deepakg,
The only thing you hit on that I see as a fault of the school is the CDO could use improvement in certain areas but for finance they are great. As far as faculty, we have world-renowned professors in venture capital, private equity, finance, economics, and nonprofit. I was watching the NBC special on the credit crisis and they quoted three or four of my profs on CNBC. I didn't hear a Harvard prof quoted.
Last week we went to a target IB event and our students are on par with any program in the nation. Chicago, Columbia, NYU and Duke were respresented and our students made a great impression on bankers according to those from nontarget schools. We have great relationships with every bank but Goldman.
I encountered the "yale is my third or fourth option" speak last year also. I can say it's a great university with very bright students. A lot of this has to do with rankings and not brand name as Yale is one of four schools in the world with such a name. One of the items businessweek looks at is the average salary of students and our nonprofit salaries bring us way down.
As far as PE, it is hard to get into PE out of any school right now especially without a great finance background.