If x/(x + y) = n, and x/(x - y) = m, then x/y = ? (|x| does not

Question

If  \frac{x}{x+y} = n , and  \frac{x}{x-y} = m , then  \frac{x}{y} = ?  (|x| does not equal |y|, xy does not equal 0)

A.  \frac{3mn}{2}

B.  \frac{3m}{2n}

C.  \frac{n(m+2)}{2}

D.  \frac{2nm}{m-n}

E.  \frac{n^2 - m^2}{nm}

KarishmaB · Accepted Answer

You can do it either algebraically or by assuming numbers:

Algebra:
Note that we are happier with (x+y)/x rather than x/(x+y) since in the former case we can make manipulations easily. So let's take the inverse of both n and m

\frac{1}{n} = \frac{(x+y)}{x} = 1 + \frac{y}{x}  ....(I)
 \frac{1}{m} = \frac{(x-y)}{x} = 1 - \frac{y}{x}  .....(II)

Since we have both m and n in our answer, lets subtract II from I to get

\frac{1}{n} - \frac{1}{m} = \frac{2y}{x}

\frac{(m-n)}{2mn} = \frac{y}{x}

\frac{x}{y} = \frac{2mn}{(m-n)}

Answer (D)

Or Plug in numbers: x = 2, y = 1
n = x/(x+y) = 2/3
m = x/(x-y) = 2

x/y = 2

Now put n = 2/3 and m = 2 in the options. Only option (D) gives you x/y = 2.

Hence answer (D)

MrWallSt · Answer

@Karishma thanks for the post. Your blogs are extremely helpful btw. I am not sure if you ever followed up about your CFA, but I hope that went well for you.

CrackverbalGMAT · Answer

Let us say x = 3, y = 1, n = 0.75, m = 1.5

x/y = 3

(A) 3(3/2)(3/4) = 9/8 (Eliminated)
(B) 3(3/2) 2(3/4) = (Eliminated)
(C) (3/4) (3/2 + 2)/2 = (Eliminated)
(D) 2(3/4)(3/2)/(.75) = 3 (BINGO!)
(E) Eliminated

Hence answer is D

Alaukik · Answer

Sorry for opening a long answered question.

with algebric solution, i am getting many answers in terms of m & n. so the problem needed to be solved by picking numbers. 
when we pick x = 3 & y = 1. I am getting B & D both as answer and but with x = 2 & y= 3. I am getting D as an answer. shouldnt it be unique for all numbers, since there is no restriction (like x, y = consequetive or x>y or viceversa) on picking numbers.

KarishmaB · Answer

When you take one of the numbers as 1 or 0, or when you take numbers to be equal, you could get multiple options satisfying your conditions.

For example, if n = 1
3n/(m+n) will give the same result as 3/(m+n).

Sometimes, you will get the same answer from multiple options if the options are written intelligently. So you could need to try out 2 or even 3 sets of values.

Alaukik · Answer

well the question states xy != 0, so x or y cant be 0. also |x| != |y| so they cant be equal either.

I was hoping for a more bullet proof solution for this question. as 2 sets will take more time. we will get answer but at a huge expense of time.

KarishmaB · Answer

Note that it is a generic comment about number plugging - not just specific to this question.

Also, I have given the algebra solution above - as "bulletproof" as you can get.

evdo · Answer

VeritasPrepKarishma  your solution is excellence. I am wondering, how do we know that one form of fraction (you mentioned it as case) is easier to manipulate than another? I tried to solve this problem using the original form of fraction but I ended up nowhere. Do you have the solution using original form of the fraction?

KarishmaB · Answer

When you need to separate the variables, multiple terms in the numerator are easy to handle since you can split them:

(x+y)/ x = x/x + y/x = 1 + y/x

But if they are in the denominator, you cannot separate them.

You can start with the equations as they are but you will eventually cross multiply to simplify the denominator. If you do different things with the equations, you will get different but equivalent expressions. So a case can be made to do the question by number plugging instead.

jmmanquez · Answer

Hello,

Could someone explain why is it not possible to assume that: x = n(x+y) and x = m(x-y); so n(x+y) = m(x-y) if we solve this we arrive to x/y = (n+m) / (m-n)

I know it is not the correct answer, but I would like to understand my mistake. Many thanks

KarishmaB · Answer

It is not incorrect, it is just not what you need. Different manipulations can lead to different but equivalent expressions.

Kinshook · Answer

Asked: If x/(x+y) = n, and x/(x-y) = m, then x/y = ? (|x| does not equal |y|, xy does not equal 0)

Let us take x = 3; y = 2
x/y = 3/2 = 1.5
3/5 = n = .6
2/1 = m = 2

A. 3mn/2
3*2*.6/2 = 1.8; NO
B. (3m)/(2n)
6*1.2 = 7.2; NO
C. (n * (m+2))/2
.6*4/2 = 1.2; NO
D. 2nm / (m-n)
2*.6*2/(2-.6) = 2.4/1.4 = 12/7; NO
E. (n^2 - m^2) / nm
(.36 - 4 )1.2 ; NO

MrWallSt 
All answers seem incorrect.
Please check.

sambitspm · Answer

Kindly see the attachment.
 It took me around 2:45 min to solve this.

At first, my answer didn't match any of the options. I tried checking my calculation but didn't get to the right choice. Lastly, I went to replacing m and n in options and landed in D. Option D was my first guess, but since it was not exam mode, I was inclined on solving this.

VeritasKarishma, your both approaches help to get a new perspective on this question.

VeritasKarishma , your both approaches help to get a new perspective on this question.

rxb266 · Answer

This is the simplest question

substitute values to each variable and check with the option provided

assuming x=5 and y = 1
m =5/4 and n=5/6

and my x/y should be = 5 (ie,5/1)

only in option D when i substitute the variables I get the value as 5.. Hence my answer is D

(In Gmat the time is a luxury.. try to avoid algebra whenever possible)

Poojita · Answer

Hi
I dont quite seem to understand how did you checked each answer? could you please elaborate more on that?
Also , after getting x/y as m+n/m-n , i assumed m=5 and n=4 but still none of the answer matches. could you help on that please?

Prince1890Sharma · Answer

Hello

Can someone please tell what is wrong with this way of solving....none of the answer choice is matching

Posted from my mobile device

mosesjchong · Answer

KarishmaB

Or Plug in numbers: x = 2, y = 1
n = x/(x+y) = 2/3
m = x/(x-y) = 2

x/y = 2

Now put n = 2/3 and m = 2 in the options. Only option (D) gives you x/y = 2.

Hence answer (D)

When plugged in for answer (A) it also gives you 2. Is there a reason why it works for both?

axeofflane · Answer

Doesnt option A give you 2 as well? What am i missing.

If x/(x + y) = n, and x/(x - y) = m, then x/y = ? (|x| does not

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

If x/(x + y) = n, and x/(x - y) = m, then x/y = ? (|x| does not

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards