ghunar
zoya2010
My conjecture:
I think the email went out by mistake. It doesn't have to do anything with who is admitted and who isn't. Somebody on the back end must have made some sort of an error and only a batch of people ended up getting this email.
However, it did end up revealing (like in my case) that some people's official gmat scores were missing. Now I never got a notification, and I rarely log in because any kind of status change was accompanied by an email. And as per the FAQs about official scores being reported, it seems like they cannot render a decision until the official score is in. So they cannot accept (OR REJECT) without that official score. I'm guessing my app (unless they're still making last minute decisions) will be pushed to 3rd round which honestly is worse than just being rejected right now. I don't know if I can take another couple of months of waiting.
Once again, good luck to everyone ! 4 more days

Yes but they key is- was the batch that received the e-mail a random group, or was it the list of admits.
After thinking it over I would tend to incline toward the list being random. Over the past couple pages we have been able to discover the following five facts:
1. It has an ‘unsubscribe’ message attached to it, meaning it is likely a marketing email ( as opposed to generated within the application system).
2. For one individual, it was sent to their email address attached to their GMAC account instead of their application account.
3. One individual received this exact email two months before they applied. Another received it in August before they applied.
4. They already verified most of us about a month ago after we received an interview request and before they make a final decision.
5. GMAC provides a website where they give access to our scores after we release them to a school.
I feel confident that this email was generated by whoever was downloading scores from the website. I would assume that the website has an option for them to send a verifying email or to not send a verifying email---Chicago Booth usually doesn’t send an email out, but whoever was doing it this time must of accidently checked the box on the website to send an email.
Now when they download scores, the website probably has a basic way they go about it. They input a search, the results come up, they highlight or check the results they want, and then they download them. There are probably a couple different ways that they can search for reports : by an individual name, by a criteria like score level, GPA level, undergrad, and by date ( ie activity in last three months, last year, last 5 years). I wouldn’t expect them to search for a group of people—they are probably constrained by the system GMAC has set up ( how would that work of inputting multiple names at once?).
So that leaves us with two options:
1) They performed a basic search with a broad range of people, then they individual checked off the 300-400 admits for this round, and then they downloaded those reports and accidentally had the send verify email box checked off. I find this unlikely—why would they do this when they already have our scores from a month ago? This seems like a lot of work, especially when you realize they would have to sift through each admit to find the highest ‘official’ score for their statistics. It would be soo much easier to just use what they have in their application system to do this. This just seems redundant.
2. They performed a routine search, which they probably do on a schedule, and they accidentally checked the verify email when they did this. I find this more likely. I would expect every couple weeks they re-download recent scores into their own personal database. Given that most people I could find with the email had fulfilled their scores after January or recently re-took the test, I would guess that they did a search for all updates from 2011, and these are the people that got the email. They probably do searches like this every month or couple weeks, and most of them we don’t know about since they don’t send us verifying emails (except for the few cases of people who got it before they applied).
That is my opinion; it is just random and not representative of anything. But only admissions could really know.