jessello
Here is the question:What fraction of seven lettered words formed using the letters of the words CLASSIC will have the two C's always together?
A) 2/7
B) 5/7
C) 15/19
D) 4/19
E) 2/8
Why do we cancel out the two S's and C's? Surely they are separate letters and must be treated as such? I thought the answer was to treat the two C's as one thing and then: 6!/7! = 1/7. I know I am wrong, but don't understand why. First, if you post in the correct forum you have a chance of better response to your query. In this case: quant P.S.
I'll go ahead and explain:
let us start by an easier example: arrange ILL. so according to the formula you read it should be 3!/2! (because L is repeated twice) and according to you it should be 3! (because the two Ls are separate identities)
cases:
ILL
LIL
LLI
That is all the cases you can make (which is 3!/2! and not 3!)
So why do we divide by 2! when a letter is repeated twice?
basically to negate the double counting of words: if 2 Ls were separate identities L(1)L(2)I and L(2)L(1)I would be two separate words. But they are not. At the end of the day they are just LLI - 1 word. You cannot differentiate between the two Ls when they are together.
Now Why 2! and why not just 2.
Notice that you may arrange LL in two places in 2! ways (and thus by that factor the words will duplicate). 2!=2 so you won't find trouble here. But if the word were MMMI then it would have been 4!/3! and not 4!/3. Because you may arrange MMM in 3! ways.
Makes sense?
You can extend this logic to any number of letters.