is it D ?
A lawyer who does not return phone calls from her clients cannot be a skillful, experienced lawyer. I feel comfortable with the skill and experience of my attorney because she returns all of my phone calls, even when she is busy.
Which of the following selections presents a reasoning pattern most similar to the flawed pattern presented in the passage?
(A) Anyone who plays on a baseball team has had to make sacrifices for the good of the team. Ted is used to making sacrifices, so he might play on a baseball team.
(B) Anyone who is opposed to the city bond issue has not received the city’s information packet on the issue. Sandy says she will vote against the city bond issue, so she hasn’t received the city information packet.
(C) No one who likes science fiction movies will miss seeing the second release of the Star Wars trilogy in movie theaters. Jimmy loves the Star Wars movies, but he did not see the second movie of the trilogy when it was released recently.
(D) A school-age child who spends three afternoons a week at gymnastics practice does not have a proper balance between school work and gymnastics. Tom spends only one afternoon per week at gymnastics practice, so he has a proper balance between school and gymnastics.
(E) A person who is jumpy and impatient will not work well with animals. Janice is impatient, so she would not be a good animal trainer.