Last year, James McGuel received heavy criticism for his poor form that contributed significantly to OldFort United’s worst ever performance in National Premier Football Championship. Despite the fact that OldFort United has been winning many more games this year and James McGuel is averaging more goals per game than last year, critics still continue to doubt Jame’s form and are voting against his inclusion in the World Cup squad.
Which of the following statements most explains the paradox in the above argument?
A. It is not true that OldFort United has been playing more number of matches this year.
Incorrect B. Football critics are mostly not correct in their opinion since biases cloud their judgment.
Irrelevant C. OldFort United’s decision to hire Wayne Bruce has turned out well for the team as he is the leading scorer for the team this year.
IrrelevantD. Questions are being raised by certain critics about the actual nationality of James McGuel and it is likely that he shall be excluded from the World Cup squad for the country.
Irrelevant E. After last year’s poor showdown, OldFort United has been relegated from the premier league and is currently playing against weaker opponents.
Correct: Since OldFort United is playing against weaker opponents critics criticism is valid though James McGuel scored more goal this year than last year.