Machines X and Y work at their respective constant rates. How many mor

Question

Machines X and Y work at their respective constant rates. How many more hours does it take machine Y, working alone, to fill a production order of a certain size than it takes machine X, working alone?

Let \(x\) and \(y\) be the times needed for machines X and Y respectively working alone to fill a production order of this size.

Question: \(y-x=?\)

(1) Machines X and Y, working together, fill a production order of this size in 2/3 the time that machine X, working alone, does --> general relationship: \(\frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{y}=\frac{1}{total \ time}\) --> Total time needed for machines X and Y working together is \(total \ time=\frac{xy}{x+y}\) (general formula) --> given \(\frac{xy}{x+y}=x*\frac{2}{3}\) --> \(2x=y\). Not sufficient

(2) Machine Y, working alone, fills a production order of this size in twice the time that machine X, working alone, does --> \(2x=y\), the same info. Not sufficient

(1)+(2) Nothing new. Not Sufficient.

Answer: E.

Hope it helps.

P.S. Please post one question per topic. Also you can attach image files directly so no need to attach zip files.

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

Machines X and Y work at their respective constant rates. How many more hours does it take machine Y, working alone, to fill a production order of a certain size than it takes machine X, working alone?

Let  x  and  y  be the times needed for machines X and Y respectively working alone to fill a production order of this size.

Question:  y-x=?

(1) Machines X and Y, working together, fill a production order of this size in 2/3 the time that machine X, working alone, does --> general relationship:  \frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{y}=\frac{1}{total \ time}  --> Total time needed for machines X and Y working together is  total \ time=\frac{xy}{x+y}  (general formula) --> given  \frac{xy}{x+y}=x*\frac{2}{3}  -->  2x=y . Not sufficient

(2) Machine Y, working alone, fills a production order of this size in twice the time that machine X, working alone, does -->  2x=y , the same info. Not sufficient

(1)+(2) Nothing new. Not Sufficient.

Answer: E.

Hope it helps.

KarishmaB · Answer

In this question, I would like to discuss the use of logic.

Ques: How many more hours does it take machine Y than it does machine X.
So I am looking for a number like 2 hrs or something.
Neither of the statements gives me a number of hours for anything. Only relative time taken. So we can straight away say the answer is (E).

Also, how to deal with a statement like without getting into equations and variables: Machines X and Y, working together, fill an order in 2/3 the time that machine X, working alone, does.

Together, they take 2/3 the time taken by machine X. i.e. if machine X took 6 hrs, together they took 4 hrs. The 2 hrs were saved because machine Y was also working for those 4 hrs. In 4 hrs machine Y did what machine X would have done in 2 hrs. So time taken by machine Y alone will be twice the time taken by machine X alone.

Bunuel · Answer

Machines X and Y work at their respective constant rates. How many more hours does it take machine Y, working alone, to fill a production order of a certain size than it takes machine X, working alone?

Let  x  and  y  be the times needed for machines X and Y respectively working alone to fill a production order of this size.

Question:  y-x=?

(1) Machines X and Y, working together, fill a production order of this size in 2/3 the time that machine X, working alone, does --> general relationship:  \frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{y}=\frac{1}{total \ time}  --> Total time needed for machines X and Y working together is  total \ time=\frac{xy}{x+y}  (general formula) --> given  \frac{xy}{x+y}=x*\frac{2}{3}  -->  2x=y . Not sufficient

(2) Machine Y, working alone, fills a production order of this size in twice the time that machine X, working alone, does -->  2x=y , the same info. Not sufficient

(1)+(2) Nothing new. Not Sufficient.

Answer: E.

Hope it helps.

P.S. Please post one question per topic. Also you can attach image files directly so no need to attach zip files.

vigneshpandi · Answer

Pardon me if this is a stupid approach. but still I want to get it clarified.
From 1, as you said, \frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{y}=\frac{2x}{3}
threfore \frac{1}{y}=\frac{2x}{3}-\frac{1}{x}
this gives \frac{1}{y}=\frac{2x^2-3}{3x}
Now using the value y=2x, substitute in the above equation and u get 2x^2=\frac{9}{4}
hence x=\frac{3}{2}
with this we can even find y.
Hence answer is C.
What is wrong in this approach?

Bunuel · Answer

What you are basically saying is that you can solve 1 equation  \frac{xy}{x+y}=x*\frac{2}{3}  with 2 unknowns  x  and  y . Though it's not generally impossible (for example: 2x+y=y+4) this is not the case here.

Next, we have  total \ time=\frac{xy}{x+y}=x*\frac{2}{3}  and not  \frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{y}=\frac{2x}{3}  as you wrote (the calculation in red is not correct, it should be:  \frac{1}{x}+\frac{1}{y}=\frac{1}{total \ time}=\frac{1}{x*\frac{2}{3}}=\frac{3}{2x} ). So if you substitute  y  by  2x  in  total \ time=\frac{xy}{x+y}=x*\frac{2}{3}  (which by the way gives this relationship) you don't get the  x=\frac{3}{2} , you'll get  x*\frac{2}{3}=x*\frac{2}{3}  -->  \frac{2}{3}=\frac{2}{3}  as  x  will cancel out.

Hope it's clear.

calvin1984 · Answer

Just a question regarding this problem.
I choose E because I decided that there's no concrete value indicating the hours. The values they give from both statements indicate relative values. Is this a good approach or did I just get lucky?

Bunuel · Answer

No that's not correct. We have two exactly the same linear equations from both statements, that's why we cannot solve for x and y. But if we had two  distinct  linear equations then we would be able to solve.

For example if either of statement were:  the time needed for Machines X working alone to fill a production order of this size plus the time needed for Machines Y working alone to fill a production order of double the size is 10 hours  --> x+2y=10.

So, for (1)+(2) we would have x+2y=10 and 2x=y --> x=2 and y=4 --> y-x=2.

Generally if you have n  distinct  linear equations and n variables then you can solve for them. " Distinct  linear equations" means that no equation can be derived with the help of others or by arithmetic operation (multiplication, addition).

For example:
 x+y=2  and  3x+3y=6  --> we do have two linear equations and two variables but we cannot solve for  x  or  y  as the second equation is just the first one multiplied by 3 (basically we have only one distinct equation);
OR
 x+y=1 ,  y+z=2  and  x+2y+z=3  --> we have 3 linear equations and 3 variables but we cannot solve for  x ,  y  or  z  as the third equation can be derived with the help of first two if we sum them (basically we have only two distinct equation).

Hope it's clear.

A4G · Answer

Hi,

I am not understanding statement 1.
If x & Y are the rates respectively , then 1/X and 1/Y are the time taken to complete the task.
Shouldnt the equation be

1/X + 1/Y = 2/3X

It gives a degree 3 equation but I am not sure where I am going wrong in logic ?

KarishmaB · Answer

As Bunuel noted above, X is the  time taken  by machine X and Y is the  time taken  by machine Y. Combined time taken is 2X/3
Rates are 1/X and 1/Y which are additive. The combined rate is 3/2X
1/X + 1/Y = 3/2X

Also note that you are trying to add individual time taken in your equation. But times are not additive, only rates are additive. e.g. if you take 2 hrs to complete a work and I take 3 hrs, together will we take 5 hrs? I hope you understand that we will take less than 2 hrs for sure because you alone can complete it in 2 hrs. So times are NOT additive.

himanshujovi · Answer

Bunuel my thought process was that - No where in the question is the absolute time mentioned for any any machine so none of the 2 points are sufficent . hence E.

Bunuel · Answer

That's not entirely correct.

For example, if the first statement were:  machines X and Y, working together, fill a production order of this size in  1/2  the time that machine X, working alone, does , then this would be sufficient. Because in this case we would have x=y, and hence x-y=0.

Does this make sense?

sukanyar · Answer

Let us suppose that machine X takes x hours, while machine Y takes y hours, to fill production order. According to question, we have to find (y-x)

So, in 1 hour, X finishes 1/x while Y finishes 1/y production order

(1) says: Machines X and Y, working together, fill a production order of this size in two-thirds the time that machine X, working alone, does.

Working together, X and Y complete (1/x+1/y) production order in 1 hour

=> Working together, X and Y complete production order in 1/(1/x+1/y) hours

But, (1) says that 1/(1/x+1/y) = (2/3) x

Solving this, we get: y = 2x

So, clearly not sufficient for us to say what is (y – x)

(2) says that Machine Y, working alone, fills a production order of this size in twice the time that machine X, working alone, does.
=> y = 2x

So, clearly not sufficient for us to say what is (y – x)

Combining the two statements, again, both actually say the same thing (y=2x) and so, this is not sufficient for us to say what is (y – x).

Hence, E.

OptimusPrepJanielle · Answer

The rates of Machine X and Machine Y can be 1/A and 1/B, respectively. A and B represent the number of hours to complete the task. The question is asking for B-A. 
Statement 1 tells you that (1/B) + (1/A) = (2/3)(1/A). There are still 2 unknowns, so eliminate A, D.
Statement 2 tells you that (1/B) = (1/2A) or B=2A. Still, we have 2 unknowns. Eliminate B. 
No new information can be obtained by combining to the two statements. Therefore E is the answer.

iPen · Answer

If y = 2x, then I can't simply leave the answer as y - x = 2x - x = x?

That is, machine y takes x hours longer than x? It doesn't solve for the value of x, but isn't that technically an answer?

Or, does the GMAT require a value for x, since we're still left to wonder how many hours x is... e.g. x could be 1 hour or 10 hours, or so forth? So, even if you get an answer but there's still at least one variable in the answer, the data is missing and thus insufficient?

Bunuel · Answer

Official Guide:

In data sufficiency problems that ask for the value of a quantity, the data given in the statements are sufficient only when it is possible to determine  exactly one  numerical  value  for the quantity.

iPen · Answer

I did it a little differently.

\frac{1}{x} + \frac{1}{y} = \frac{1}{h}

\frac{y}{xy} + \frac{x}{xy} = \frac{1}{h} = \frac{y + x}{xy}

(1)  \frac{1}{2/3*x} = \frac{3}{2x} = \frac{y + x}{xy}

\frac{3}{2} = \frac{y + x}{y} ; 3y = 2(y + x); 3y = 2y + 2x; y = 2x

Two variables - we don't know the values of either x or y, so insufficient.

(2)  \frac{1}{y} = \frac{1}{2x} ; y = 2x

Again, two variables remain, so it's insufficient.

(1) + (2): Two different equations, same result of y = 2x

\frac{3}{2} = \frac{y + x}{y} 
 \frac{3}{2} = 2x + \frac{x}{2x} ; \frac{3}{2} = 2x + \frac{1}{}2 ;  2x = 1 ;  x =\frac{1}{2} 
 y = 2(\frac{1}{2}) = 1

Together, they finish a given job in 1/3 hours. 
Machine x does it in 1/2 hours.
Machine y does it in 1 hour.
y - x = 1/2 hours.

But, plugging the same y = 2x only gives us a relative difference. And, the three results above would need to be multiplied by a constant, because the equation holds true for any positive value of x (e.g. If x is 1, then y is 2, together it's 2/3, and y-x = 1). Thus, insufficient. Answer is E.

ZaydenBond · Answer

\frac{xy}{x+y}=x*\frac{2}{3}  -->  2x=y

Could you go through the bolded part and explain how you derived 2x=y? I am quite confused how you got rid of the x....

Bunuel · Answer

\frac{xy}{x+y}=\frac{2x}{3} ;

Cross-multiply:  3xy=2x(x+y) ;

3xy = 2x^2 + 2xy ;

xy = 2x^2 ;

Reduce by x:  y=2x .

Hope it's clear.

GMATinsight · Answer

ANswer: Option E

Machines X and Y work at their respective constant rates. How many mor

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

Machines X and Y work at their respective constant rates. How many mor

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards