Bunuel
12 Days of Christmas 2024 - 2025 Competition with $40,000 of PrizesA business exports 2 products, A and B. If 300 total units of these 2 products were exported yesterday, what fraction of the product B units were exported to Country X?
(1) Half of the units exported yesterday were product A, and one-third of the units exported yesterday were exported to countries other than Country X.
(2) Yesterday, there were twice as many units of product A exported to Country X as there were units of B exported to other countries.
Manhattan Prep Official Explanation:
This Data Sufficiency problem is testing
Overlapping Sets: each of the 300 units is either Type A or Type B, and each is either exported to Country X or exported elsewhere. Set up a
Double-Set Matrix to track what you know:
| A | B | Total |
| X | | | |
| Other | | | |
| Total | | | 300 |
The question stem asks for the ratio of the number of units of product B exported to Country X to the total number of units of product B.
Statement (1): INSUFFICIENT. This allows you to fill in all of the Totals as follows:
| A | B | Total |
| X | | | 200 |
| Other | | | 100 |
| Total | 150 | 150 | 300 |
In particular, there were 150 total units of product B. However, the four cells in the upper left remain unknown, so you cannot solve for the number of units of B exported to Country X.
Statement (2): INSUFFICIENCT. This establishes a 2:1 ratio between two of the cells in the matrix, which can be represented using the
Unknown Multiplier:
| A | B | Total |
| X | 2x | | |
| Other | | x | |
| Total | | | 300 |
However, without more information, the ratio asked for in the question stem cannot be determined.
Statements (1) and (2) together: SUFFICIENT. Combining the information from the two tables above yields:
| A | B | Total |
| X | 2x | | 200 |
| Other | | x | 100 |
| Total | 150 | 150 | 300 |
There were 150 –
x units of product B exported to Country X and the top row creates an equation that can be solved for
x:
2
x + (150 –
x) = 200
x + 150 = 200
x = 50
Therefore 150 – 50 = 100 units of the 150 total units of product B were exported to Country X and the desired ratio is 2⁄3.
The correct answer is (C): Both statements together are sufficient, but neither statement alone is sufficient.