The primary hospital in the town of Riverton has been criticized for

Question

The primary hospital in the town of Riverton has been criticized for declining to accept patients who do not have insurance or who have insufficient insurance to cover their medical care at the hospital. Responding to the criticism, the mayor of Riverton has denounced the hospital for discrimination and demanded that the policy be revised. The mayor has also encouraged the city council to pass an ordinance requiring hospitals to accept all patients, regardless of insurance coverage. The city council has declined, however, arguing that as a private business the hospital has the right to refuse customers who are unable to pay for hospital services.

Which of the following assumptions can be inferred from the city council’s argument that the hospital has a right to decline treatment to patients?

(A) The majority of residents in the town of Riverton have sufficient insurance coverage, so there will be very few patients who are refused service.

(B) The city council believes that anti-discrimination laws do not cover a hospital refusing service to patients who are unable to pay for their medical services.

(C) The uninsured and insufficiently insured patients will be covered by state and federal funding, so the hospital will ultimately not need to turn patients away.

(D) There is a large hospital in a town very near to Riverton that accepts all patients regardless of their insurance coverage.

(E) The mayor is a member of a different political party than most members of the city council, so they tend to oppose him on every recommendation he makes.

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION

Overview:

Question presents a scenario in which a large hospital in the town of Riverton has an established policy of turning away patients with no insurance or with insurance that is insufficient to cover their medical needs. The mayor of Riverton has taken a stand against this practice and has asked the city council to pass an ordinance that requires hospitals to accept all patients, regardless of their insurance coverage. The city council has refused on the grounds that the hospital is a 
private business and should not have to serve those who cannot pay. The student is asked to consider which assumption among the answer choices can be inferred from the city council’s argument.

The Correct Answer:

B Although the passage does not directly mention anti-discrimination laws, it does mention that the mayor perceives the hospital’s policy to fall under these laws and thus explains his reason for taking the matter before the city council. The city council’s decision, then, indicates that they do not believe any laws forbidding discrimination apply to a hospital that is refusing service to uninsured or underinsured patients.

The Incorrect Answers:

A There is nothing in the city council’s decision or in the passage to indicate that the majority of residents in Riverton already have sufficient coverage. In fact, the outcry raised against the hospital suggests otherwise, so answer choice (A) cannot be correct.

C, D There is no information in the passage to suggest that the city council bases its decision on the possibility of government funding or on another hospital accepting patients. The passage does mention that the hospital under discussion is the “primary” one, indicating that there might be others, but there is no suggestion regarding a hospital in a nearby town or about its policies concerning uninsured patients. Therefore, answer choices (C) and (D) cannot be correct.

E Although the city council might very well be composed mostly of members who support a different political party than that of the mayor, it is impossible to deduce from the passage that the council is so composed or that this contributes to the city council’s decision regarding the hospital. Answer choice (E) is clearly incorrect.

jrk23 · Answer

Confused between "C" and "E" . Lets wait

winterschool · Answer

The primary hospital in the town of Riverton has been criticized for declining to accept patients who do not have insurance or who have insufficient insurance to cover their medical care at the hospital. Responding to the criticism, the mayor of Riverton has denounced the hospital for discrimination and demanded that the policy be revised. The mayor has also encouraged the city council to pass an ordinance requiring hospitals to accept all patients, regardless of insurance coverage. The city council has declined, however, arguing that as a private business the hospital has the right to refuse customers who are unable to pay for hospital services.

Which of the following assumptions can be inferred from the city council’s argument that the hospital has a right to decline treatment to patients?

(A) The majority of residents in the town of Riverton have sufficient insurance coverage, so there will be very few patients who are refused service.  Incorrect

cant explain or linked why hospital has the right to refuse customers

(B)  The city council believes that anti-discrimination laws do not cover a hospital refusing service to patients who are unable to pay for their medical services.   Correct

it is a private business and anti-discrimination laws do not cover cost of unable patients, so they have right to refuse customers

(C) The uninsured and insufficiently insured patients will be covered by state and federal funding, so the hospital will ultimately not need to turn patients away.  Incorrect

against city council's argument

(D) There is a large hospital in a town very near to Riverton that accepts all patients regardless of their insurance coverage.  Incorrect

against city council's argument

(E) The mayor is a member of a different political party than most members of the city council, so they tend to oppose him on every recommendation he makes.  Incorrect

this cant be city council's assumption

rocky620 · Answer

Since the basis of Mayor demand that the hospitals policy be revised is DISCRIMINATION. The city council has declined his demand by arguing that "  as a private business the hospital has the right to refuse customers who are unable to pay for hospital services  ".
It could be the case that the act of hospitals, to refuse patients, who do not have insurance or who have insufficient insurance to cover their medical care, does not fall under the DISCRIMINATION LAWS. Hence, the city council declined the Mayor's request.

Only  Option B  covers this aspect.

As for other options:

A. We do not know what MAJORITY reflects. (51, 52, 53.......98,99,100). If it is 51 the remaining 49 are refused service (and so on), this is a huge number.

C. If so, the Mayor would not have raised the issue.

D. We are only concerned with Riverton hospitals. What other town hospitals do is OFS.

E. Political scenarios are OFS.

IMO  Option B

unraveled · Answer

The primary hospital in the town of Riverton has been criticized for declining to accept patients who do not have insurance or who have insufficient insurance to cover their medical care at the hospital. Responding to the criticism, the mayor of Riverton has denounced the hospital for discrimination and demanded that the policy be revised. The mayor has also encouraged the city council to pass an ordinance requiring hospitals to accept all patients, regardless of insurance coverage. The city council has declined, however, arguing that as a private business the hospital has the right to refuse customers who are unable to pay for hospital services.

Which of the following assumptions can be inferred from the city council’s argument that the hospital has a right to decline treatment to patients?

The passage is all about hospital rejecting patients without enough insurance coverage and even though mayor denounced the hospital, the city council took a decision in favour of the hospital.

(A) The  majority of residents  in the town of Riverton  have sufficient insurance coverage , so there will be very few patients who are refused service. - WRONG. Few or more it doesn't matter, patients are still rejected.

(B) The city council  believes  that  anti-discrimination laws  do not cover a hospital refusing service to patients who are unable to pay for their medical services. - CORRECT.

(C) The uninsured and insufficiently insured patients will be  covered by state and federal funding , so the hospital will ultimately not need to turn patients away. - WRONG. Irrelevant.

(D) There is a  large hospital  in a town very  near to Riverton  that accepts all patients regardless of their insurance coverage. - WRONG. Again irrelevant.

(E) The mayor is a member of a different political party than most members of the city council, so they tend to oppose him on every recommendation he makes. - WRONG. Totally out of scope.

in B, frankly, the two highlighted words made me reject is at the first instance. However, after going through all the options option B looked better in all aspects. I mean why one would be bothered what city council believes and that about anti-discrimination laws which is nowhere mentioned in the passage. At best, it looked irrelevant to talk about these two things.

Answer B.

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

The primary hospital in the town of Riverton has been criticized for

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

The primary hospital in the town of Riverton has been criticized for

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards