If ab 0, is |a - b| |a + b|? (1) ab b

Question

If  ab ≠ 0 , is  |a-b| > |a+b| ?

(1)  ab < 0

(2)  a > b

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

If ab ≠ 0 , is |a-b| > |a+b| ? Square |a-b| > |a+b| (we can safely do this since both sides are nonnegative): Is a^2 - 2ab + b^2 > a^2 +2ab + b^2 ? Is ab < 0 ? (1) ab < 0 . Directly answers the question. Sufficient. (2) a > b . Not sufficient to say whether ab < 0. Answer: A.

chetan2u · Answer

Hi,
Ofcourse the above method by  Bunuel  is the right and best method, But what it means logically..

is  |a-b| > |a+b| ?..
We have a number line in which a and b and -b are marked..
the MOD asks us whether a is farther from b than -b..

two cases-

A) if both are same sign, a will be closer to b than -b, since midpoint of b and -b will be 0.. ans will be NO
B) if both are opposite sign, a will be closer to -b and ans will be YES..
 
1)  ab < 0 
 Both a and b are of opposite sign .. ans YES 
Suff

2)  a > b 
Nothing ..
 both can be same sign or opposite sign ..
the above TWO cases still remain. .
Insuff

unverifiedvoracity · Answer

For |a-b| > |a+b|, a and b should have opposite signs. So, if a > 0, b should be less than 0 and vice versa.

1) ab < 0
this proves a and b have opposite signs. So, sufficient.

2) a>b
not sufficient as it does not prove a and b will have opposite signs.
for e.g. a=1, b=-2 --> |3| > |1| --> Yes
a=3, b =2 --> |1| < |5| --> No

Sallyzodiac · Answer

Thanks for the reply, Bunuel! Just a quick follow-up: can we assume that both sides are non-negative since ab ≠ 0?

Bunuel · Answer

Both sides are nonnegative because both sides are absolute values which cannot be negative.

Z10201Z · Answer

Hope this helps

https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20160506/4590e349e83aecbb831c5907dd7072b8.jpg

Mo2men · Answer

Hi chetan2u,

I tried other approach by opening the modulus but it seems there is an error.

is |a−b|>|a+b|?

case 1:

a-b > a+b……… 2b<0……..so b<0.. B is negative

case 2:

a-b < -a-b …….. 2a<0……..so a< 0 ..a is negative

Statement 1:

ab<0

According to my analysis above, it should be insufficient because both a & b should negative.

Statement 2:

a>b It should be insufficient

Can you help with identifying the problem with above solution?

Thanks in advance

chetan2u · Answer

Hi, the problem in your solution is opening of MOD.. yes, you can save a lot of time in opening of MOD, if both sides are +ive but do not open it straightway, SQUARE it.. Do not waste time in taking four scenarios, but square both sides, it will siffice.. |a-b|>|a+b|.. square both sides.. (a-b)^2 > (a+b)^2................... a^2+b^2-2ab>a^2+b^2+2ab............ 4ab<0.... .... so we should find out if ab<0 and statement I tells us that ab<0 .. so suff

Mo2men · Answer

Thanks Z10201Z for your help Hi chetan2u, Thanks you for your quick response. I certainly will follow the rule in case of two modulus with inequality. :-D

Aster reading your post about 'Absolute modulus : A better understanding', I have two questions: 1- I want to take further to solve a confusion. I have seen your way solving in one problem when two modulus in equality: |X|=|Y| X=Y or X=-Y or -X=-Y (which is same as X=Y) or -X=Y (Which is the same as X=-Y). However, the previous technique is valid only for Equity and invalid for inequality. Am I right? I think this my error. 2- if the question is |a-b|>a+b ............what the best to solve it? In the case, I'm curious to know how to open modulus just to get to know. I hope one day you can make another post for absolute modulus under inequality.

Thanks in advance for your help. I appreciate it.

chetan2u · Answer

hi lets solve |a-b|>a+b.. this can be straight .. 1) a-b>a+b......2b<0..... b<0.. 2) -(a-b)>a+b......-a+b>a+b.....2a<0..... a<0.. Or Critical points.. a is 0, when a is b, so b is our critical point.. this gives us two ranges a=b.. 1) aa+b......-a+b>a+b.....2a<0..... a<0.. 2) a>=b.. then a-b will be +ive or 0.. so a-b>a+b......2b<0..... b<0.. Best METHOD for any MOD irrespective of = or inequality, follow "critical point" method

GMATAcademy · Answer

You can think of absolute value as distance from zero. So we need enough info to definitely determine whether a - b is further from zero than the sum a + b.

Statement one tells us that a and b have different signs (that's the only way that the product will be negative).

For the difference a - b, this means that the numbers end up 'working together' to get away from zero; if you take a positive number away from a negative number, you go further down, further away from zero (e.g. -10 - 2 = -12). If you take a negative number away from a positive number you go further up (e.g. 10 - - 2 = 12) Takeaway: The difference of numbers with opposite signs is always further from zero than either of the original numbers.

For the sum a + b, statement one means that the numbers end up 'working in opposite directions.' That is, when we add numbers of opposite signs, one cancels out part of the other's distance to zero. Think of 10 + - 2 and -2 + 10. In both cases we end up closer to zero than the furthest term was to begin with. Takeaway: the sum of two numbers with opposite signs will be closer to zero than the original number of greatest magnitude (the term that was furthest from zero to begin with).

So if we know two numbers have opposite signs, we know the difference of those numbers ends up further from zero than the sum. Sufficient.

statement 2 doesn't tell us anything about the signs, so we might be suspicious right from the start. And sure enough, if all we know is that a is to the right of b, then we might have a couple of positives, (such as a = 3, and b = 2) in which case the sum is further from zero than the difference. But we could also have a positive and a negative (such as a = 3, and b = - 2), in which case the difference is further from zero than the sum. Insufficient.

vitaliyGMAT · Answer

1) ab < 0 Means that there are two possibilities: either a>0 and b<0 or a<0 and b>0. Let's look at htose two seperately. a>0, b<0. Let's denote b=-y (y - some positive integer). -y<0, y>0. |(a - (-y))| > |a - y| |a + y| > |a - y| On the left side we have sum of two positive integers so we can pull off our modulus. On the right side we have difference o two positive integers which will always be lesser than their sum. a<0, b>0. Same approach. a=-x (x some positive integer). -x<0, x>0 |-x - b| > |-x + b| | - (x +b)| > |b - x| x + b > |b - x| Again we have sum of two positive integers on the left and their diffrence on th right. Sufficient. 2) a > b We have three possible scenarious. a) a>0, b>0 b) a<0, b<0 c) a>0, b<0 a) To eveade confusion it would be impler to use particular numbers here. a = 30, b = 10 |30 - 10| ... |30 + 10| ----> 20 < 40 b) a = -10 b = -30 |-10 - (-30)| ... | -10 - 30| | -10 + 30| ... | - (10 + 30)| 20 < 40 c) In c we have same case as in (1) a=10, b=-30 |10 - (-30)| ... |10 - 30| 40 > 20 Insufficient Answer A I hope my approach wasn't too vague. May be our experts will give you more details.

BrushMyQuant · Answer

Learn More about Absolute Values Here

|a-b|>|a+b| will be true only when a and b have different signs, as when we are doing
-> |a-b| we are actually adding the values of a and b and
-> |a+b| we are actually subtracting the values of a and b.

STAT1
ab < 0 => a and b have different signs
SUFFICIENT

STAT2
a > b
a and b can have the same sign or can have different signs too
example:
1. a = 7 b = 2 => a> b
but |a-b|<|a+b| (|5| < |9|)
2. a = 7 b = -2 => a> b
|a-b|>|a+b| (|9| > |5|)
So, INSUFFICIENT

So, Answer will be A
Hope it helps!

Watch the following video to learn the Basics of Absolute Values

Cez005 · Answer

Hi Bunuel, to confirm, the sign of the sides matters because if we multiply by a -ve, then the inequality sign would need to flip, correct?

Bunuel · Answer

We can raise both parts of an inequality to an even power if we know that both parts of an inequality are non-negative (the same for taking an even root of both sides of an inequality). For example: 2<4 --> we can square both sides and write: 2^2<4^2 ; 0\leq{x}<{y} --> we can square both sides and write: x^2-2 if we square we'll get 1>4 which is not right. So if given that x>y then we cannot square both sides and write x^2>y^2 if we are not certain that both x and y are non-negative. Check the link below for more: Inequality tips Manipulating Inequalities Similar questions to practice: https://gmatclub.com/forum/if-ab-ab-is- ... 46246.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-a-b-a-b-1 ... 46248.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-a-b-a-b-1 ... 46249.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/is-a-b-a-b-1 ... 46206.html https://gmatclub.com/forum/does-a-b-b-a ... 18291.html

bovannu01 · Answer

@ Brunuel

Sorry but I'm confused about this probelm.

Below was how I tried to solve this.

|a−b|>|a+b|
Then it means there are 2 cases: a-b>a+b OR a-b<-(a+b)
Solving those 2 inequalities, we have -2b>0 OR 2a<0
Finally we have b<0 OR a<0.
So the question stem is asking if b<0 OR a<0.

1) ab<0. This means that a and b have opposite signs. This means a and b can be negative or possitive. This does not answer the question. INSUFFICIENT.

2) a>b. Again, this does not answer the question. INSUFFICIENT.

1) and 2). Since we know that a and b have opposite signs, and a >b, that means a must be possitive and b must be nagatice . So we have a>0 and b<0. This answer the question. SUFFICIENT.

Please help me out and let me know where this logic is wrong.
Thanks!

Bunuel · Answer

Why only 2 cases? There are 4: When a > b and a > -b, we get a - b > a + b, which results in b < 0. So, in this case -a < b < 0 < a. When a > b and a < -b, we get a - b > -(a + b), which results in a > 0. So, in this case b < -a < 0 < a. When a < b and a > -b, we get -(a - b) > a + b, which results in a < 0. So, in this case a < 0 < -a < b. When a < b and a < -b, we get -(a - b) > -(a + b), which results in b > 0. So, in this case a < 0 < b < -a Now, ab < 0 can occur in the following 4 cases: -a < b < 0 < a, b < -a < 0 < a. a < 0 < -a < b a < 0 < b < -a For each of those, |a - b| > |a + b|. However, this is not a good way of solving this question. I'd suggest to review the one given in my post above.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If ab 0, is |a - b| > |a + b|? (1) ab < 0 (2) a > b

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions