Official Solution:
The board of directors of the city art museum has begun discussing ways to deal with a large and unexpected budget shortfall. Several prominent members of the board suggest suspending free admission days, which occur every Tuesday, with the additional revenue to go directly into day-to-day operating costs.
The answer to which of the following questions is LEAST directly relevant to the board members’ consideration of whether suspending free admission days will correct the shortfall in the museum budget?
A. How many people are expected to pay for admission on days that were previously free?
B. Do most members of the board agree that this is the best solution?
C. What percentage of the budget shortfall are day-to-day operating costs?
D. Did the free admission days have any impact on creating the budget problems?
E. Will the money generated from the plan be sufficient to cover day-to-day operating costs?
Situation: Members of the board of directors of a museum propose suspending free admission days to correct a budget shortfall.
Reasoning:
The answer to which question is irrelevant in determining the success of the plan? To answer this question, consider what information can be gained by answering each individual question, then determine whether that information is relevant. The plan is to eliminate free entrance and to use money gained from charging admission to pay for daily operating costs. Any information that will suggest the success or failure of the plan is relevant, and that answer choice can be eliminated.
A. The answer to this question will provide information about how much money will be raised by suspending free admission days. It is relevant.
B. CORRECT. The answer to this question will not provide any directly relevant information about whether the plan will be successful. If the plan is not sound, it will fail even if most members
do agree to implement it.
C. The answer to this question will tell how much of the budget shortfall can be corrected by using additional revenue to cover operating costs. It is relevant.
D. The answer to this question will allow board members to determine whether the free admission days were part of the budget problem. It is relevant.
E. Though covering daily operating costs may not completely correct the budget shortfall, knowledge of
how much positive impact this aspect can have on the overall plan is relevant.
Answer: B