In Region R in a South American country, farmers grow landrace and

Question

ᅠᅠIn Region R in a South American country, farmers grow landrace and commercial bean varieties. Landrace beans are beans that descend from generations of indigenous domestication, and commercial beans are beans that are produced and distributed by large commercial vendors that originated and currently operate in the South American country. There are numerous varieties of both types. These two types of beans have advantages and disadvantages, which are widely known among all the farmers in Region R.

The advantages of landrace beans are:

• There are more varieties of landrace beans than commercial varieties, and this increase in biodiversity affords landrace varieties greater protection against disease.

• Landrace varieties are hearty. As a result, they grow better and have higher yields in adverse farming conditions—for example, in areas without irrigation, in rocky soil, or on steep hillsides—than do commercial varieties.

• Landrace varieties require less capital than do commercial varieties to grow a crop, since landrace seeds may be planted from the previous year's crop. By contrast, it violates patent laws for farmers to obtain, keep, or profit from the commercial seeds produced by the previous year's crop.

Bismuth83 · Accepted Answer

Question 2 Part 2 and 3 ask about: "Of those farms that grew only landrace beans, greater than 50% had beans planted on nonirrigated/irrigated land".

In theory, one of them should be true and the other should be false, since if one is <50% then the other is >50%. However, we are to   "select Yes if the statement accurately reflects the information in the tabs"  . There is   no information that could tell us the answer  . So, both of them are a  "No" .

Hope that answered your question!

Sidak02 · Answer

can anyone please explain the answers of it

sachi-in · Answer

1. Which one of the following statements about growing beans in Region R is most strongly supported by the information provided in the tabs?

Of the 60 farms, 95% of them had a higher yield from commercial beans than from landrace beans over the period in question.

This option is tricky: 95% of land (34.1 hectare = commercial but irrigated) had better yields than 5%(2 hectare = non-commercial but irrigated) of land.
But we don't know if 95% farms had the same statistics ( that is possible only when land is divided proportionally between farms)

Hence this option isn't correct.

Growing bean varieties that farmers frequently sell on international markets may require more capital than would growing varieties that sell less frequently.  
seeds cost more
irrigation cost
fertilizer cost
so yes the passage indirectly indicates commercials are capital intensive

Correct

Farmers that plant only landrace varieties do so primarily to be legally able to plant seeds from their own crops.

It's one reason ( may not be primary )

Farmers who want to maximize their yields will, without exception, plant commercial bean varieties.

No some may prefer non-commercials in unirrigated terrains

The information in the tabs defends the view that the advantages of one type of bean significantly outweigh the advantages of the other.

No there is no such conclusions

2. For each of the following statements about Region R during the growing season represented in the two tables, select Yes if the statement accurately reflects the information in the tabs. Otherwise, select No.

For the area with landrace beans planted on it, greater than 65% of it is nonirrigated Table 2 ( nonirrigated / total = 70%) - Yes
Of those farms that grew only landrace beans, greater than 50% had beans planted on irrigated land - No
Of those farms that grew only landrace beans, greater than 50% had beans planted on nonirrigated land. - No

Because there is no statistics about no.of farms that have irrigation and those that doesn't have.

3. For each of the following statements, select Yes if the statement is supported by the information provided in the tabs. Otherwise, select No.

Generally, bean farmers in Region R assign the greatest value to protecting their bean crop against disease. - We don't know which advantage is more important - No

Some bean farmers in Region R grow their bean crops in adverse farming conditions. - Some do (table 2) - adverse conditions - no irrigation - Yes

Bean farmers in Region R would violate a law if they planted commercial seeds obtained from the previous year's crop. - It is mentioned that commercial seeds can't be replanted cuz of copyright - Yes

divyasaxena2825 · Answer

I did not understand your explanation to the question- ''Some bean farmers in Region R grow their bean crops in adverse farming conditions. - Some do (table 2) - adverse conditions - no irrigation - Yes''
There is nothing mentioned in table 2 regarding adverse conditions. Please could you add more details?

vaishmahe · Answer

In the passage about landbeans - examples of adverse condition are mentioned - non availability of irrigation is one of them. As the tables have data pertaining to crops being raised on non-irrigated land, we can conclude some of the farmers are growing bean crop in adverse condition.

shriyaapathi · Answer

For the second question , the third sub question asked why is the answer a no?

Ghoskrp3 · Answer

1. Which one of the following statements about growing beans in Region R is most strongly supported by the information provided in the tabs?

A. Of the 60 farms, 95% of them had a higher yield from commercial beans than from landrace beans over the period in question. -  There is no info. at all pertaining to the yield/output/production shared in the tables or other tabs (It says, "In good farming conditions, commercial varieties tend to produce higher yields than landrace varieties", but left to us to speculate)

B. Growing bean varieties that farmers frequently sell on international markets may require more capital than would growing varieties that sell less frequently.   -Conclusive! by combination of data from tab1 & tab2 ( Tab1:  It says, " Landrace varieties require less capital than do commercial varieties to grow a crop, since landrace seeds may be planted from the previous year's crop"  + Tab2:  It says, "Farmers sell commercial bean varieties more frequently on both regional and international markets.") 
 
C. Farmers that plant only landrace varieties do so primarily to be legally able to plant seeds from their own crops.   - Somewhat true but , surely this is an extreme option, using the words "only" & "Primarily", so should be avoided

D. Farmers who want to maximize their yields will, without exception, plant commercial bean varieties. -    Definitely No! , Maximum Yield with commercial bean?, they are not hearty to withstand harsh weather and land conditions and also require to be irrigated.

E. The information in the tabs defends the view that the advantages of one type of bean significantly outweigh the advantages of the other.   -I felt this too in tab1 but tab 2 also introduced points to balance out the biasness and the tables showing the farm spread also sorts this confusion, hence "slightly outweighs" would be a better term to saying "significantly outweighs"

2. For each of the following statements about Region R during the growing season represented in the two tables, select  Yes  if the statement accurately reflects the information in the tabs. Otherwise, select  No .

A. For the area with landrace beans planted on it, greater than 65% of it is nonirrigated-    Yes!,  70% of the land is unirrigated (data present in table 2)

B. Of those farms that grew only landrace beans, greater than 50% had beans planted on irrigated land.  -  Not Sure , There are in total of 0.6+6.1 = 6.7 hectares of landrace crop, of which  "only landrace"  is 0.6 hectares and table 2 says, 2 hectares of landrace crop is Irrigated and 4.7 hectares of landrace is unirrigated, but still hard to tell which is which, where is our only 0.6 hectares part of landrace growing crop actually present in these parts.

C. Of those farms that grew only landrace beans, greater than 50% had beans planted on nonirrigated land.   -  Again Not Sure , same issue as above

3. For each of the following statements, select  Yes  if the statement is supported by the information provided in the tabs. Otherwise, select  No .

A. Generally, bean farmers in Region R assign the greatest value to protecting their bean crop against disease.   -    No!,    Data not given in any of the tabs on this

B. Some bean farmers in Region R grow their bean crops in adverse farming conditions.   - Yes! , In tab 1 it says " Landrace varieties are hearty. As a result, they grow better and have higher yields in adverse farming conditions—for example, in areas without irrigation, in rocky soil, or on steep hillsides—than do commercial varieties". Hence, "non irrigation" area qualifies as an adverse farming condition and by data in table 2 36% of the land is unirrigated which can be referred as "some farmers"

C. Bean farmers in Region R would violate a law if they planted commercial seeds obtained from the previous year's crop.   - Yes! , shared in tab1: "By contrast, it violates patent laws for farmers to obtain, keep, or profit from the commercial seeds produced by the previous year's crop."

RahulGrover21 · Answer

For question 3, Bean farmers in Region R would violate a law if they planted commercial seeds obtained from the previous year's crop, shouldn't the answer be No. Since this is applicable to Landrace beans and only mentioned in that tab. Had it been Landrace beans mentioned in the statement, wouldn't it be yes in that case?

Ghoskrp3 · Answer

Nope!, the answer would still be "Yes", irrespective of which tab the data is shared, as the data shared talks particularly about violation of patent laws, if commercial seeds produced by the previous year's crop

As shared in tab1: "By contrast, it violates patent laws for farmers to obtain, keep, or profit from the commercial seeds produced by the previous year's crop."

abcd1234!! · Answer

For Q1, 95% of 60 farms is 57, but from first table, farms growing commercial only and commercial + landrace is total 55(35+20). Hence it can never be that 57 farms or 95% of farms had better yield from commercial.

Ghoskrp3 · Answer

Nope! it says, " Of the 60 farms, 95% of them had a higher yield from commercial beans than from landrace beans", means 95% of these farms vs 95% of those farms:

=> Yield from 95% of Commercial bean farms > Yield from 95% of landrace bean farms
=> Yield from 95% (35+x) farms > Yield from 95% of (5+y) farms, (where x+y = 20)

So, there are still 2 factors we need first to be able to definitely conclude: First is,  yield (for which we have no data; out of 10 farms did all 10 produced effectively or only 2 farms produced effectively), Second, in the farms where commercial and landrace beans are planted together what portion of farms do they beans occupy each

Therefore, Answer is Niether Yes, Nor a definite No (as you tried to conclude), but will be,   "Can't Be Determined".

abcd1234!! · Answer

Yes that's what I had thought at first, that 95% of farms growing commercial, landrace or both had a higher yield from commercial than from landrace. But then 95% of 60 farms thought struck me and I thought I had found a simple loophole. For your second point it is mentioned in the Data tab table that planted together they each occupy how much land or am I missing something?

Ghoskrp3 · Answer

2 things, I want to understand:

1. Are you trying to prove that that since, of 57 farms or 95% of farms' yield can never be ever from Commercial so the answer should be "Option A"

2. What about the yield? (how are you factoring that?, 10 farms can yield nothing for all I know or out of 10 farms only 3 farms yield or 2 farms yield, how to conclusively prove it?)

Either way I see the argument inconclusive and rest my case ...

In Region R in a South American country, farmers grow landrace and

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

Yes	No
		For the area with landrace beans planted on it, greater than 65% of it is nonirrigated
		Of those farms that grew only landrace beans, greater than 50% had beans planted on irrigated land.
		Of those farms that grew only landrace beans, greater than 50% had beans planted on nonirrigated land.

GMAT Multi-Source Reasoning (MSR) Questions

In Region R in a South American country, farmers grow landrace and

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards