Here are the official solutions:
Q1. According to the passage, which of the following most accurately characterizes the relationship between the Chinese fleet and the foreign ambassadors they encountered during the Ming treasure voyages?
Explanation:
(A): Incorrect. The passage does not suggest that the ambassadors were brought back as a show of military superiority. While the Chinese fleet was heavily militarized, the passage emphasizes political and economic control rather than military dominance. Therefore, this option misrepresents the nature of the relationship between the fleet and the ambassadors.
(B): Incorrect. The passage states that foreign rulers were willing to declare themselves tributaries of China, meaning there was no coercion involved. This option incorrectly implies that the ambassadors were forced into allegiance, which is not supported by the text.
(C): Correct. The passage clearly states that foreign rulers were willing to declare themselves tributaries of China, which aligns with the idea that the ambassadors were brought back voluntarily. This option accurately reflects the passage's description of the relationship between the Chinese fleet and the foreign ambassadors.
(D): Incorrect. While the passage mentions that the Chinese were motivated by political and economic control, it does not suggest that they sought long-term political alliances to secure trade monopolies. This option introduces the idea of monopolies, which is not discussed in the passage.
(E): Incorrect. The passage focuses on political and economic control through the tributary system rather than mutual economic growth. This option misinterprets the purpose of the diplomatic relations established during the voyages.
Q2. Which of the following, if true, would most undermine Ray’s position regarding the efficiency of the Chinese state-controlled maritime trade during the Ming dynasty?
Explanation:
(A): Correct. This option directly contradicts Ray’s position by indicating that state control led to inefficiency and increased costs, which undermines his argument that the voyages were profitable and efficient under government control.
(B): Incorrect. This option supports Ray’s view that the state-controlled voyages were profitable, and it implies that government involvement did not hinder economic success.
(C): Incorrect. While this option introduces bureaucratic interference, it does not speak to the inefficiency of state control itself. Instead, it implies that private interests sought to undermine state control, which aligns with Ray’s argument.
(D): Incorrect. This supports Ray’s position by suggesting that state control allowed the voyages to manage a profitable network of trade routes, reinforcing the efficiency of the system.
(E): Incorrect. This option discusses the success of private merchants after the voyages ended but does not address or refute Ray’s argument about the efficiency of the state-controlled voyages during the Ming dynasty.
Q3. Which of the following best describes the primary purpose of the passage?
Correct Answer: (E)
Explanation:
(A): Incorrect. This option incorrectly emphasizes territorial expansion, which the passage explicitly states was not a goal of the Ming treasure voyages. The Chinese were not seeking territorial control but rather political and economic dominance through the tribute system and trade networks. As the passage highlights their non-expansionist motives, this option misrepresents the main focus.
(B): Incorrect. While the passage discusses the voyages' effects on trade and political relationships, it does not deeply analyze their impact on global trade or alliances. The passage is more focused on the reasons the voyages stopped, particularly the debate about financial and political sustainability, making this option an incomplete representation of the passage’s main point.
(C): Incorrect. This option is close but not fully accurate because it emphasizes the debate about why the voyages ended while neglecting the equally important discussion of the fleet’s success. The passage balances both the success of the voyages and the reasons they ceased, so this option doesn’t fully capture the dual focus of the passage.
(D): Incorrect. This option places too much emphasis on military power, which is not the central theme of the passage. While the fleet was militarized, the passage focuses on political and economic control, not military dominance over maritime trade or territories. Therefore, this option misrepresents the passage’s main point.
(E): Correct. This option accurately captures the primary purpose of the passage, which is twofold: it discusses the success of the Ming treasure fleet in projecting Chinese power and restructuring trade networks, and it examines the reasons for the cessation of the voyages, including the debate among scholars about financial and political factors. This option best reflects the passage’s comprehensive discussion of both the voyages' achievements and the reasons for their end.
Q4. Which of the following best describes the structure of the final paragraph of the passage?
Correct Answer: (D)
Explanation of Answers:
(A): Incorrect. The final paragraph does present conflicting viewpoints, but the author does not provide evidence supporting one of the viewpoints over the others. The passage remains neutral in its presentation of multiple scholarly opinions, so this option misrepresents the author's stance.
(B): Incorrect. The paragraph does not introduce a single explanation and then refutes it. Instead, it discusses several scholarly perspectives on why the voyages ended without prioritizing one over another.
(C): Incorrect. While multiple theories are presented, the paragraph does not evaluate the validity of each theory. The author presents the perspectives of different scholars without making judgments or analyzing the strength of each viewpoint, so this option misinterprets the structure.
(D): Correct. The author presents competing interpretations from different scholars (e.g., Duyvendak, Ray, Finlay, and Dreyer) regarding the reasons for the cessation of the Ming treasure voyages. However, the author does not take a position or endorse any particular explanation, which makes this option the best fit for describing the structure of the final paragraph.
(E): Incorrect. The final paragraph does not discuss the success of the voyages; it focuses solely on the reasons for their cessation. This option adds an element ("discusses the success of the voyages") that is not present in the paragraph, making it an inaccurate description of the structure.