.

B)   Incorrect:  The passage highlights that sectors with retraining programs outperformed others, contradicting the idea that high-growth sectors did not rely on retraining.

C)   Incorrect:  While productivity slowed, the cause is attributed to the plateau in workforce skill development, not exclusively to capital investment and automation.

D)   Incorrect:  Although retraining is linked to higher productivity, the passage focuses on diminishing returns in automated sectors, not those that had relied exclusively on automation. This claim is too general.

E)   Incorrect:  The passage suggests lower productivity growth was linked to sectors with less emphasis on retraining, rather than limited technological investment alone.

4. Which of the following situations is most analogous to the problematic situation identified in the passage concerning the reliance on technological advancements to drive productivity growth?

(A) A company reports revenue growth figures without accounting for inflation, leading to an overestimation of the company’s real economic performance.
(B) A manager credits the success of a project solely to new software, overlooking the extensive experience-building employees underwent to implement it effectively.
(C) A university ranks departments based only on research output, ignoring the contributions of faculty mentoring and student success rates.
(D) A construction firm measures productivity by the number of buildings completed but fails to account for the increased use of subcontractors who perform much of the work.
(E) A healthcare provider reports improved patient outcomes after adopting new medical equipment but neglects to mention the concurrent hiring of highly specialized staff.

A)   Incorrect:  While this option reflects overestimation, the analogy to technology vs. workforce retraining is not direct. Inflation does not mirror the skill development component of productivity growth.

B)   Correct:  This option subtly parallels the passage by reflecting how productivity (or project success) is misattributed to technology, while employee experience-building (analogous to retraining) plays a significant but under-recognized role.

C)   Incorrect:  Although this option highlights incomplete evaluation, it focuses on multiple performance indicators rather than the interplay between capital investment and workforce development.

D)   Incorrect:  This option introduces the concept of outsourcing/subcontracting, which deviates from the internal retraining dynamic described in the passage.

E)   Incorrect:  While this option mentions dual contributing factors, hiring specialized staff suggests external solutions, differing from the focus on enhancing existing employee skills.

napolean92728 · Answer

1. Which of the following is a claim made in the passage about labor productivity growth in Germany between 2000 and 2018?

(A) The slowdown in productivity growth after 2012 was primarily caused by a decline in automation and digitalization investments. 
 (B) Sectors that focus heavily on automation consistently outperformed those that did not in terms of productivity growth from 2013 to 2018. 
 (C) Workforce retraining programs contributed significantly to mitigating the slowdown in productivity growth after 2012. 
 (D) Since workforce training accounted for just 12% of productivity growth in the textile sector, technological investments must have driven the remaining gains. 
 (E) Higher labor productivity growth in Germany after 2012 was entirely driven by workforce skills and education.

✅  Explanation for Correct Answer (C): 
The passage specifically discusses a  slowdown in productivity growth in German manufacturing after 2012 , noting that  automation alone was yielding diminishing returns . Importantly, it states: 
 
 This clearly  supports the idea  that  workforce retraining helped to mitigate  (lessen) the productivity slowdown. Hence,  (C) is a correct claim made in the passage .

❌  Why the Other Options Are Incorrect: 
 (A) The slowdown in productivity growth after 2012 was primarily caused by a decline in automation and digitalization investments.  
 
   Incorrect : The passage does  not attribute the slowdown to a decline in automation and digitalization . In fact, it mentions  diminishing returns from automation , not a  decline in investment . The issue was  automation's limited impact over time , not its reduction.

(B) Sectors that focus heavily on automation consistently outperformed those that did not in terms of productivity growth from 2013 to 2018.  
 
   Incorrect : This directly contradicts the passage. The passage states that  automation alone  was insufficient and that sectors with  robust retraining programs outperformed others . So, automation-heavy sectors  without training  did  not consistently outperform  others.

(D) Since workforce training accounted for just 12% of productivity growth in the textile sector, technological investments must have driven the remaining gains.  
 
   Incorrect : This is  speculative . While it's true that workforce training contributed 12% in textiles, the passage  does not specify or quantify  what drove the rest of the growth. It  doesn't confirm  that technology alone drove the remaining 88%.

(E) Higher labor productivity growth in Germany after 2012 was entirely driven by workforce skills and education.  
 
   Incorrect : The passage  never claims  that  workforce skills were the  only  factor  after 2012. It says they became increasingly important, especially as automation's returns diminished. The term  “entirely driven”  overstates the passage’s claim.

2. Based on the information in the passage, it can most reasonably be inferred that sectors in Germany with higher labor productivity growth after 2012

(A) relied heavily on workforce retraining programs and reduced investments in automation. 
 (B) experienced diminishing returns on automation alone, prompting the need for workforce retraining to sustain growth. 
 (C) saw larger productivity gains when both workforce retraining and capital investments were emphasized. 
 (D) primarily belonged to industries with lower capital intensity and simpler supply chains. 
 (E) achieved higher productivity growth due to workforce adjustments in response to demographic shifts and labor shortages.

✅ Explanation for Correct Answer (C):  
 Reasoning for the correct answer: 
The passage provides clear evidence supporting this option: 
 
   Firms with robust retraining outperformed : "firms with robust employee retraining programs outperformed their peers by nearly 40 percent in productivity measures"  
   Technology alone is insufficient : "The notion that technological upgrades alone drive productivity growth is therefore incomplete"  
   High-performing sectors combine both : The passage shows that sectors like pharmaceuticals and precision engineering, which "invest heavily in employee upskilling," achieved higher productivity. These are capital-intensive industries that combine substantial technology investments with workforce development.  
   Capital investment remains crucial : The passage explicitly states "while capital investment remains crucial, human capital development plays an increasingly pivotal role"

❌  Why the Other Options Are Incorrect:  
  (A) relied heavily on workforce retraining programs and reduced investments in automation.  
 
   Incorrect : The passage never suggests reduced automation investments. It emphasizes that capital investment "remains crucial" and that the most successful approach combines both elements.

(B) experienced diminishing returns on automation alone, prompting the need for workforce retraining to sustain growth.  
 
   Incorrect : This describes the problem that led to slower growth, not what characterized the higher-performing sectors. The automotive industry example shows what happened to sectors that experienced diminishing returns.

(D) primarily belonged to industries with lower capital intensity and simpler supply chains.  
 
   Incorrect : The examples given (pharmaceuticals, precision engineering) are actually high capital-intensity industries with complex operations, not simple ones.

(E) achieved higher productivity growth due to workforce adjustments in response to demographic shifts and labor shortages.  
 
   Incorrect : While the passage mentions demographic shifts and labor shortages as future challenges, it doesn't attribute the higher productivity growth after 2012 to responses to these factors.   
 The key insight is that the most successful sectors didn't abandon capital investment but rather complemented it with substantial workforce development, creating a synergistic effect that drove superior productivity growth.

3. A claim made in the passage is that

(A) technological advancements alone were insufficient to sustain long-term labor productivity growth in Germany after 2012. 
 (B) German manufacturing sectors with the highest productivity growth after 2012 did not rely on workforce retraining programs. 
 (C) productivity growth in Germany slowed across all sectors due to a plateau in capital investment and automation. 
 (D) workforce retraining programs contributed to higher productivity growth in industries that had previously relied heavily on automation. 
 (E) industries in Germany with lower productivity growth after 2012 were primarily those with limited technological investment.

✅  Explanation for Correct Answer (A): 
This claim is explicitly supported in the passage. It says: 
 
 and 
 
 These statements  clearly support the claim  that  technological advancements alone were not enough  to sustain productivity growth, especially  after 2012  in Germany. Thus,  (A)  is directly backed by the passage.

❌  Why the Other Options Are Incorrect: 
 (B)   German manufacturing sectors with the highest productivity growth after 2012 did not rely on workforce retraining programs.  
 
   Incorrect : The passage says the  opposite  — firms with robust retraining programs  outperformed  others by nearly  40%  in productivity measures.

(C)   Productivity growth in Germany slowed across all sectors due to a plateau in capital investment and automation.  
 
   Incorrect : The passage attributes the slowdown to  diminishing returns on automation  and a  plateau in workforce skill development ,  not a drop  in capital investment.

(D)   Workforce retraining programs contributed to higher productivity growth in industries that had previously relied heavily on automation.  
 
   Tempting , but  too specific  and  not clearly stated . The passage discusses the  overall impact of retraining , but  does not specify  that these industries had "previously relied heavily on automation" as a prerequisite for benefitting from retraining.

(E)   Industries in Germany with lower productivity growth after 2012 were primarily those with limited technological investment.  
 
   Incorrect : The passage  does not claim  this. It focuses on the importance of  skills and retraining , not suggesting that  lack of tech investment  was the main reason for low productivity.

4. Which of the following situations is most analogous to the problematic situation identified in the passage concerning the reliance on technological advancements to drive productivity growth?

(A) A company reports revenue growth figures without accounting for inflation, leading to an overestimation of the company’s real economic performance. 
 (B) A manager credits the success of a project solely to new software, overlooking the extensive experience-building employees underwent to implement it effectively. 
 (C) A university ranks departments based only on research output, ignoring the contributions of faculty mentoring and student success rates. 
 (D) A construction firm measures productivity by the number of buildings completed but fails to account for the increased use of subcontractors who perform much of the work. 
 (E) A healthcare provider reports improved patient outcomes after adopting new medical equipment but neglects to mention the concurrent hiring of highly specialized staff.

✅  Explanation for Correct Answer (B): 
This closely mirrors the core issue in the passage —  over-reliance on technology  as the sole driver of success,  ignoring the vital contribution of human skills and training .
The passage argues that: 
 
 So (B) draws an accurate analogy:  new software ≈ automation , and  employee experience ≈ workforce retraining . The failure to credit the latter reflects the  same mistaken assumption  critiqued in the passage.

❌  Why the Other Options Are Incorrect: 
 (A)   Revenue figures not adjusted for inflation  
 
   Not analogous : This is about  misleading data interpretation , not about  overvaluing technology  versus human factors.

(C)   University ranks departments based only on research output  
 
   Only loosely related : While this reflects narrow evaluation criteria, it’s about  measurement methods , not reliance on  technology vs. human capital .

(D)   Construction firm doesn’t account for subcontractor use  
 
   Irrelevant : This is a  labor outsourcing  issue, not about  technology vs. skills .

(E)   Healthcare provider highlights tech but not specialized staff  
 
   Partially similar , but the focus is on  hiring , not  training or skill development , and it’s not as directly analogous as (B).

The concept of labor productivity growth has long been a key

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

The concept of labor productivity growth has long been a key

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards