Like many arid regions, Ariba must import many of its fruits and vegetables from neighboring lands.
A Like
B Just like
C As have
D As did
E Just as with
Why is the answer choice C incorrect.
As have many arid regions, Ariba must import many of its fruits and vegetables from neighboring lands.
We are comparing clause to a clause then why is this answer choice incorrect. Also, please confirm is "have" acting as a verb in the above sentence ? I read the following Princeton Explaination but I am not sure if we need the two verbs in the same tense and if that is a rule.
Please help.
Although we would all love to live in a world of absolutes, either like or as could be used in a situation like this. (Sit tight!) We are either comparing arid regions and Ariba (comparison of nouns, requiring "like"); or comparing the import habits of arid regions with those of Ariba (comparison of actions, requiring "as"). EITHER is valid!
Why are C through E eliminated, then? Because they lack verb parallelism! Correctly used, the sentence with "as" would read, "As do many arid regions, Ariba must import many of its fruits and vegetables from neighboring lands." This matches parallel tense with parallel tense in both clauses. It is not by mere coincidence that none of the answer choices give this option. They use the present perfect have (in choice C) or the simple past did (in choice D); both are mismatches with the present-tense verb, must import, in the main clause.
Choice B, Just like, is disqualified because it lacks concision: the word Just is unnecessary. It is also a colloquialism-that is, it's too informal. You would seldom if ever encounter this expression in formal written English.