According to anthropologists, the use of human language

Question

According to anthropologists, the use of human language covers a wide spectrum from  practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy  within a social group.

A) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy
B) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy
C) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishing of hierarchy
D) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to hierarchy established
E) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy

Carcass · Answer

communicating practically is unidiomatic so b and D out suddenly A C and E A to establishing hierarchy unidiomatic C the establishing of hierarchy idem E must be the answer . infact is correct

aditi1903 · Answer

IMO E
reasons highlighted in the quote above.
Parallelism issue with the statement. What is the Source?

nitzz · Answer

@carcass -you seem to be a native speaker

@aditi1903 - source is Manhattan GMAT prep(CAT exam question)

Carcass · Answer

No I'm not

the source was already indicated

sshivanis04 · Answer

According to anthropologists, the use of human language covers a wide spectrum from practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy within a social group.

A. practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy

B. communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy

C. practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishing of hierarchy

D. communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to hierarchy established

E. practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy

Meaning Analysis :

Anthropologists suggest that use of human language covers:

1. Practical communication b/w people engaged

2. Establishing hierarchy with in a social group

Error Analysis

1. There is one clause

a. Subject : The use & Verb : covers

b. Idiom usage : From X to Y , so X & Y should be parallel

c. X = Noun Phrase

i. Noun = Practical Communication

ii. Engaged is verb-ed modifier

d. Y = Noun Phrase ( Gerund/Verb ing)

i. Noun= ‘Establishing’ Hierarchy

Problem : I don’t understand why answer choice is incorrect.

d3goldnews · Answer

We will get a DK on the envy ah. At present in this map I found a white day-to-day stands in the middle of a good map to find. Comparison of this mission nausea, is one of five mission four small mission must have in order to make the mission the first five pay, NPC allows you to find four of their respective mandates captain to come back: to the U.S.

LoneSurvivor · Answer

Although I have marked correctly but I have question to Experts,

1. Practical communication must be  among  People right ?
2. Two task must be parallel right ? From-----to  the  /  From------to-----  ?

E has the above mentioned concerns please let me know if I am wrong.

According to anthropologists, the use of human language covers a wide spectrum from practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy within a social group.

A) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy
B) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy
C) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishing of hierarchy
D) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to hierarchy established
E) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy

AjiteshArun · Answer

Luckily, this question does not force us to choose between between and among here.

However, this is one of those cases in which a between is acceptable, because we're interested in smaller groups within people . ... communication among people engaged in the same task... This makes it sound as if there is a large group of people discussing something among themselves (as a group). ... communication between people engaged in the same task... This makes it sound as if there are smaller conversations between members of a larger group. As for from... to... , the the is important only if the noun requires it. Otherwise, it has absolutely no significance. For example: From the government to you ...

LoneSurvivor · Answer

Thank you so much,your explanations are lucid.

dcummins · Answer

Official Explanation
  The original sentence contains the construction "from X to Y," which requires parallelism between X and Y. In this case, X is the regular noun phrase "practical communication," but Y is the gerund "establishing". (A gerund is an "-ing" form of a verb acting as a noun, such as in the sentence "Swimming is fun.")

We need to find a choice that puts both X and Y in the same grammatical form. Note that the difference between "people engaged in the same task" and "people engaging in the same task" is minimal.

Both forms are valid. 
(A) This choice is incorrect as it repeats the original sentence. 
(B) This answer choice changes X to a gerund and Y to a regular noun phrase. X and Y are still not parallel. 
(C) Adding the word "the" in front of Y here doesn't change the fact that the regular noun phrase is not parallel to the gerund. 
(D) This answer choice changes X to a gerund but Y to "hierarchy established," which is not parallel to X. 
(E) CORRECT. This choice correctly changes Y to a regular noun phrase "the establishment of hierarchy," so that this phrase is now parallel to X, "practical communication." It is not necessary that both phrases have the article "the."

SingaravelChocks · Answer

establishment of hierarchy is correct idiomatic.

PrafulLata · Answer

According to anthropologists, the use of human language covers a wide spectrum from  practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy  within a social group.

A) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy.  WRONG : two construction,"From...X... To...Y.." should be parallel which is absent in this option.
B) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy.  WRONG : As same explanation as that of option A
C) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishing of hierarchy.  WRONG : As same explanation as that of option A
D) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to hierarchy established.  WRONG : As same explanation as that of option A
E) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy.  CORRECT .

tt147 · Answer

GMATNinja ,  GMATNinjaTwo ,  mikemcgarry ,  VeritasKarishma

I agree with the explanations for eliminating B and D. But can we eliminate B and D because of the phrase - "between people engaging in the same task" ?
If yes, then is it because "engaging" here signifies people who are now engaging ?

KarishmaB · Answer

We are looking for the range covered by "the use of human language". So we will use nouns in lieu of 'the use'. Hence, 'communication' and 'establishment' are correct. That is why (B) and (D) are not correct.

'People engaging in the same task' does not represent present continuous, if that is what you mean. 'engaging' is used as a present participle modifier. It does not act as a verb so does not represent a tense. To act as a verb, it needs a helping verb such as "are engaging" or "were engaging" etc.

nivivacious · Answer

This may look difficult but it actually isn't if you eliminate options.
Communicating practically makes no sense in this sentence, so lets eliminate B and D
 B) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy
D) communicating practically between people engaging in the same task to hierarchy established

Now we're left with:
A) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to establishing hierarchy
C) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishing of hierarchy
E) practical communication between people engaged in the same task to the establishment of hierarchy

Establishing of is idiomatically wrong so lets eliminate C
E>A keeping in mind parallelism - so lets go with E.. which is the right answer.

According to anthropologists, the use of human language

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

According to anthropologists, the use of human language

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards