The study of gene editing technologies, particularly CRISPR-Cas9, has

Question

The study of gene editing technologies, particularly CRISPR-Cas9, has rapidly transformed the field of genetics. This breakthrough allows for precise modifications to DNA, offering the potential to cure genetic diseases, enhance agricultural productivity, and even extend human life expectancy. However, the ethical and societal implications of such technologies are complex and contentious, and their widespread use raises significant concerns about unintended consequences.

One of the most pressing issues is the possibility of “designer babies,” where genetic modifications could be made to embryos to select for specific traits, such as intelligence or physical appearance. This opens up the possibility of genetic inequality, where only the wealthy could afford to enhance their children’s genetic traits, leading to a further stratification of society. Additionally, there are fears that such technologies could be misused for less noble purposes, such as creating genetically modified organisms (GMOs) for military or commercial exploitation.

While the benefits of gene editing are clear, there is a pressing need for international collaboration to establish clear guidelines and regulations. Without a global framework, individual countries might pursue divergent paths in the development and application of gene editing, potentially leading to harmful outcomes. For instance, one country might allow genetic modifications that could have unforeseen ecological consequences, such as the introduction of modified crops that disrupt local ecosystems. Conversely, another country might ban gene editing altogether, preventing its citizens from accessing potentially life-saving treatments.

Governments and scientific communities must therefore work together to create a balanced approach to gene editing. This should be done through a coordinated international effort that addresses three key areas: (1) fostering open, transparent discussions about the risks and benefits of gene editing, while focusing on understanding its potential consequences; (2) securing funding and political support for large-scale, controversial experiments, ensuring that these studies are conducted under strict ethical oversight and peer review; and (3) developing international norms and regulations to guide the testing, application, and possible deployment of gene editing technologies. In this way, scientists and policymakers can collaborate to ensure that the power of gene editing is harnessed responsibly, minimizing harm and maximizing its potential for good.    1 
 1. Which of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?
 
A. CRISPR-Cas9 technology represents a revolutionary breakthrough in genetics that could lead to significant advances in medicine and agriculture.
B. While gene editing offers significant benefits, an international framework for regulation and collaboration is needed to ensure responsible development and implementation of these technologies.
C. The primary concern with gene editing technology is the creation of "designer babies," which could exacerbate social inequality and lead to ethical complications.
D. Scientists and governments must work together to conduct controversial experiments in gene editing while maintaining strict ethical oversight and peer review.
E. The rapid advancement of gene editing technologies has created a divide between countries that embrace genetic modification and those that ban it entirely.

2  
 2. The passage indicates that, at the time the passage was written, discussion of gene editing tended

A) to assume that the benefits of gene editing will be universally accessible without significant ethical concerns.
B) to be focused on the potential of gene editing to enhance human life expectancy, without addressing its societal implications.
C) to ignore the need for international collaboration in developing guidelines and regulations for gene editing.
D) to be primarily concerned with the technical aspects of gene editing, with little regard for its ethical and societal consequences.
E) not to involve a focused assessment of the concrete risks and ethical dilemmas associated with gene editing technologies.

3  
  3. The passage most strongly implies which of the following?
 
A) The easiest and most cost-effective means of gene editing is likely to be genetic modification of embryos to enhance specific traits.
B) The potential benefits of gene editing will outweigh the ethical concerns, making it an inevitable technology for future use.
C) Without international collaboration, gene editing technologies will certainly be misused, leading to significant societal and ecological risks.
D) Gene editing will ultimately be banned globally due to concerns about genetic inequality and misuse.
E) Embryos genetically modified for better physical appearance could eventually lead to a further divided society.

4  
  4. Which of the following most accurately describes the structure of the passage as a whole?  
 
A) A problem is introduced in the first paragraph, a solution is proposed in the second paragraph, and the solution is expanded upon and justified in the following paragraphs.
B) A claim is made in the first paragraph, followed by a detailed explanation in the second and third paragraph, and the final paragraph outlines the ethical implications of the issue.
C) A problem is raised in the first paragraph, followed by an argument supporting the seriousness of the issue in the second and third paragraphs, and a proposed solution is presented in the final paragraph.
D) The passage begins with a problem, followed by a suggested solution, a critique of that solution, and an alternative solution presented with supporting details in the final paragraph.
E) The first paragraph presents a general view, which is later challenged in the second and third paragraphs, and possible ways to address the challenges are offered in the final paragraph.

Check the links to other Butler Projects:

Problem Solving Butler  
  Data Sufficiency Butler  
  Critical Reasoning Butler  
  Reading Comprehension Butler  
  Data Insights Butler

cdrectenwald · Answer

Is it just me but there's not a timer/answer choices above each question?

Anyways, here is what I like for the passage:

Which of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?
Answer: B.
Explanation: The passage explains the potential benefits of gene editing but emphasizes the need for an international regulatory framework to manage its ethical and societal implications.

The passage indicates that, at the time the passage was written, discussion of gene editing tended
Answer: C.
Explanation: The text stresses a “pressing need for international collaboration” and implies that current discussions did not adequately address the need for global guidelines and regulations.

The passage most strongly implies which of the following?
Answer: E.
Explanation: The passage raises concerns about the possibility of “designer babies” and the subsequent risk of deepening social inequality, making option E the best reflection of its implications.

Which of the following most accurately describes the structure of the passage as a whole?
Answer: C.
Explanation: The passage begins by introducing the promise and challenges of gene editing, then elaborates on the ethical, societal, and international concerns in subsequent paragraphs, and finally outlines a solution through international cooperation.

Whoisdmx15 · Answer

cdrectenwald  No timer attempt for me too.

1. Which of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?

A. CRISPR-Cas9 technology represents a revolutionary breakthrough in genetics that could lead to significant advances in medicine and agriculture.  Eliminated  Several other implications of the tech has been elaborated in subsequent paragraphs.
B.  While gene editing offers significant benefits, an international framework for regulation and collaboration is needed to ensure responsible development and implementation of these technologies .  Suitable  This is the main point of the passage as summarized in para 4.
C. The primary concern with gene editing technology is the creation of "designer babies," which could exacerbate social inequality and lead to ethical complications.  Eliminated  Although listed as one of the concerns, this has not been indicated to be the primary concern, additionally only concerns is not the main point of the passage.
D. Scientists and governments must work together to conduct controversial experiments in gene editing while maintaining strict ethical oversight and peer review.  Eliminated  Although listed as one of the measures required to be taken, this does not encapsulate the passage as a whole.
E. The rapid advancement of gene editing technologies has created a divide between countries that embrace genetic modification and those that ban it entirely.  Eliminated  Although listed as one of the measures required to be taken, this does not encapsulate the passage as a whole.

2. The passage indicates that, at the time the passage was written, discussion of gene editing tended

A) to assume that the benefits of gene editing will be universally accessible without significant ethical concerns.  Eliminated  This was being talked about, can be inferred from " However, the ethical and societal implications of such technologies are complex and contentious, and their widespread use raises significant concerns about unintended consequences 
B) to be focused on the potential of gene editing to enhance human life expectancy, without addressing its societal implications.  Eliminated The implementations was not limited to human gene editing. This has been introduced as a pressing issue, hence the social implications were being considered.
C)  to ignore the need for international collaboration in developing guidelines and regulations for gene editing .  Suitable  Can be inferred from " While the benefits of gene editing are clear, there is a pressing need for international collaboration to establish clear guidelines and regulations ."
D) to be primarily concerned with the technical aspects of gene editing, with little regard for its ethical and societal consequences.  Eliminated  There was due regard being given to ethical and social consequences, can be inferred from " However, the ethical and societal implications of such technologies are complex and contentious, and their widespread use raises significant concerns about unintended consequences 
E) not to involve a focused assessment of the concrete risks and ethical dilemmas associated with gene editing technologies. There was due regard being given to ethical and social consequences, can be inferred from " However, the ethical and societal implications of such technologies are complex and contentious, and their widespread use raises significant concerns about unintended consequences

3. The passage most strongly implies which of the following?

A) The easiest and most cost-effective means of gene editing is likely to be genetic modification of embryos to enhance specific traits.  Eliminated  These have not been mentioned as easiest and most cost effective means.
B) The potential benefits of gene editing will outweigh the ethical concerns, making it an inevitable technology for future use.  Eliminated  potential benefits of gene editing will outweigh the ethical concerns has not been indicated.
C) Without international collaboration, gene editing technologies will certainly be misused, leading to significant societal and ecological risks.  Eliminated  Extreme statement, one possibility has been represented as certainty.
D) Gene editing will ultimately be banned globally due to concerns about genetic inequality and misuse.  Eliminated  Extreme sentence, not necessarily will this tech be banned.
E)  Embryos genetically modified for better physical appearance could eventually lead to a further divided society .  Suitable  Can be inferred from " genetic modifications could be made to embryos to select for specific traits, such as intelligence or physical appearance. This opens up the possibility of genetic inequality, where only the wealthy could afford to enhance their children’s genetic traits, leading to a further stratification of society ."

4. Which of the following most accurately describes the structure of the passage as a whole?

A) A problem is introduced in the first paragraph, a solution is proposed in the second paragraph, and the solution is expanded upon and justified in the following paragraphs. Eliminated  Solution proposed in last paragraph
B) A claim is made in the first paragraph, followed by a detailed explanation in the second and third paragraph, and the final paragraph outlines the ethical implications of the issue. Eliminated  No claim made in first paragraph
C)  A problem is raised in the first paragraph, followed by an argument supporting the seriousness of the issue in the second and third paragraphs, and a proposed solution is presented in the final paragraph . Suitable  
D) The passage begins with a problem, followed by a suggested solution, a critique of that solution, and an alternative solution presented with supporting details in the final paragraph. Eliminated  No suggested solution follows the problem raised. It is provided in the very last
E) The first paragraph presents a general view, which is later challenged in the second and third paragraphs, and possible ways to address the challenges are offered in the final paragraph. Eliminated  The view has not been challenged anywhere.

Bunuel · Answer

Official Solution:

1. Which of the following most accurately states the main point of the passage?

A. CRISPR-Cas9 technology represents a revolutionary breakthrough in genetics that could lead to significant advances in medicine and agriculture.
B. While gene editing offers significant benefits, an international framework for regulation and collaboration is needed to ensure responsible development and implementation of these technologies.
C. The primary concern with gene editing technology is the creation of "designer babies," which could exacerbate social inequality and lead to ethical complications.
D. Scientists and governments must work together to conduct controversial experiments in gene editing while maintaining strict ethical oversight and peer review.
E. The rapid advancement of gene editing technologies has created a divide between countries that embrace genetic modification and those that ban it entirely.

A. While true, this is only the introductory context and doesn't capture the passage's main argument about the need for international cooperation.

B. Correct. This option captures the passage's central argument that while gene editing has benefits, international cooperation is crucial for proper regulation and implementation. This reflects both the benefits and concerns discussed, as well as the passage's emphasis on the need for a coordinated global approach.

C. Designer babies are just one example of the concerns mentioned, not the main point of the passage. 
 
D. This represents only one part of the three-key-areas solution proposed, not the main point of the entire passage. 
 
E. This misrepresents the passage - while the passage mentions this as a potential risk, it's not presented as a current reality or the main point.

2. The passage indicates that, at the time the passage was written, discussion of gene editing tended

A) to assume that the benefits of gene editing will be universally accessible without significant ethical concerns.
B) to be focused on the potential of gene editing to enhance human life expectancy, without addressing its societal implications.
C) to ignore the need for international collaboration in developing guidelines and regulations for gene editing.
D) to be primarily concerned with the technical aspects of gene editing, with little regard for its ethical and societal consequences.
E) not to involve a focused assessment of the concrete risks and ethical dilemmas associated with gene editing technologies.

A) Incorrect:  The passage does not suggest that the benefits of gene editing will be universally accessible; it highlights concerns about inequality. 
  
B) Incorrect:  The passage discusses both the benefits and the ethical concerns, not just focusing on life expectancy. 
  
C) Incorrect:  The passage stresses the need for international collaboration, not that it was ignored. 
  
D) Incorrect:  While the passage mentions the technical aspects, it does not imply that these were the primary focus of discussions. 
  
E) Correct:  The passage points out that there is a need for focused assessment of the risks and ethical dilemmas of gene editing, which was not adequately addressed in prior discussions.

3. The passage most strongly implies which of the following?
 
A) The easiest and most cost-effective means of gene editing is likely to be genetic modification of embryos to enhance specific traits.
B) The potential benefits of gene editing will outweigh the ethical concerns, making it an inevitable technology for future use.
C) Without international collaboration, gene editing technologies will certainly be misused, leading to significant societal and ecological risks.
D) Gene editing will ultimately be banned globally due to concerns about genetic inequality and misuse.
E) Embryos genetically modified for better physical appearance could eventually lead to a further divided society.

A) Incorrect:  The passage does not focus on genetic modification of embryos for specific traits like physical appearance. It discusses the broader ethical concerns and societal implications. 
  
B) Incorrect:  The passage does not suggest that the benefits of gene editing will outweigh the ethical concerns. Instead, it emphasizes the need for careful consideration and regulation of the technology. 
  
C) Incorrect:  While international collaboration is important, the passage does not imply that gene editing technologies will certainly be misused without it. It emphasizes the need for regulation and ethical oversight. 
  
D) Incorrect:  The passage does not suggest that gene editing will be banned globally but advocates for international cooperation and regulation. 
   
E) Correct:     The passage discusses the potential for genetic inequality, particularly through the possibility of "designer babies," which could lead to a divided society based on access to genetic enhancements. This option captures the passage's concerns about social stratification.

4. Which of the following most accurately describes the structure of the passage as a whole?  
 
A) A problem is introduced in the first paragraph, a solution is proposed in the second paragraph, and the solution is expanded upon and justified in the following paragraphs.
B) A claim is made in the first paragraph, followed by a detailed explanation in the second and third paragraph, and the final paragraph outlines the ethical implications of the issue.
C) A problem is raised in the first paragraph, followed by an argument supporting the seriousness of the issue in the second and third paragraphs, and a proposed solution is presented in the final paragraph.
D) The passage begins with a problem, followed by a suggested solution, a critique of that solution, and an alternative solution presented with supporting details in the final paragraph.
E) The first paragraph presents a general view, which is later challenged in the second and third paragraphs, and possible ways to address the challenges are offered in the final paragraph.

A) Incorrect:  While a solution is proposed, it is not clearly fleshed out in later paragraphs; instead, the passage focuses on the complexities of gene editing and its ethical implications.
 
B) Incorrect:  The final paragraph discusses the need for international collaboration and regulation, rather than focusing on the ethical implications of the solution.
  
C) Correct:    This option accurately reflects the structure of the passage: the problem (gene editing's ethical concerns) is introduced in the first paragraph, the seriousness of the issue is elaborated upon in the second and third paragraphs, and the solution (international cooperation and regulation) is proposed in the final paragraph. 
 
D) Incorrect:  While a solution is suggested, the passage doesn't critique it in the third paragraph, nor does it present an alternative solution in the final paragraph.
 
E) Incorrect:  The passage doesn't present a general view to be challenged but instead addresses the complexity of the issue and the need for careful regulation and oversight.

bb · Answer

Sorry about that. Added the timer back.

The study of gene editing technologies, particularly CRISPR-Cas9, has

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

The study of gene editing technologies, particularly CRISPR-Cas9, has

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards