CadTec
Dear GMAT Assassins,
unfortunately I have a problem with the following Assumption-Q.:
While e-reading is more convenient by far, it has drawbacks: you can have books purloined by publishers and vendors over legal squabbles, the battery can die, and you need to turn your e-reader off for airplane takeoffs and landings. Regardless of how pervasive technology becomes in our literary lives, people will forever long for the tactile experience of reading a tangible book - bought from a tangible store. Therefore, online stores and e-books do not pose a threat to independent bookstores or larger chains.
(A) No larger book store chain will go out of business in the foreseeable future
(B) Independent bookstores should become better positioned to compete with larger chains and online stores
(C) A representative consumer factors in the tactile sensation of a book in the decision process to purchase that book
(D) Online stores and e-books will continue to grow in popularity
(E) The subject matter of a book is the deciding factor in the decision to own that book
Boil it down:
online stores and e-books are no threat to independent bookstores or larger chains because people will forever long for the tactile experience
--> Assumption: (B), (D) and (E) are the 3 easy outs.
If I make the negative test on (A) A larger bookstore chain will go out of business in the foreseeable future --> In my opinion the argument is destroyed, hence (A) is the correct answer.
(C) is for me as a non-native not really understandable....
I hope you can help me with that issue.
Kindest regards,
CadTec
Hi,
Although
Vyshak has already given you few reasons, let me pitch in with my two cents-
two reasons WHY A should not be the answer-
1) NO larger book store chain--
NO here makes it too extreme and more than often it is good ground to eliminate the choice2)
Is it a assumption at all - NO. It is more like an inference or some kind of conclusion or something flowing out of the argument..
Remember assumption is something which connects the premise and conclusion
Now two reasons WHY C should be the answer-
1)
simple, no better choice.2) I can understand that many of us will not understand pervasive, tangible, tactile, purloined and I really doubt that real GMAT will make it a TEST of your VOCABULARY rather than CRITICAL REASONING.
But still if you get such a Q somewhere else also,
what should strike you is the word tactile as it also has been used in the main PARA. so the two sentences which should help you in this is --
PARA - people will forever long for the tactile experience of reading a tangible book..
CHOICE - A representative consumer factors in the tactile sensation of a book in the decision process to purchase that bookAdd the two and you will get your answer irrespective of WHAT tactile means..