A manufacturer of flooring materials plans to release a new product

Question

A manufacturer of flooring materials plans to release a new product that will be simpler to install than any of their other existing products. An outside consultant has advised the manufacturer not to display the product in the limited space available at an upcoming exhibition of new home remodeling products. This advice was given despite the popularity of the exhibition and the success that the manufacturer has had displaying its products at the exhibition in the past.

Which of the following, if true, most strongly justifies the advice given by the consultant?

(A) The consultant is aware that another manufacturer will be displaying a similar product at the exhibition.
(B) The new flooring material is intended for homeowners to use, but the exhibition is for professional remodelers.
(C) The manufacturer has several other products that for years have generated the bulk of the company’s profits.
(D) The consultant has been told by engineers who work for the manufacturer that the new flooring material is not as durable as other flooring materials the company produces.
(E) There will be another, larger exhibition of home remodeling products six months after the upcoming one.

EMPOWER  gmat    CR Question Pack 2

Question 20: Flooring Materials

48 Hour Answer & Explanation Window  
 Earn KUDOS!  Have your explanations evaluated to help boost your learning. Post your reasoning why the answer you chose is correct, and why the other 4 options are incorrect within 48 hours of this post.

Scroll Down For Official Explanation

◀ Question 19 
 ▶ Question 21 
 ⏏ CR Library Pack 2 Home

rohit8865 · Answer

(A) The consultant is aware that another manufacturer will be displaying a similar product at the exhibition. INCORRECT  it is no matter of concern what other manufacturer is displaying in exhibition
(B) The new flooring material is intended for homeowners to use, but the exhibition is for professional remodelers. CORRECT  if it is true then the purpose of displaying in exhibition is not fulfilled.
(C) The manufacturer has several other products that for years have generated the bulk of the company’s profits. INCORRECT ...other products has no any concern
(D) The consultant has been told by engineers who work for the manufacturer that the new flooring material is not as durable as other flooring materials the company produces. INCORRECT  expert adviced not to display in limited space, so the quality is not a concern
(E) There will be another, larger exhibition of home remodeling products six months after the upcoming one. INCORRECT  another exhibition is out of scope .

Ans B

Akp880 · Answer

A manufacturer of flooring materials plans to release a new product that will be simpler to install than any of their other existing products. An outside consultant has advised the manufacturer not to display the product in the limited space available at an upcoming exhibition of new home remodeling products. This advice was given despite the popularity of the exhibition and the success that the manufacturer has had displaying its products at the exhibition in the past.

Which of the following, if true, most strongly justifies the advice given by the consultant?

Explanation:

(A) The consultant is aware that another manufacturer will be displaying a similar product at the exhibition.
 Irrelevant.This is not a proper reasoning why the manufacturer shall not display his product in the upcoming exhibition

(B) The new flooring material is intended for homeowners to use, but the exhibition is for professional remodelers.
 Correct.This can act as a reason why consultant has advised the manufacturer not to display the product.Also Links properly with the information given in argument.

(C) The manufacturer has several other products that for years have generated the bulk of the company’s profits.
 Out of scope.We are concerned about exhibiting new flooring material only.

(D) The consultant has been told by engineers who work for the manufacturer that the new flooring material is not as durable as other flooring materials the company produces.
 Out of scope.Our main concern is display in exhibition not the quality or durability.

(E) There will be another, larger exhibition of home remodeling products six months after the upcoming one.
 Incorrect.This is not a proper reasoning why the manufacturer shall not display the product in the upcoming exhibition.

Hence B is the correct answer IMO

gvij2017 · Answer

I didn't get why B is correct. Does it mean that professional remodeler won't recommend this new product to end users? It might be possible that professional remodeler may promote the new product among home owners, consequently creating more revenue for company. 
I understand this choice could be best among the given choices but the answer to why the exposure of product to professional remodelers is not good.

In sum, my point is that can I expect such choices in actual GMAT test in which choice could have multiple meaning.

Need guidance!

EMPOWERgmatVerbal · Answer

Official Explanation:

A manufacturer of flooring materials plans to release a new product that will be simpler to install than any of their other existing products. An outside consultant has advised the manufacturer not to display the product in the limited space available at an upcoming exhibition of new home remodeling products. This advice was given despite the popularity of the exhibition and the success that the manufacturer has had displaying its products at the exhibition in the past.
 
 Which of the following, if true, most strongly justifies the advice given by the consultant? 
 
 (A) The consultant is aware that another manufacturer will be displaying a similar product at the exhibition. 
 (B) The new flooring material is intended for homeowners to use, but the exhibition is for professional remodelers. 
 (C) The manufacturer has several other products that for years have generated the bulk of the company’s profits.
(D) The consultant has been told by engineers who work for the manufacturer that the new flooring material is not as durable as other flooring materials the company produces.
(E) There will be another, larger exhibition of home remodeling products six months after the upcoming one.

Question Type:   Strengthen; Resolve Paradox
  Boil It Down:   Flooring material manufacturer is releasing a new product, but an outside consultant advised them not to display it at an upcoming exhibition, even though the exhibition is popular and the manufacturer has been successful there in the past.
  Goal:    Find the strongest reason why the consultant might tell the manufacturer to not display their new product.

Analysis:

This question asks us to strengthen (justify) the consultant’s conclusion.
 
 Conclusion:  Don’t display the new product at the exhibition of new home remodeling products.
 
There is no evidence to support the conclusion. (In fact, there is evidence that makes the conclusion questionable.) Therefore, you must provide evidence in the right choice. If, as choice B states, the product’s intended market is not the same people as those in attendance at the exhibition, the manufacturer would do better to do other things with the limited space that they have available. 
 
(A) The consultant is aware that another manufacturer will be displaying a similar product at the exhibition.
 This information does not suggest that the manufacturer should not display their product. It could actually serve to suggest the opposite. They should display it so as to not be outsold by their rival.

(B) The new flooring material is intended for homeowners to use, but the exhibition is for professional remodelers.
 This is the correct choice. The manufacturer has limited space to display their products, so it’s logical to not display a product that is unlikely to be bought by those in attendance at the exhibition.

(C) The manufacturer has several other products that for years have generated the bulk of the company’s profits.
 This is irrelevant to an exhibition of specifically NEW products, as stated in the passage.

(D) The consultant has been told by engineers who work for the manufacturer that the new flooring material is not as durable as other flooring materials the company produces.
 This is irrelevant background information. It might still be a successful product that would benefit from being displayed at the exhibition.

(E) There will be another, larger exhibition of home remodeling products six months after the upcoming one.
 This does not mean that the new product shouldn’t be displayed at the upcoming exhibition. Why not display the product at both exhibitions?

Don’t study for the GMAT. Train for it.

TarPhi · Answer

(A) The consultant is aware that another manufacturer will be displaying a similar product at the exhibition. 
Irrelevant
(B) The new flooring material is intended for homeowners to use, but the exhibition is for professional remodelers.
CORRECT - If it's not the right Target Audience, why waste the limited space.
(C) The manufacturer has several other products that for years have generated the bulk of the company’s profits.
Irrelevant
(D) The consultant has been told by engineers who work for the manufacturer that the new flooring material is not as durable as other flooring materials the company produces.
Close, cause this could suggest that showing something less durable could affect the way people view the company's products. However, B is a better option.
(E) There will be another, larger exhibition of home remodeling products six months after the upcoming one.
Irrelevant

BMohit · Answer

A - Not a justification for not displaying own product. Incorrect
B - The flooring is simple to install and is meant for homeowners. As the exhibition does not target the intended consumer, display there will not benefit. Also the limited space can be used to display other relevant products. Correct
C - Old products generating profits in past might not be profitable now. Not a reason for not displaying the new flooring.
D - Durability is irrelevant here. Incorrect
E - Not a reason for not displaying the product now. Incorrect.

Ans - B

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

A manufacturer of flooring materials plans to release a new product

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

A manufacturer of flooring materials plans to release a new product

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards