A popular electronics company that is known for producing innovative

Question

A popular electronics company that is known for producing innovative technology recently began heavy marketing for a new music-playing device. The company is excited about the new device, because it is much smaller than previous devices and is very light and highly portable, allowing the listener to carry it easily, without any cumbersome pieces or cords. After three months on the market, however, the device is not selling well, and the company is forced to admit that its competitor’s product is still selling much better, in spite of the fact that the competitor’s product is heavier and does not offer the same qualities of portability.

Considering the passage above carefully, which of the following provides the best reason for the failure of the new device to take off with the public?

(A) Consumers have become accustomed to using the competitor’s device and dislike the style of the new device.

(B) The competitor is planning to update its popular device soon, so the new device from the first company will have major rivalry among the public.

(C) The popular company that produced the new device hired a marketing firm that failed to inform the public sufficiently about the benefits of the new device.

(D) The new device requires that owners purchase and download music in a unique form, as it is incompatible with other forms and does not allow for conversion.

(E) The president of the popular electronics company is currently in talks to leave and become president of the competitor company.

DHRJ0032 · Answer

only D talks about the reason for the failure of the company's new product.

D is the answer

abuc0112 · Answer

To answer this question, we are looking for an answer that will show some disadvantages of the new product that the customers are not willing to overlook and answer D does that.

Answer: D

Bunuel · Answer

OFFICIAL EXPLANATION

Overview:

Question presents a situation in which a popular electronics company has recently manufactured a new music-playing device, and they expect it to take off immediately with the public. According to the passage, the company is well known for its inventive new technology, and the product is being marketed for its easy portability as well as its technical superiority over competitor devices. As it turns out, though, the new device does not sell very well, and the electronics company realizes that the primary competitor’s device is still selling much better, in spite of specific drawbacks. The question asks the student to identify an answer choice that best explains the reason for the new device to fail with the public, even though it is easier to use and more portable than the competitor’s device. To answer this question correctly, the student must read through each answer choice and compare the information in the answer choice to the 
statements made in the passage.

The Correct Answer:

D Answer choice (D) offers the explanation that the new music-playing device, whatever its benefits of use and portability, does require owners to purchase music in a unique form that is not compatible with other forms. This means that anyone who has already purchased music will not be able to utilize the purchases and will have to spend even more money to acquire the same music in a different form. This would certainly create a hindrance to easy sales, so answer choice (D) best explains the disparity between the electronics company’s expectations and the results. Answer choice (D) is correct.

The Incorrect Answers:

A It is interesting to find out that consumers have become accustomed to using the competitor’s device and dislike the style of the new device, but this in itself does not provide a tangible enough reason for why the new device would be so unpopular. Given that the electronics company is said to be very popular and is “known for producing innovative technology,” it is reasonable to assume that the new style plays into consumer preferences for this company. Answer choice (A) does not offer a satisfactory explanation for the public response, so it cannot be correct.

B The impending release of a new device from the competitor is useful information, but again this in itself does not offer a good explanation for why consumers would prefer the old competitor’s device to the new device from the company discussed in the passage. Either way, consumers will have to purchase a new device, and since the answer choice does not mention that the competitor company is providing a refund for turning in an old device, there is no reason to assume that there is any immediate benefit to waiting for the upcoming competitor device. Answer choice (B) cannot be correct.

C Answer choice (C) directly contradicts the statements made in the passage: the company “recently began heavy marketing for a new music-playing device,” and it is “excited about the new device, because it is much smaller than previous devices and is very light and highly portable.” These statements suggest strongly that the electronics company took care to market the new music-playing device effectively. Answer choice (C) is clearly incorrect.

E The possibility of the president of the one electronics company leaving to work for the other electronics company is interesting but irrelevant to the immediate discussion of why the public would not be eager to purchase the new music-playing device. Without further information about the president deliberately sabotaging marketing attempts, there is no clear link between a staff change and a failed product. Answer choice (E) cannot be correct.

unraveled · Answer

A popular electronics company that is known for producing innovative technology recently began  heavy marketing  for a new music-playing device. The company is excited about the new device, because it is much smaller than previous devices and is very  light and highly portable , allowing the listener to carry it easily, without any cumbersome pieces or cords. After three months on the market, however, the device is not selling well, and the company is forced to admit that its competitor’s product is still selling much better, in spite of the fact that the competitor’s product is heavier and does not offer the same qualities of portability.

Considering the passage above carefully, which of the following provides the best reason for the failure of the new device to take off with the public?

(A) Consumers have  become accustomed  to using the competitor’s device and dislike the style of the new device. - WRONG. Goes against the premise. It was portable.

(B) The competitor is  planning to update its popular device soon , so the new device from the first company will have major rivalry among the public. - WRONG. New info but gives context for the future possibilities. Hence irrelevant.

(C) The popular company that produced the new device hired a marketing firm that  failed to inform the public sufficiently  about the benefits of the new device. - WRONG. Goes against the premise. It was heavily marketed.

(D) The new device requires that owners purchase and download music in a unique form, as it is  incompatible with other forms and does not allow for conversion.  - CORRECT. New info that helps sort things for us.

(E) The president of the popular electronics company is currently in talks to leave and become president of the competitor company. - WRONG. New info again with future context. Irrelevant at best.

The blue text are keywords as per the choices available, however, there are many.

Answer D.

Pranavsawant · Answer

Can someone give a good reason why A is wrong?
I am unable to eliminate it. Both A and D look equally strong to me

DanTheGMATMan · Answer

A isn't a bad choice, but I suppose if customers have become accustomed to the other device, it means they have already purchased an item and perhaps aren't in the market to buy the new device. So this narrows the audience down more than we want, if we want a good explanation for why it's selling so poorly overall. It doesn't address why people without a device aren't buying the new thing. They wouldn't have become accustomed to the less portable device because they don't have one, so it isn't clear why they're not buying the new one.

KarishmaB · Answer

(A) would make sense if the product were a staple which is bought repeatedly - say bread. So people could have gotten accustomed to a particular bread and would not be switching. 
A music device likely has a life of a few years at least. Those who have become accustomed to the competitor's device are anyway likely not buying a new one. They are not the target audience. The problem is why are people in the market for a music device not buying this new one. After all, the company is a popular electronics company. 
The context is important. Visualize it in the real world.

nimishb23 · Answer

A: Is an interesting choice, however it doesn't fully explain a reason why another product although not as good as the other, is selling better
B: If the competitor is planning to update its device soon, its not really telling us why at the moment, there is a decrease in popularity of the new product as compared to the competitors product.
C: If the Marketing firm had failed to inform the public sufficiently then, the product wouldnt have sold well in the first place as in the passage it does mention that they did heavy marketing. 
 D:This is the one which provides a reason to believe. If the new device requires that owner purchase and download music in a unique form and it is incompatible with other forms, it can lead us to believe that it is becoming a hastle for customers, therefore the drop in sales of the new product in comparison to its competitor 
 E: The president being in talks to leave has no bearing on the sales.

A popular electronics company that is known for producing innovative

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

GMAT Critical Reasoning (CR) Questions

A popular electronics company that is known for producing innovative

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia