Bunuel
Three filling pipes R, S and T together can fill an empty tank in 2 hours, S can fill the tank four times faster than T. Initially R alone is opened and after 'x' hours, it is closed and immediately S and T are opened together. The tank is full after another 'y' hours. If the tank was filled in a total of 4 hours, and x is not equal to y, what is the time (in hours) that T alone would take to fill the tank?
(A) 6
(B) 12
(C) 20
(D) 24
(E) 28
Are You Up For the Challenge: 700 Level QuestionsFirst of all, this is a problem solving question so it is bound to have a unique solution.
All three together take 2 hrs so their combines rate is 1/2 tank per hour.
But R is opened alone separately and S and T are opened together but independently of R. The time taken in this case is 4 hrs, twice of time taken before. This happens when the rate of work of 2 individuals/groups is equal. When they work together, time taken is half of time taken when they work independently.
So rate of R must be equal to rate of S and T together.
If rate of T is T, rate of S is 4T (four times rate of T). Then rate of R is 5T (same as combined rate of S and T).
Combined rate of all three = T + 4T + 5T = 10T = 1/2 tank per hour
Rate of T = 1/20th tank per hour
Time taken by T alone is 20 hrs.
Answer (C)
Note that it doesn't matter what x and y are. They could be 1 and 3 respectively or 1.5 and 2.5 or 2.1 and 1.9 etc. Since both the rates are same ('Rate of R alone' = 'Rate of S+T') time taken will be 4 hrs only. Whether we make only R work or S and T work, it has the same effect.
For more on this, check out the work-rate module here using the 3 day trial:
https://anaprep.com