Despite starting this thread, as a R1er that is now facing a deposit deadline I am actually in this situation. Currently, with no money from Kellogg or NYU, I know I would choose Kellogg. However, Consortium money from NYU could definitely change my mind.
At this point I know I don't want to risk losing Kellogg if I don't get any money from NYU. So I'm going to put the $2,500 deposit down. It's due February 28th. If NYU gives me a scholarship, then I now have something else to weigh: present value of $2,500 v. the future value of job opportunities and less loans. But if they don't, I know I'll be happy and very thankful that I took the risk and put the money down.
Angelfire, you don't have to worry. All your deposit deadlines should be after the "Consortium draft" is complete.
Posted from my mobile device