Is the two-digit positive integer P a prime number?

Question

GMATBusters’ Quant Quiz Question -10 
For questions from previous quizzes click  here

(1) P has a factor f such that 1<f<P.
(2) Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime.

GMATBusters · Answer

Official Solution:

Statement 1 P has a factor f such that 1<f<P. 
A prime number can not have any factor except 1 or P itself.
Hence by definition of a prime number, P is not a prime number
SUFFICIENT

Statement 2: Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime. 
This is not sufficient
37 (35, 39 are not prime): prime
24 (22, 26 are not prime): not prime

hence NOT SUFFICIENT

Answer A

AndreV · Answer

1) All prime numbers have two factors: 1 and the number itself. However, this statement indicates that P has another factor f (1<f<P); therefore, P cannot be prime.
Clearly, this statement is sufficient.
2) All prime numbers above 3 are of the form 6n-1 or 6n+1. If P=6n-1, then P-2=6n-3=3(2n-1), which is divisible by 3 and; therefore, is not a prime number. Likewise, if P=6n+1, then P+2=6n+3=3(2n+1), which is divisible by 3 and; therefore, is not a prime number.
It follows from the analysis that P cannot be a prime number. 
Clearly, this statement is sufficient.
Answer:D

akadiyan · Answer

Is the two-digit positive integer P a prime number?

(1) P has a factor f such that 1<f<P.
(2) Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime.

(1)P has a factor f such that 1<f<P.
Only factors of a prime number is 1 and itself. If a factor between 1 and the number itself, then the number is not a prime number.

Option A alone is sufficient. Eliminate B,C and E.

(2)Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime.

We do not need to do any calculations for this option as there are many examples that comes to mind to prove P is not a prime. 
For P-2, we can state 5 as example. 5 is a prime and 5-2=3 is also prime number. 
For P+2, we can state same 5 as example as 5 is prime and 5+2 = 7 is also prime number. 
So P is not a prime number.

Option B alone is sufficient. Eliminate A,C and E.

Ans:  D

ITGMAT · Answer

Qs : Is the two-digit positive integer P a prime number?
Given : two digit integer and positive.

(1) P has a factor f such that 1<f<P.

the statement say that there will be always a factor for a number that will be less than that number and greater than 1. so that number will contain at-least 3 factors. if more than two factors are possible then the number is not prime. Hence sufficient to answer the question. 
Example : 
p=10, then factor= 1, 2, 5,10 so f= 2, 5 but 10 is not prime.
p=17, then factor = 1, 17 so no f is possible.

(2) Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime.
 consider the cases, if P= 23, then p-2= 21, p+2= 25 both are not prime. however P is prime. 
 if P= 28, then p-2= 26, p+2= 30 both are not prime. however P is not prime. 
so no unique answer is possible. the condition is not sufficient.

Answer is A.

_________________

bM22 · Answer

Statement 1: P has a factor f which is >1 & <P, so it implies that P is not a prime number since a prime number can have only 2 factor, 1 and the number itself. 
So  Sufficient .

Statement 2: P-2 and P+2 are not primes.

Let P = 13,
11 is prime, whereas 15 not prime,
 
Let P = 83, 
81 is not Prime, 85 is also not prime, so we cannot say anything for sure about P being a prime number. Statement is Insufficient.

Answer is A.

TheNightKing · Answer

Is the two-digit positive integer P a prime number?

(1) P has a factor f such that 1<f<P.
(2) Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime.

Given : P is a 2 digit Positive integer.

Question: P is prime? Y or N.

(1) P has a factor f such that 1<f<P.
 
If P has any factor other than 1 and P then it is not a Prime number. Hence the answer is No.

Sufficient.

(2) Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime.

If P is 23 then 21 and 25 are not Prime. Y.
If P is 97 then 95 and 99 are not Prime. Y.
But If P is 11 then 9 is not a Prime but 13 is a Prime. So even though P is prime but the statement is not true.

Not Sufficient.

Answer A

Archit3110 · Answer

Is the two-digit positive integer P a prime number?

(1) P has a factor f such that 1<f<P.
(2) Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime

#1
no prime no can have any factor except no itself and 1 ; so f being a factor means p is not prime ; sufficient
#2
Neither P− 2 nor P + 2 is prime
test with P = 20 ; we get P is not prime and P = 23 ; yes is prime ; insufficient
IMO A

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Is the two-digit positive integer P a prime number?

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

Is the two-digit positive integer P a prime number?

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards