If x is an integer greater than 1, is y divisible by x?

Question

(1) y is divisible by x − 1
(2) y = x! + x − 1

Hatakekakashi · Answer

statement 1 - y mod x-1 = 0

y mod x can be =0 or != 0

i.e y=100 x=5 x-1 = 4 the answer is yes
 y = 27 x=10 x-1 = 9 the answer is no

so CBD

statement 1 is not sufficient

statement 2 - y = x! + x - 1

we know y mod x = 0 + 0 - 1

y= kx - 1 where k is any integer

so statement 2 is sufficient

(B) imo

rahulkashyap · Answer

if y=4 and x=2 and x-1 = 1, ans is yes
if y=5 and x=2 and x-1 = 1 , ans is no

x! and x are both divisble by x, but 1 is not divisible by x, as x>1

ans should be b

jch103020 · Answer

Here is my approach:

Stem: x is integer >1, is y/x an integer?

1) y is divisible by x-1 ---> y/(x-1) = integer

Insufficient: x = 4 --> y/3 = integer
 x = 3 --> y/2 = integer
 Both of these cases can't be true, thus (1) is insufficient

2) y=x!+x-1

x! = x(x-1)

y=x(x-1)+x-1
y=x^2-x+x-1
y=x^2-1
y=x(x-1)
y/(x-1)=x

Sufficient
----

Can anyone comment on my reasoning for deciding statement 1 is insufficient? I got the correct, answer, but want to be sure I didn't just get lucky with my reason for eliminating A

globaldesi · Answer

This problem rewards students who remember that all multiples of the integer x
 will be x
 units apart. Statement (1) gives that y
 is divisible by x−1
. This can be proven insufficient with a quick number picking thought experiment. If x=4
 is it possible to have a number that is divisible by both x=4
 and x−1=3
? If you multiply 3 and 4 together to get 12, the answer is yes, there are an infinite number of ways to have a value of y
 that is divisible by both x
 and x−1
.

Conversely, there are also an infinite number of integers that are divisible by x−1
 that aren't divisible by x
. In the case of x−1=3
, 6, 9, and 21 are all divisible by 3 but aren't divisible by 4. Since this means you can get both a "yes" and a "no" based on the information given in statement (1), statement (1) is insufficient. Eliminate (A) and (D).

Statement (2) gives that y=x!+x−1
. This may seem to give information similar to what is given in statement (1), but it is much more sufficient.

Remember that x!
 can be written as "(x)(x−1)(x−2)(x−3).....(2)(1)
".

This means that for any given value for x
 where x
 is an integer greater than 1, that x!
 must be divisible by x−1
 as well as x
.

If you add x−1
 to x!
, you get a number that is divisible by x−1
 but that cannot be divisible by x
. To understand this, it helps to pick numbers.

If x=4
, then x!=(4)(3)(2)=24
. If you add x−1=3
 to that, you get 27, which is still divisible by 3 but that isn't divisible by 4.

This is because multiples of the same number are evenly spaced - all multiples of 4 will be 4 apart, all multiples of 3 will be 3 apart, etc. So for whatever number you pick for x
, if you add x−1
 you will always get a number that is 1 less than a multiple of x
, which means that y
 can never be divisible by x
.

This means that statement (2) gives you a consistent "no" and is sufficient. Answer choice (B) is correct.

Mo2men · Answer

the question asks if  \frac{y}{x}  =Integer

(1) y is divisible by x − 1

Let x =2...then x-1 = 1........ \frac{y}{1}  =  y

If y odd..........answer is NO

If y even......... answer is Yes

Insufficient

(2) y = x! + x − 1

Divide both sides by x

\frac{y}{x} = \frac{x!}{x} + \frac{x}{x} − \frac{1}{x}

It is clear that every term will yield integer value except  \frac{1}{x} .......Answer is always NO

Sufficient

Another approach to plug-in values

Let x =2 .........y=3............Answer is NO

Let x= 3..........y=8...........Answer is NO

Let x = 4.........y=27..........Answer is NO

Let x= 5..........y =124........Answer is No

Answer: B

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If x is an integer greater than 1, is y divisible by x?

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

If x is an integer greater than 1, is y divisible by x?

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards