Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Senior Manager
Joined: 10 Oct 2005
Posts: 351
Location: US

There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 19 May 2014, 07:45
Question Stats:
37% (02:54) correct 63% (02:50) wrong based on 483 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
There are three secretaries who work for four departments. If each of the four departments have one report to be typed out, and the reports are randomly assigned to a secretary, what is the probability that all three secretary are assigned at least one report? A. 8/9 B. 64/81 C. 4/9 D. 16/81 E. 5/9
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
Originally posted by mahesh004 on 15 Jul 2006, 01:02.
Last edited by Bunuel on 19 May 2014, 07:45, edited 1 time in total.
Added the options and OA.




Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9850
Location: Pune, India

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Feb 2015, 21:23
Lapetiteflo wrote: Hi, I have Big troubles with this question. We havé total possibilities N =3^4 Then we can say that the probability to give at least one report to each secretary is the opposite of giving no report to at least one secretary. So evaluating this proba : ways to choose 1 secretary among 3 (she will not be assigned any report)=3 ways to affect 4 reports to 2 secretaries (it can be just one if ever) : examples (1122) assigns 2 first reports to secretary 1 and two last one to secretary 2. There are 2^4 possibilities (1111,1112,1122,....)
So result is 1(3*2^4)/3^4=11/27.
The true result is 12/26.... Could you explain where is my mistake ? Thanks a lot Marie "We havé total possibilities N =3^4" What are these total possibilities? They are the ways in which the 4 reports can be distributed among 3 secretaries so that all reports may go to one secretary, the reports may be distributed among 2 secretaries or they may be distributed among all 3. So such cases are included (4, 0, 0), (0, 4, 0), (2, 2, 0), (1, 3, 0), (1, 1, 2), etc In how many ways can you give 4 reports to only 1 secretary? You choose the secretary who will get the reports in 3C1 = 3 ways In how many ways can you give 4 reports to only 2 secretaries? Choose the 2 secretaries in 3C2 ways. Each secretary must get at least one report so you can distribute them in 2 ways: '1 and 3'  Choose one report in 4C1 ways and give it to one secretary in 2C1 ways. The other secretary gets the other 3 reports. or '2 and 2'  Choose 2 reports in 4C2 ways and give to the first secretary. The other secretary gets the other two reports. Total number of ways is 3C2 * (4C1*2C1 + 4C2) = 42 ways Note that in your method 2^4 is incorrect. It includes the ways in which all 4 reports go to one secretary. So this means that in 3 + 42 = 45 ways, at least one secretary gets no report. In the rest of 81  45 = 36 ways, each secretary gets at least one report. Required Probability = 36/81 = 12/27
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >




SVP
Joined: 20 Nov 2005
Posts: 2127
Schools: Completed at SAID BUSINESS SCHOOL, OXFORD  Class of 2008

Total outcomes = 3^4 = 81
When each secretary is assigned atleast 1 report then two report will be assigned to 1 and 1 report each to remaining two.
Favourable outcomes = (Ways to select two report) * (Ways to select 1 seceratry) * (Ways to assign two report to two secretaries)
= (4C2) * (3C1) * (2!) = 36
Prob = 36/81
_________________
SAID BUSINESS SCHOOL, OXFORD  MBA CLASS OF 2008




Director
Joined: 13 Nov 2003
Posts: 632
Location: BULGARIA

Not pretty sure but think that the prob of any secretary typing a report 1/3 and NOT typing a reports is 2/3. Then the prob of NOT typing any of the reports is 16/81. We have 3 secretaries then 48/81 is the prob that one of them will not have a report to type. The required prob is 148/81=33/81=11/27



Senior Manager
Joined: 10 Oct 2005
Posts: 351
Location: US

Posting answer 
For each report there are three possible outcomes: Secretary A, Secretary B, Secretary C
Total outcome: 3^3=27
Total outcome that three secretary are assigned at least one report: P(3,3)=3!=6
Probability = 6/27=2/9



SVP
Joined: 20 Nov 2005
Posts: 2127
Schools: Completed at SAID BUSINESS SCHOOL, OXFORD  Class of 2008

mahesh004 wrote: Posting answer 
For each report there are three possible outcomes: Secretary A, Secretary B, Secretary C Total outcome: 3^3=27 Total outcome that three secretary are assigned at least one report: P(3,3)=3!=6 Probability = 6/27=2/9
What about fourth report?
This is wrong solution. See this:
http://www.gmatclub.com/phpbb/viewtopic.php?t=14706
_________________
SAID BUSINESS SCHOOL, OXFORD  MBA CLASS OF 2008



SVP
Joined: 06 Sep 2013
Posts: 1545
Concentration: Finance

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Dec 2013, 11:31
mahesh004 wrote: There are three secretaries who work for four departments. If each of the four departments have one report to be typed out, and the reports are randomly assigned to a secretary, what is the probability that all three secretary are assigned at least one report? I got the same answer: Here's my reasoning First Report you have 3 choices Second Report you have 2 choices Third Report you have 1 choice Fourth report 3 choices again Then total number of ways is: 3*2*1*3=3^2*2 Total number of possibiliities = 3^4 So probability = 2/9 Please advice if this is the correct answer Cheers! J



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9850
Location: Pune, India

mahesh004 wrote: Posting answer 
For each report there are three possible outcomes: Secretary A, Secretary B, Secretary C Total outcome: 3^3=27 Total outcome that three secretary are assigned at least one report: P(3,3)=3!=6 Probability = 6/27=2/9 Here you are assuming there are 3 reports and 3 secretaries. But you are given that there are 4 reports (from 4 departments). Hence this is not correct.
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9850
Location: Pune, India

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Dec 2013, 21:56
jlgdr wrote: mahesh004 wrote: There are three secretaries who work for four departments. If each of the four departments have one report to be typed out, and the reports are randomly assigned to a secretary, what is the probability that all three secretary are assigned at least one report? I got the same answer: Here's my reasoning First Report you have 3 choices Second Report you have 2 choices Third Report you have 1 choice Fourth report 3 choices again Then total number of ways is: 3*2*1*3=3^2*2 This is not correct. You have assumed that the 4th report must go to someone who already has a report. There is no such constraint. You can easily give the 1st and 2nd reports to secretary 1, 3rd report to secretary 2 and 4th report to secretary 3. But you have ignored all such cases. The number of ways of ensuring at least one report goes to each secretary is 4C2 (select 2 reports out of 4 which go to the same person)*3C1 (select the person who must type 2 reports)*2! (since you have 2 reports left which you must distribute to the 2 remaining people such that each person gets one) = 36 Required probability = 36/81
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Senior Manager
Joined: 17 Sep 2013
Posts: 318
Concentration: Strategy, General Management
WE: Analyst (Consulting)

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 May 2014, 09:25
What is wrong with.. Choose 3 out of 4 letters...4C3..assign them to each secretary...4C3 * 3! ways Assign the remaining letter to any secretary: 3 ways = 72/81



Intern
Joined: 17 May 2014
Posts: 36

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
Updated on: 18 May 2014, 20:17
JusTLucK04 wrote: What is wrong with.. Choose 3 out of 4 letters...4C3..assign them to each secretary...4C3 * 3! ways Assign the remaining letter to any secretary: 3 ways = 72/81 Lets take an example to understand this. Lets say, we have 2 persons and 3 reports a, b,c. Then lets try and apply you logic: 3C2 =3. They can be given in 2! ways = 3*2 =6 1st 2nd a b (1) b c c a b a c b (2) a c All right till here I suppose. Now the third report can be given in 2 ways, but you will see that there are repetitions. (1) and (2) will produce the same result, ie ac,b and ac, b. Hence duplication. The problem with your approach is, you are trying to arrange all the reports, and therefore concerned about the fact the which report is given to him first, which is immaterial for our analysis. Hope it works!!! In fact, as you notice that a person getting two reports A and B can get it in 2 ways, A followed by B and otherwise, but it should be considered as a single case. Therefore, you need to divide 72 by 2 to get 36.
Originally posted by mittalg on 18 May 2014, 09:47.
Last edited by mittalg on 18 May 2014, 20:17, edited 1 time in total.



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9850
Location: Pune, India

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 May 2014, 20:17
JusTLucK04 wrote: What is wrong with.. Choose 3 out of 4 letters...4C3..assign them to each secretary...4C3 * 3! ways Assign the remaining letter to any secretary: 3 ways = 72/81 Using your logic, "Reports R1, R2 and R3 are selected and given to secretaries A, B and C respectively and then report R4 is given to A", is a different case from "reports R2, R3 and R4 are selected and given to secretaries C, B and A respectively and then report R1 is given to A". But actually both cases are same because A gets R1 and R4, B gets R2 and C gets R3. So there is double counting.
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Senior Manager
Joined: 17 Sep 2013
Posts: 318
Concentration: Strategy, General Management
WE: Analyst (Consulting)

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 May 2014, 22:24
VeritasPrepKarishma wrote: JusTLucK04 wrote: What is wrong with.. Choose 3 out of 4 letters...4C3..assign them to each secretary...4C3 * 3! ways Assign the remaining letter to any secretary: 3 ways = 72/81 Using your logic, "Reports R1, R2 and R3 are selected and given to secretaries A, B and C respectively and then report R4 is given to A", is a different case from "reports R2, R3 and R4 are selected and given to secretaries C, B and A respectively and then report R1 is given to A". But actually both cases are same because A gets R1 and R4, B gets R2 and C gets R3. So there is double counting. Ohh..Is there any foolproof specific approach for such problems so that we avoid such errors..Quite hard to catch them on the xam



Intern
Joined: 17 May 2014
Posts: 36

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 May 2014, 22:40
JusTLucK04 wrote: VeritasPrepKarishma wrote: JusTLucK04 wrote: What is wrong with.. Choose 3 out of 4 letters...4C3..assign them to each secretary...4C3 * 3! ways Assign the remaining letter to any secretary: 3 ways = 72/81 Using your logic, "Reports R1, R2 and R3 are selected and given to secretaries A, B and C respectively and then report R4 is given to A", is a different case from "reports R2, R3 and R4 are selected and given to secretaries C, B and A respectively and then report R1 is given to A". But actually both cases are same because A gets R1 and R4, B gets R2 and C gets R3. So there is double counting. Ohh..Is there any foolproof specific approach for such problems so that we avoid such errors..Quite hard to catch them on the xam Try to think about the solution in the way you will actually do it in practice. You should always try and assume a case to verify an answer as has been done by Karishma. I would say more practice will make you confident on these kinds of questions and enlighten you on the mistakes you may commit.



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9850
Location: Pune, India

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 May 2014, 02:26
JusTLucK04 wrote: Ohh..Is there any foolproof specific approach for such problems so that we avoid such errors..Quite hard to catch them on the xam
Double counting is a very common mistake people new to P&C make  don't worry about it. Once you practice more, you will get used to taking a step back and ensuring that you are not double counting.
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Manager
Joined: 04 Jan 2014
Posts: 94

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 May 2014, 07:27
How do we get the total outcomes as \(3^4\)= 81 ?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59587

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 May 2014, 07:48
pretzel wrote: How do we get the total outcomes as \(3^4\)= 81 ? Each of the four reports can be assigned to any of the three secretaries, so each report has 3 options, total = 3*3*3*3.
_________________



Intern
Joined: 12 Jul 2014
Posts: 3
Concentration: Entrepreneurship, Social Entrepreneurship
GMAT Date: 10232014
GPA: 4
WE: Sales (Retail)

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
17 Jul 2014, 16:14
VeritasPrepKarishma wrote: jlgdr wrote: mahesh004 wrote: There are three secretaries who work for four departments. If each of the four departments have one report to be typed out, and the reports are randomly assigned to a secretary, what is the probability that all three secretary are assigned at least one report? I got the same answer: Here's my reasoning First Report you have 3 choices Second Report you have 2 choices Third Report you have 1 choice Fourth report 3 choices again Then total number of ways is: 3*2*1*3=3^2*2 This is not correct. You have assumed that the 4th report must go to someone who already has a report. There is no such constraint. You can easily give the 1st and 2nd reports to secretary 1, 3rd report to secretary 2 and 4th report to secretary 3. But you have ignored all such cases. The number of ways of ensuring at least one report goes to each secretary is 4C2 (select 2 reports out of 4 which go to the same person)*3C1 (select the person who must type 2 reports)*2! (since you have 2 reports left which you must distribute to the 2 remaining people such that each person gets one) = 36 Required probability = 36/81 Can someone explain why we must select the person who must type two reports (3C1)? That feels to me like doublecounting, because in my mind, I feel like we already selected that person with 4C2. I'd like to know to understand completely so I don't continue to make mistakes on these kinds of problems. Thanks!



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9850
Location: Pune, India

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
17 Jul 2014, 21:34
napoleonsselfie wrote: The number of ways of ensuring at least one report goes to each secretary is 4C2 (select 2 reports out of 4 which go to the same person)*3C1 (select the person who must type 2 reports)*2! (since you have 2 reports left which you must distribute to the 2 remaining people such that each person gets one) = 36
Required probability = 36/81
Can someone explain why we must select the person who must type two reports (3C1)? That feels to me like doublecounting, because in my mind, I feel like we already selected that person with 4C2. I'd like to know to understand completely so I don't continue to make mistakes on these kinds of problems. Thanks!
So here is the sequence of events you must follow: Pick two reports out of 4 (R1, R2, R3, R4). You can do this in 4C2 ways such as (R1, R2) or (R1, R3) or (R2, R4) etc Now go to the secretaries and select one secy from the 3 and hand over the two reports to her. You can do this in 3C1 ways such as A or B or C. Now you have 2 reports and 2 secys. You can give them the reports in 2! ways.
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Intern
Joined: 09 Dec 2014
Posts: 5
Concentration: Economics, Finance
GPA: 4

Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
Show Tags
10 Feb 2015, 16:08
Hi, I have Big troubles with this question. We havé total possibilities N =3^4 Then we can say that the probability to give at least one report to each secretary is the opposite of giving no report to at least one secretary. So evaluating this proba : ways to choose 1 secretary among 3 (she will not be assigned any report)=3 ways to affect 4 reports to 2 secretaries (it can be just one if ever) : examples (1122) assigns 2 first reports to secretary 1 and two last one to secretary 2. There are 2^4 possibilities (1111,1112,1122,....)
So result is 1(3*2^4)/3^4=11/27.
The true result is 12/26.... Could you explain where is my mistake ? Thanks a lot Marie




Re: There are three secretaries who work for four departments.
[#permalink]
10 Feb 2015, 16:08



Go to page
1 2
Next
[ 36 posts ]



