To determine whether one species blocks another out of an area, one

Question

New Project RC Butler 2019  -  Practice 2 RC Passages Everyday   
Passage # 341, Date : 20-Sep-2019
 This post is a part of New Project RC Butler 2019 .  Click here for Details

To determine whether one species blocks another out of an area, one approach is to infer assembly rules, which reconstruct the sequence in which species were added to an evolving community. For example, the presence of a plant species might support the establishment of a beetle that feeds on the plant, and a wasp that in turn parasitizes the beetle. Each of these species, like a puzzle piece, might block the entry of some competing species into the community. But whether a species holds an exclusive functional place cannot easily be identified by studying a community as an isolated unit; local communities are not isolated assemblages and are better thought of as members of a metacommunity of linked smaller ecosystems. Consequently, observing the existence of two functionally similar species in a particular community could reflect that there is room for both species in the assembly or that they really belong to what are mostly distinct, neighboring communities. For example, in a particular brackish coastal lagoon, the species scophtalmus rhombus and solea solea are not only both fish, but have comparable functional traits such as eye diameters, caudal fin aspect ratios, and length-to-body-depth ratios. This functional similarity could imply mutual exclusivity, but another possibility is that scophtalmus rhombus and solea solea occupy positions in the same community within the lagoon, perhaps because food is abundant or because they are less functionally similar than they appear; another is that they occupy exclusive positions in neighboring communities within that lagoon or the mouth of that lagoon to the coastal seas, and they fact that they have been found near each other reflects an exception rather than the rule.   1 
 A 
 1. The passage mentions which of the following as a factor that implies that  scophtalmus rhombus  and  solea solea  might not tend to coexist in the same ecosystem?

A. The degree to which they are functionally similar
B. The degree to which other animals within that ecosystem prey on both  scophtalmus rhombus  and  solea solea 
C. The fact that communities are not isolated entities and are better thought of as members of groups of ecosystems
D. The similarity of the ratio of the species' dorsal fin to body length
E. The degree to which prey are abundant in a particular ecosystem

2 
 C 
 2. Which of the following hypothetical experiments most clearly exemplifies the method of identifying species' roles that the author considers problematic?

A. The weevils in deciduous forest are counted across a series of ecosystems in order to determine whether they are blocking out other beetles.
B. A species of fish that is dominant in one marine ecosystem is introduced into another marine ecosystem to see whether the species will be dominant there.
C. Whether one woodpecker blocks another from occupying a particular ecosystem is determined based on the similarity or difference of their prey in that community.
D. A study is made to determine average levels of species diversity in communities in a particular type of climate, such as temperate forests.
E. Patterns of species extinction are studied in order to evaluate the effect of the climate changes on diversity in a particular tundra community.

3 
 B 
3. Which of the following, if true, would most clearly support the statement presented in the last sentence of the passage?

A. As a species of small mammal becomes more abundant, it tends to have a larger effect on the community it inhabits, especially a megacommunity.
B. Two species of aphid that have identical diets tend not to coexist within the same ecosystem but may do so if prey is especially abundant.
C. Study of a marshland reveals that more species with functional similarities coexist within that ecosystem than had previously been supposed.
D. A species of bat is completely dependent on the insect populations within a community, and the ability of that insect population to exist depends on the presence of certain plant species.
E. Although two species of bird within a particular ecosystem hunt the same prey, one camouflages itself while hunting and the other does not.

4 
 D 
 4. The passage suggests which of the following about determining whether one species blocks another out of an area?

A. Such a determination can be made solely on the basis of functional characteristics, as long as neighboring communities are considered.
B. Such a determination must be made of an ecosystem considered with clearly defined boundaries.
C. Such a determination is likely to be less accurate for communities that contain more species of a given family.
D. Such a determination cannot be proved or disproved for two given species simply by finding them both within the same ecosystem.
E. Such a determination can best be made by observing the diet of species in succession, starting with plant life.

Source:  GMAT Free  (21)
Difficulty Level:   650

Piyush785 · Answer

SajjadAhmad  
can you please explain me the question number 2 .

it is clearly mentioned in the passage that the identification of the species cannot be done in isolation,rather it should be done with considering the whole ecosytem.
option 2 says that a kind of fish is introduce in other ecosystem .
it meets the above mentioned criteria.

mayurmb · Answer

Score(3 out of 4)
Time (12 mins).
Did I took so long to answer the questions?
Passage was quite difficult for me though.

Posted from my mobile device

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Hello mayurmb

Yes your time is not that good you should not have been spend more than 9 minutes on this passage ideally. First two questions are hard but the remaining two are with the medium difficulty level.

Good Luck

sherlockholmes21 · Answer

MayurB  Can you please explain question 3 and 4?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Official Explanation

2. Which of the following hypothetical experiments most clearly exemplifies the method of identifying species' roles that the author considers problematic?

Difficulty Level:   700

Explanation

The  "problematic"  aspect most likely was that there were two possible explanations of the second example in the passage, not just one. We can go back and confirm that fact. The expression of the problem starts with the word  "but"  on line 9.  "Whether a species hold an exclusive functional place cannot easily be identified by studying a community as an isolated unit."  We want an answer choice that exemplifies this problem, so it might conduct a study just within one community when a neighboring community might be relevant, as in the example of the fish. Each of the answer choices matches our expectation in some respects but not all.

Choice (C)  hits all the important points, because, just like the fish example in the passage, it involves trying to determine assembly rules in a specific community based on functional similarity of two species.

The correct answer is (C).

siddhantvarma · Answer

Let me try to explain how I approached this one.

Q: Which of the following hypothetical experiments most clearly exemplifies the method of identifying species' roles that the author considers problematic?

Going back to the passage, this is where we understand what's problematic about identifying specifies:
 
The problem is that two functionally similar species could either tell us that both belong to the same ecosystem or they could not. Now let's look at this:
 
Here, we're given an example that we can use to pick out an experiment from the given choices that most resemble it.

A. The weevils in deciduous forest are counted across a series of ecosystems in order to determine whether they are blocking out other beetles.
This says the approach uses sequencing to determine which species blocks out another one, as mentioned at the beginning of the passage:
 
This isn't the problem. For all we know this method works well.  So A is out.

B. A species of fish that is dominant in one marine ecosystem is introduced into another marine ecosystem to see whether the species will be dominant there.
You're right about " species cannot be done in isolation,rather it should be done with considering the whole ecosystem.​​​​​​​ " but let's take a closer look at what this means. The author is basically saying you cannot isolate a species and have to consider various sub-ecosystems combined. The answer choice on the other hand, says that a species  is introduced  to another ecosystem. Even then, their dominance persisting in different ecosystems has no relevance here.  So B is out.  
​​​​​​​
C. Whether one woodpecker blocks another from occupying a particular ecosystem is determined based on the similarity or difference of their prey in that community.
This option points to the problem in the sense it talks about "abundance of food". It's also quite similar to the example cited above. We know that there is an exception cited at the end of the passage where one species appears to belong to another ecosystem just because there is abundance of food in that ecosystem.  C seems a good choice.

D.  Study is made to determine average levels of species diversity in communities in a particular type of climate, such as temperate forests.
Irrelevant and out of scope. Nothing about climate changes and diversity is mentioned in the passage as the problem.  D is out.  
​​​​​​​
E. Patterns of species extinction are studied in order to evaluate the effect of the climate changes on diversity in a particular tundra community.
Irrelevant and out of scope. Nothing about climate changes is mentioned in the passage as the problem. 
 E is out.

Therefore, C seems the only correct choice.

To determine whether one species blocks another out of an area, one

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

To determine whether one species blocks another out of an area, one

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards